J. C. Ryle · Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: St. John, Vol. I
John 21
57 excerpts on John 21, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
JOHN XXI. 1—14.
We should observe, for one thing, in these verses, the poverty of the first disciples of Christ. We find them working with their own hands, in order to supply their temporal wants, and working at one of the humblest of callings, — the calling of a fisherman. Silver and gold they had none, lands and revenues they had none, and therefore they were not ashamed to return to the business to which they had, most of them, been trained. Striking is the fact, that some of the seven here named were fishing, when our Lord first called them to be Apostles, and again fishing, when He appeared to them almost the last time. We need not doubt that to the minds of Peter, James, and John, the coincidence would come home with peculiar power.
John 21:1–14 · Open Word Bible
1After this Jesus revealed Himself to the disciples once more, by the Sea of Tiberias. It happened in this way. 2Simon Peter was there with Thomas (called Didymus, which means Twin), Nathanael from Cana in Galilee, Zebedee's sons, and two more of His disciples. 3Simon Peter said to them, "I am going out fishing." They answered, "We will come with you." They went out and got into the boat, but all that night they caught nothing. …
After these things
This expression is indefinite. It only means that the appearance of our Lord, about to be described in this chapter, took place " after" His appearance on the eighth day following His resurrection. The time therefore, in the verse before us, is some day between the eighth and the fortieth day, when He ascended up into heaven. But what precise day we cannot tell. One thing at any rate we may be sure of. It was not the Sabbath day, or else the disciples would not have gone fishing. Even on the day following the crucifixion, Christ's disciples " rested according to the commandment." (Luke xxiii. 56.)
[Jesus showed Himself again.. .disciples.] A deep question naturally rises out of the expression before us. Where was our Lord on the days when He did not " manifest or show Himself" to His disciples? It is evident that He was not with them always, and that He only visited them at intervals. Where was He then in the mean time ? — Not in heaven, we may be sure, because He had not yet ascended. But where was He on earth ? I speak of course of His human nature. As God, He is everywhere. But where was He, as a man? This is a mysterious matter, and one about which it is useless to speculate. Enough for us to know that our Lord was visible, or invisible, and appeared suddenly in one place or another place, and assumed one form or another form, at His own will, after a manner that we cannot understand. But it is quite plain that, when we read the words in Acts, " being seen of them forty days " (Acts i. o), we must not suppose them to mean that our Lord was seen every day. It only means that during forty days He was seen at intervals. Each appearance, we doubt not, had its own special purpose and intention.
John 21:1 · Open Word Bible
1After this Jesus revealed Himself to the disciples once more, by the Sea of Tiberias. It happened in this way.
Chrysostom remarks, " It is clear from the words ' showed Himself,' that Christ was not seen (after His resurrection) unless He condescended, because His body was henceforth incorruptible, and of unmixed purity."
[At the Sea of Tiberias.] Concerning this remarkable piece of water, sometimes called the Lake of Gennesaret, and sometimes the Sea of Galilee, I have already said something in my note on John vi. 1. (Vol. 1, " Expository Thoughts on John," p. 329.) It is a fresh-water lake, through which the river Jordan runs, twelve and a half miles long and six and three-quarters broad, and remarkable in a geological point of view, as being six hundred and fifty-five feet below the level of the Mediterranean Sea.* In a theological point of view it must always be most interesting to a Christian, because some of our Lord's mightiest miracles were wrought on it, or close to it.
* I give the above measurements from Tristram's " Topography of the Holy Land," as I believe they are more trustworthy than those which I gave in the first volume of this work.
Here our Lord walked on the waters, and came to the disciples toiling in rowing. Here He stilled the wind and waves with a word. Here He granted to four of His Apostles a miraculous draught of fishes. Here He provided payment of the tribatemoney, out of the mouth of a fish which He commanded Peter to catch. On the banks of this lake He fed a multitude with a few loaves and fishes. On a high ground overhanging this lake He cast out the legion of devils, and allowed them to drive 2,000 swine into the sea. In the towns upon this lake, Chorazin, Bethsaida, and Capernaum, He did some of His mightiest works. Sitting in a boat on this lake. He delivered the parable of the Sower. In short, of all the districts in which our Lord preached and wrought miracles, there was none which saw and heard so much as the district round " the Sea of Tiberias."
Can we doubt, when we remember all this, that our Lord had a deep purpose and meaning, in appearing to His disciples at the Sea of Tiberias ? Can we doubt that He meant to remind them of all they had seen in former days of his wisdom, love, and power, by the side of these well-known waters ? He knew well the influence which scenery and places exercise over the mind of man. He would recall to the memory of His disciples all that they had witnessed in the early days of His ministry. Above all He would stir the hearts of Peter and James and John, by saying some of His last things to them, at the very place where He had first called them to leave their boats and nets, to follow Him, and to become fishers of men. Where He had begun with them, there He would have one of His last interviews with them, before leaving the world.
2.—[There were together Simon Peter, etc.] This verse contains the names of the seven witnesses, before whom the remarkable appearance of Christ, about to be described, took place. Seven, we may remember, is the number of perfection, and the evidence of seven witnesses was regarded as the most complete evidence that could be given. Two of the seven, we shall observe, are not named, and we are left entirely to conjecture who these two were. Most commentators think they must have been Andrew and Philip, — Andrew because he was Peter's brother, and Philip because he was an inhabitant of Bethsaida, on the lake. But we really do not know, and it is useless to guess.
Why these seven alone, out of the eleven, were here, we are not told. But we need not doubt there was good reason. All the company of the Apostles, we may believe, went into Galilee when the passover feast was over, according to our Lord's command, and probably very soon after His appearance for the benefit of Thomas. But where Matthew, Simon, James the less, and Jude, were, on the present occasion, we do not know.
It is worth noting that this is the only place in St. John's Gospel, where he mentions the name of his own father, Zebedee.
Why these seven disciples in particular were together, is worth inquiry. The presence of Simon Peter, as he lived in Galilee, and had a special message from our Lord that He was going into Galilee, we can understand. Thomas, once convinced that Jesus had risen, would very likely take care to stick close to Peter and John. Nathanael lived at Cana in Galilee, and was probably Bartholomew. Augustine, however, doubts this. The two sons of Zebedee were Simon's partners, and are always found together with him on great occasions.
John 21:2 · Open Word Bible
2Simon Peter was there with Thomas (called Didymus, which means Twin), Nathanael from Cana in Galilee, Zebedee's sons, and two more of His disciples.
The message of our Lord about Galilee, we must remember, was, " Tell my brethren that they go into Galilee : there shall they see Me." (Matt, xxviii. 10.) These were our Lord's own words. — The angel also said to the women, " He goeth before you into Galilee : there shall ye see Him." (Matt, xxviii. 7.) We might reasonably expect to find the Apostles in Galilee after this.
On Thomas being one of the party, Henry remarks, " Thomas is named next to Peter, as if he now kept closer to the meetings of the Apostles than ever. It is well if losses by our neglect make us more careful afterwards not to let opportunities slip."
Simon Peter saith unto them, &c.
Some worthy commentators have presumed to find fault with Peter for going a fishing. They say that he showed a disposition to return to the world, and to follow his worldly calling once more. From this view I entirely dissent. I see no harm whatever in Peter's conduct on this occasion. He and his companions were poor men, and must needs work in order to provide for their subsistence. There was nothing wrong in the act of fishing, and it was only natural to take up the business with which they were most familiar. The great business of going out as our Lord's messengers, to preach the Gospel, was not to begin until His ascension, and in the interval it was better to follow an honest calling than to be idle. Neither in Peter's proposal, nor in the simple frank consent of his companions, can I detect a jot of proof that anything wrong was done. Idleness does Christians far more injury than work. Among the Jews every man, whatever his rank or position might be, was required to learn a worldly calling.
Chrysostom remarks, " Since neither Christ was with them continually, nor was the Spirit yet given, nor they at that time entrusted with anything, having nothing to do, they went after their trade."
Augustine observes, " The Apostles were not forbidden to seek their necessary subsistence by the exercise of their craft, a lawful and permitted one, if at any time they had no other means of subsistence." He also remarks that they were no more to blame than St. Paul was, when he wrought with his own hands as a tent-maker, (Acts xviii. 3.)
John 21:3 · Open Word Bible
3Simon Peter said to them, "I am going out fishing." They answered, "We will come with you." They went out and got into the boat, but all that night they caught nothing.
Calvin remarks, " Peter had not yet been enjoined to appear in public, for the discharge of his office of teaching, but had only been reminded of his future calling (John xx, 21 — 23), that he and others might understand that they had not in vain been chosen from the beginning. Meanwhile, they were to do what they were accustomed to do, and what belonged to men in private life."
Ferus remarks that a lawful business is not sinful. If Matthew had gone back to a publican's life it would have been a very different thing from Peter going to fish.
Stier remarks that this going to fish was only carrying out our Lord's words. " But now, he that hath a purse, let him take it, and likewise his scrip : and he that hath no sword, let him sell his garment and buy one." (Luke xxii. 36.)
The expression " a boat " should have been translated " the boat." Does not the use of the article show that this was that well-known boat, which our Lord and His disciples had always used, when they went on the lake ?
In the fact that " they caught nothing that night," there is nothing that would surprise a fisherman. Of all callings by which men earn their living none is more uncertain than that of a fisherman. (Luke v. 4.) " Night " is the time when most fish are caught, as all who are familiar with fishing know. That there was probably a deep typical meaning in all this, I shall hope to show when I reach the end of the passage. I think it better to reserve all remarks upon that point, until I can present them to the reader in one continuous form.— For the present, both here and throughout the passage, I shall simply comment on the facts as facts.
Burgon remarks, " One thing is certain, and the circumstance is full of interest. It must have been their necessities which sent forth the Apostles on this lowly errand of fishing. And yet these were they on whom the Church was to be built 1 These seven were among the names written on the twelve foundations of the heavenly Jerusalem."
Burgon also thinks that the words " went forth," point to the Apostles sitting together indoors, in the evening, and very likely on a Sabbath evening.
But when the morning...come
This probably means " When the day began to break, so that an object at a little distance could be seen." As soon as there was enough light, through the grey dawn, the party in the boat saw the figure of a person on the shore. There is little or no twilight in countries so far south as Palestine. Night goes, and day follows, much more suddenly than with us.
[Jesus stood on the shore.] This reads like a sudden and instantaneous appearance, like that which took place when our Lord appeared the first time in the midst of the disciples. Just in the same manner, it seems to me, in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, Jesus appeared standing on the shore of the lake. The risen body of our Lord, we must remember, appeared or disappeared, — was present or absent, according to His will, in a moment of time.
Grotius remarks that our Lord never went on the sea after His resurrection. (Comp. Rev. xxi. 1.) " There was no more sea."
John 21:4 · Open Word Bible
4Just as day was breaking, Jesus stood on the shore, though the disciples did not realize that it was Jesus.
but the disciples knew not...was Jesus
The disciples did not recognize our Lord, in my opinion, because He appeared in another form, just as He appeared to the two who were journeying to Emmaus. I reject entirely the idea that the dim light of the early morning was the reason why they did not know Him. It is evident to me that our Lord's risen body did not, on any occasion, after He rose again, for some mysterious reason, look exactly like the body He had before His crucifixion. It - — was the same, and yet not the same, if I may so speak. Will it not be so with our own bodies when we rise again at the last day ? We shall be the same, and yet not the same.
It is noteworthy that the Greek words here used, were exactly those that were used about Mary Magdalene, when she thought the gardener spoke to her", and " knew not that it was Jesus." (John xx. 14.)
Then Jesus saith unto them, &c.
We cannot suppose for a moment, that our Lord did not know whether the disciples had any meat, when He asked the question of this verse. It is clear to me that He asked it in order to raise attention in the minds of the disciples, and to put them at ease in conversing with them. He appeared as a stranger, who was graciously pleased to say something familiar and friendly. Does it not remind us of the way in which He began conversation with the woman of Samaria, and broke the ice, as it were, between Him and her ? " Give Me to drink," He said. (John iv. 7.) Nothing sets people so much at ease, when they meet as strangers, as courteous inquiries about the simple matters of daily life.
The word " meat " is a striking example of the change which comes over the meaning of English words in the course of time. It means literally " anything eatable." — Two centuries ago the word " meat " was a translation which no Englishman would misunderstand. Now, unfortunately, it is a word confined entirely to " flesh." No translation can ever be perfect. All require occasional reverent revision.
The context seems to me to show that our Lord's inquiry was specially meant to apply to the success of the disciples in fishing. " Have ye caught anything that can be eaten ? " The disciples evidently took it in this sense.
John 21:5 · Open Word Bible
5So Jesus called out to them, "Friends, you have no fish to eat, have you?" They answered Him, "No."
It is worth noticing that our Lord must have spoken in a very loud voice, when He addressed His disciples in this verse. We are distinctly told that the boat was two hundred cubits, at least one hundred yards, from land, in the eighth verse, and there is nothing to show that the disciples put out further into the lake, when our Lord told them to cast in their net again. I mention this, because some, as Gerhard, Henry, and Besser, think that there was something curt, rough, and rather abrupt in the answer of the disciples. But they seem to forget that a conversation carried on over a hundred yards of water, could only be carried on in very brief and abrupt phrases.
The word " children " in this verse, rendered " sirs " in the margin, is to my mind rightly rendered in the text. It is a familiar, friendly mode of address, like our English " boys " or " lads," not necessarily implying great youth in the persons addressed.
And he said...Cast...right side...find
Our Lord now goes a step further in order to discover Himself to His disciples. He gives a command or counsel to cast their net, which they had apparently hauled into the boat, once more into the water, and upon the right side of the ship. Such advice, and such a promise of success from a stranger, could hardly fail to strike the disciples. Would it not raise in the quick mind of John a suspicion, that this was no common stranger who spoke ? Would not he and Peter both remember a former occasion, when they " toiled all the night and took nothing," and yet, at the command of their Master, had let down their nets again with marvellous success ? I think they would.
To me it seems highly probable that the disciples had finished their night's work, had hauled up their net into the boat, and were rowing toward home, tired of their profitless toil, when our Lord appeared and spoke to them.
John 21:6 · Open Word Bible
6He said to them, "Throw the net out on the boat's right side, and you will find fish." So they threw it out, and now they could not haul it in because there were so many fish.
They cast therefore, and now...fishes
In the fact that the disciples found a multitude of fishes in their net the moment they acted on our Lord's advice, there is, in one point of view, nothing extraordinary. Many fish swim in shoals, and it is quite a matter of common experience among fishermen, that one boat may take nothing, while a few yards off another boat has an immense haul. The miracle consisted in the perfect knowledge that our Lord possessed, as to where the fish were, and on which side of the boat to cast the net. This alone proved that He was omniscient.
Whether it is likely that seven tired fishermen, after working all night, and hauling up their net and stowing it away, would stop on their way home at the advice of a stranger, and cast in their net once more in broad daylight, is a point which admits of question. My own impression is that a secret power and influence went with our Lord's words, and, without knowing why, the seven disciples felt irresistibly constrained to do what the mysterious stranger advised.
Therefore that disciple...the Lord
The first to recognize Jesus was the disciple who first believed the resurrection, — the beloved disciple John, who as usual does not give his own name. With characteristic quickness and sensitiveness, he at once felt convinced that the mysterious stranger must be his beloved Master. Love is always keen-sighted. It suddenly flashed across his mind that the advice given by the stranger, and the result of following the advice, had been precisely the same three years before. The stranger must surely know what happened then, and must have been present ! The stranger must be the Lord Himself ! Thoughts such as these most probably passed through his mind far quicker than we can describe them ; and at once he said to his friend Peter, who was most likely the leading man in the boat, " It is the Lord."
Rollock thinks it was the wonderful draught of fishes that made John know it was the Lord. "He saw in it not only miraculous power, but wonderful bountifulness and liberality," just like His Divine Master.
John 21:7 · Open Word Bible
7Then that disciple whom Jesus loved told Peter, "It is the Lord!" Hearing that it was the Lord, Simon Peter tied his outer garment around himself, since he had stripped for work, and threw himself into the sea.
when Simon Peter heard, &c.
The conduct of the Apostle Peter, here described, is eminently characteristic of the man. It is just what might have been expected from the disciple who went out of the ship to walk on the water on a former occasion, and drew his sword, and began to smite, when our Lord was surrounded by His enemies. Fervent, warm-hearted, impulsive, impetuous, affectionate, thinking nothing of consequences, acting on the spur of present feeling, he at once plunges into the sea, when he hears that his Lord is on the shore, and struggles to get close to Him. Whatever we may think of his hasty behavior, we must all admire his love. Zeal for Christ deserves respect, even when it leads a man into hasty action. Enthusiasm, even when it runs to seed, is better than indifference.
We should note how Peter rushed into action, the very moment that he " heard " the words, " It is the Lord," He did not wait to see, like Thomas on another occasion, hut was satisfied with a word from his brother John, A single spark is enough to kindle tinder, and a single word is enough to stir a heart, when its affections are deeply concerned.
The Greek word which is rendered " fisher's coat," is only found here in the New Testament. Theophylact says it was the upper garment of a Syrian fisherman. The context seems to show that it was a sort of garment which a fisherman laid aside when in the very act of handling his nets.
When we read that Peter was " naked," I see no reason why we should suppose that he was entirely without clothes. I think the meaning is, that he was comparatively naked, having laid aside all his looser garments, as a fisherman in that hot climate naturally would, in order to be able to handle wet nets and fish with greater convenience. And when we read that he girt around him his fisher's coat, I think it simply means that he took up the loose outward garment that he wore when he went on the lake to fish, and girded it tightly round his waist before jumping into the sea.
When we read that Peter " cast himself into the sea," I see no reason for supposing that he swam to land. In order to swim, it is not likely that he would put on more clothes ! — I rather think that the water where he and his companions were was shallow, and that he waded to land. He knew that his large fishing-boat drew too much water to get near shore, and he was too impatient to wait for the slow process of launching the little boat, and coming ashore in it. I cannot doubt, as he jumped into the water, that he remembered going out of the same ship on a former occasion, and walking on the water " to go to Jesus."
It is only fair to say that Chrysostom thinks that Peter swam. On the other hand Brentius, Gerhard, and Archbishop Whately (see Bengel's " Gnomon," English translation), think that he walked on the water, in a miraculous manner, as on the former occasion !
And the other disciples came, &c.
Here we see, placed in strong contrast with Peter's action, the way in which the six remaining Apostles came to land. They came in the boat (" a little ship " is a defective translation), which means the skiff or punt which most large fishing vessels have with them. The • water was evidently too shallow for the large fishing vessel to get near shore. And they came slowly, we may be sure, because, for two hundred cubits, or one hundred yards, they had to drag behind their little boat a net full of fish. How heavy a drag such a net makes on a little boat's progress through the "water, those only know who have had experience.
It is noteworthy that we are not told that Peter got to shore at all sooner than his brethren. This point is, singularly enough, passed over in silence. But wading through deep water is slow work, and the fact that Peter put his coat on before plunging into the sea, is, to my own mind, strong indirect proof that he did not swim, but wade.
It is noteworthy that Peter forgot fish, and net, and boat, and everything else, in his anxiety to reach Christ. It was like the Samaritan woman who " left her waterpot." (John iv. 28.)
John 21:8 · Open Word Bible
8The other disciples came in the boat, towing the net full of fish. They were not far out, only about 100 yards from land.
As soon then...fire...coals...fish...bread
I cannot doubt that this verse records a miracle. Our blessed Lord made preparation for the bodily wants of His wearied disciples, and mercifully " furnished a table for them in the wilderness." (Ps. lxxviii. 19.) The burning fire, the fish lying on it, the bread, were all the creation of Him who had but to will a thing and it was done. Ever thoughtful, ever compassionate, our Lord thought good at this appearing, to show His poor toiling disciples that He cared for their bodies as well as their souls, and remembered that they were men. Who can tell but this miracle took place near the very spot where He had formerly fed five thousand men with a little bread and fish ? I cannot doubt that the bread and fish thus miraculously created would remind the Apostles of " loaves and fishes " multiplied. Once more they saw the same miraculous food, bread and fish, provided by the same Almighty power of their Lord.
The Greek word rendered " fire of coals," is only found in two places in the New Testament, here and in the account of the scene in the High Priest's hall at our blessed Lord's examination before Annas. (John xviii. 18.) It was a " fire of coals " at which the servants of the High Priest warmed themselves, and before which the Apostle Peter denied his Lord. Some think that our Lord had a special object in view by having a " fire of coals " in this place, and that was to remind Peter of his fall. But perhaps the idea is far-fetched.
Stier argues strongly, but needlessly in my judgment, that this provision of bread and fish was made by the angels. In any case it was a miracle, and an act of creation.
John 21:9 · Open Word Bible
9When they came ashore, they saw a charcoal fire already there, with fish laid on it, and bread.
Quesnel observes, " Here are miracles upon miracles. The same power which filled the net with fishes in the midst of the sea, created others upon land, to show His disciples that it was not from want of power to give them fish that Christ asked for Some, and ordered them to fish for them."
Jesus saith unto them, Bring, &c.
In this verse our Lord calls on the disciples to bring proof that, in casting the net at His command, they had not labored in vain. It was the second saying that He spoke, we must remember, on this occasion. The first saying was, " Cast the net on the right side, and ye shall find." The second saying was, " Bring up the fish which ye have now caught," with a strong emphasis on the word "now." I believe our Lord's object was to show the disciples that the secret of success was to work at His command, and to act with implicit obedience to His word. It is as though He said, " Draw up the net ; and see for yourselves how profitable it is to do what I tell you." Fish for food they did not want now, for that was provided for them. Proof of the power of Christ's blessing, and the importance of working under Him was the lesson to be taught, and as they drew up the net they would learn it.
John 21:10 · Open Word Bible
10Jesus said to them, "Bring some of the fish that you have just caught."
Simon Peter went up, &c.
I see no reason for supposing, in this verse, that Peter alone drew up the net. I think it reasonable to suppose that he is named as leader of the party, and captain of the boat. But I believe that all the others helped him. The " going up " must mean that Peter went on board the little boat.
Once more we see two miracles recorded in this verse. One miracle was the singularly large catch of fish which the net contained, a quantity evidently exceeding what was generally taken at one haul. The other miracle was the singular fact, that, in spite of this large quantity of fish, the net was " not broken." Miracle on miracle passed under the eyes of the astonished disciples. — Can we doubt that their minds recalled the miraculous draught of fishes on a former occasion, when " their net brake," and our Lord's words, " Fear not ; from henceforth thou shalt catch men ; " and also his original saying, " Follow Me, and I will make you fishers of men ? " And can we doubt that some of them remembered the parable of the kingdom of Heaven being like to " a net cast into the sea," and finally drawn to shore ? (Luke v. 10. Matt. iv. 19 ; xiii. 47.)
Concerning the number one hundred and fifty-three, we know nothing, and it is useless to speculate. Some have thought that it refers to the languages, and some to the tribes or nations of the world, — each, it is alleged, about one hundred and fifty in number. But this is only guess-work. Yet it is worth remembering, that the strangers whom Solomon employed in building the first temple were precisely one hundred and fifty -three thousand and six hundred. Let the remark be taken for what it is worth. (2 Chron. ii. 17.)
John 21:11 · Open Word Bible
11So Simon Peter went aboard and hauled the net ashore, full of large fish, 153 of them. Even with so many, the net did not tear.
Pearce calls attention to a remark of Jerome, that Oppian, a Greek poet of Cilicia, in the second century, who wrote on fish ing, " has given an account of the number of fishes known to him in his time, being exactly one hundred and fifty-three." This, at any rate, is curious.
Scott makes the remark, that " this draught of fishes might be sold for a considerable sum of money, which the Apostles would have need of, on their return to Jerusalem before the day of Pentecost." There may be something in the idea.
Jesus saith...Come and dine
The object of this gracious invitation seems to me to have been two-fold. It was meant partly to show our Lord's tender compassion for the weary bodies of His disciples. Though risen, He knew and felt for their wants, and would supply food for them when hungry and fatigued. It was meant partly to show that, though risen from the dead, with a glorified body. He would be on the same loving terms of familiarity and kindness as before with His disciples. They need not be frightened at Him. He had not forgotten them. He did not mean to keep them at a distance. He was still one who would eat and drink with them, as a man eateth and drinketh with his friends. It is written, " I will come in to him, and sup with him, and he with Me." (Rev. iii. 20.) An old divine says, " Christ loveth to deal familiarly with men."
The Greek word rendered " dine," does not necessarily mean a mid-day meal. Parkhurst shows, on the contrary, from Xenophon, that it may mean a morning repast. As things are in England now, the translation is a peculiarly unfortunate one. Two or three centuries ago, when people dined at eleven o'clock, the unfitness of it would not have been so remarkable. The meaning evidently is, " Come and partake of a morning meal."
John 21:12 · Open Word Bible
12Jesus said to them, "Come, eat your breakfast." Not one of the disciples dared ask Him, "Who are You?" They knew it was the Lord.
And none...durst ask...the Lord
These words describe the state of mind in which the disciples were at this moment. They all felt convinced and satisfied that the Person before them was the Lord. They felt no doubt ; and no one was the least disposed to say, " Who art thou?" Nevertheless they all felt awed and solemnized by His presence. A deep sense of the mysterious nature of their Lord, in consequence of His resurrection, filled their minds with an indefinable sensation of mingled embarrassment, reverence, and fear. Surely we can all understand this ! Even when Joseph spoke lovingly to his brethren, and revealed himself to them, they were " troubled at his presence." (Gen. xlv. 3.) To sit, and eat, and drink, in the company with one who had risen from the dead, and appeared and disappeared after a supernatural manner, was no light thing. Who can wonder that they felt awed ?
Chrysostom says, " Seeing that His form was altered, and full of awfulness, they were amazed, and desired to ask something concerning it. But fear, and their knowledge that He was not some other but the same, checked the inquiry ; and they only ate what He, with greater exertion of power than before, created for them. For here Jesus no more looked up to heaven, nor performed those human acts, showing that those also which He did formerly were done by way of condescension."
Jesus then cometh, and taketh bread, &c.
This verse describes what took place at this meal, or as our Bible calls it, this dinner. Our Lord came forward, as the host and entertainer of the seven astonished disciples, and gave them bread and fish, as He had doubtless often done on former occasions, and perhaps at the same place. He doubtless meant to give the disciples one more plain proof that He had risen from the dead. Alone by the Sea of Galilee, in the open air, far from the fear of interruption, in broad daylight, He eats and drinks at a social meal. Could these seven men ever doubt from that day, if they had doubted before, that Jesus rose from the dead ? He meant, furthermore, to encourage them to continue looking to Him, as they had done before, as a loving, familiar, sympathizing friend. Though risen, He would have them see practical proof that He could be touched with the feeling of their infirmities, and cared for their bodies as well as their souls. He meant, not least, to remind them of His great miracle of feeding the multitude with a few loaves and fishes. He would freshen their memory of that wondrous miracle, and show them that He would continue doing for them what He had formerly done for those who followed Him in the wilderness.
Chrysostom here remarks, that we are not directly told that Jesus ate with the disciples, but that it is probable from Luke's words in Acts i. 4, that He did. " How," he remarks, " it is not ours to say. These things came to pass in too strange a manner. His nature did not even need food. It was an act of condescension in proof of the resurrection." (See Gen. xviii. 8.)
John 21:13 · Open Word Bible
13Jesus came, took the bread and gave it to them, and the fish in the same way.
This is now the third time, &c.
In this verse St. John winds up the wonderful story he has just told, by one of his peculiar parenthetical comments. Concerning the meaning of the expression " third time," there has been, in my judgment, much needless dispute. No doubt it is perfectly true that this was not literally the third time that our Lord was seen by any one after His resurrection. On the contrary, we know of at least six different appearances before this one : viz. (1) to Mary Magdalene, (2) to Joanna and other women, (o) to Simon Peter, (4) to two disciples going to Emmaus, (5) to ten Apostles together, (6) to the eleven, for the special benefit of Thomas. — But it is no less true that this is strictly and literally the third time that Jesus appeared to any number of the disciples gathered together. — And it is also the third day, as Augustine remarks, that our Lord was pleased to appear at all. The first five appearances were all on the very same day when He rose from the dead. The sixth was a week afterwards, when He appeared to rebuke the unbelief of Thomas. And the appearance recorded in this chapter, though the seventh in number, took place on the third day only, that any one on earth saw Him after He rose.
John 21:14 · Open Word Bible
14This was now the third time that Jesus was revealed to the disciples after He had been raised from the dead.
The question now remains to be considered. Has the narrative contained in these fourteen verses any deep spiritual and allegorical meaning ? Were we intended to read the passage simply as a description of one of our Lord's appearances after His resurrection, and an account of one of His miracles ? Or is the narrative a typical one ? Is the passage intended to convey, under figures and symbols, great prophetical truths concerning the work of the ministry, and the history of the Church in every age, until the Lord comes ? The question is a serious one, and demands serious consideration.
(a) On the one hand, there is undeniable danger in the habit of seeking spiritual and allegorical meanings in the plain historical facts of God's Word. We may go so far in this direction, that, like Origen, and too often Augustine, we may lose sight of the primary simple meaning of Scripture, and turn the Bible into a mere book of riddles, which is useless to any common man, and useful only to those who have very fertile and fanciful imaginations. In fact, if we are always extracting figurative meanings out of Scripture, we may destroy the usefulness of the Book altogether. There must be some limit to the system of figurative interpretation. As a rule, I shrink intuitively from putting any sense on God's Word, which is not the obvious and plain sense of its language. Hooker's words are weighty and wise : " When a literal construction of a text will stand, that which is furthest from the letter is commonly the worst."
(b) On the other hand, it is impossible to deny that all Christ's miracles were meant, more or less, to teach great spiritual truths, under allegories and figures ; and the passage be fore us is a miracle. In addition to this, we must remember that the occasion of the miracle before us was a peculiarly solemn one, — that the Apostles needed certain great truths to be impressed on their attention with peculiar force, by facts as well as by words, — and that, on the eve of His ascension into heaven, our Lord would be exceedingly likely to remind them of their duty, and their position as ministers, by things under their eyes as well as by instruction in their ears. Finally let us try to put ourselves in the position of the seven Apostles on the occasion before us, and try to imagine what they thought and felt about the incidents of this remarkable morning. It is very hard to imagine that they saw nothing but a simple miracle in all that happened. I cannot think so. — I think their hearts must have burned within them, and old spiritual truths, which they had heard before, must have revived in their minds with fresh power, and been written on their souls as with the point of a diamond, never to be effaced.
JOHN XXI. 15—17.
These verses describe a remarkable conversation "between our Lord Jesus Christ and the Apostle Peter. To the careful Bible reader, who remembers the Apostle's thrice-repeated denial of Christ, the passage cannot fail to be a deeply interesting portion of Scripture. Well would it be for the Church, if all " after-dinner " conversations among Christians were as useful and edifying as this.
We should notice first, in these verses, Christ's question to Peter : " Simon, son of Jonas, lovest thou Me ? " — Three times we find the same inquiry made. It seems most probable that this three-fold repetition was meant to remind the Apostle of his own thrice-repeated denial. Once we find a remarkable addition to the inquiry : " Lovest thou Me more than these ? " It is a reasonable supposition that those three words " more than these," were meant to remind Peter of his over-confident assertion : " Though all men deny Thee, yet will not I." — It is just as if our Lord would say, " Wilt thou now exalt thyself above others ? Hast thou yet learned thine own weakness ? "
John 21:15–17 · Open Word Bible
15After they had eaten breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me more than these?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My lambs." 16A second time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Shepherd My sheep." 17A third time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter was hurt because Jesus asked him a third time, "Do you love Me?" Peter replied, "Lord, You know everything; You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My sheep.
So when they had dined
In the verses we now begin, we pass away from the region of allegory, parable, symbol, miracle, and vision, to a plain, unmistakable conversation between our Lord Jesus Christ and the Apostle Peter. It is a conversation of a deeply interesting character, of which every letter deserves to be written in gold. He that supposes that any " John," except John the Apostle, could have written these three verses, gives little evidence of possessing a sound judgment.
It is noteworthy that our Lord does not begin His conversation till the social meal was over. Trifling as this circumstance may seem, it deserves attention, and conveys a lesson. Nothing was so likely to set the Apostles at ease with their Master, and to prepare them to receive any word that fell from His lips with love and affection, as to deal familiarly and intimately with them, and let them " eat and drink " in His company.
John 21:15 · Open Word Bible
15After they had eaten breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me more than these?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My lambs."
Jesus saith to Simon Peter
The object of our Lord in addressing Simon Peter in these verses should be carefully remembered, and not misunderstood. That there was a distinct object in singling him out from the seven disciples sitting round our Lord, and specially speaking to him, I cannot doubt. But what was that object? This question can only be answered by considering the peculiar character of St. Peter, and the peculiar circumstances of his history during the last day of our Lord's ministry, before the crucifixion. None had made so high a profession. None had spoken so confidently of his own strength. None had shown such instability in the hour of trial. None had fallen so sadly, by denying his Master three times. Remembering all this, X believe that our Lord had a special object in addressing Peter on this occasion ; and I see a special wisdom in the address and conversation being recorded, as taking place before six witnesses.
(a) I believe our Lord's first object was to remind Peter of his Bad fall, through over-confidence, and want of watchfulness and prayer. He would have him know that, though raised, pardoned and forgiven, he must never forget what had happened. Three times he had denied his Master. Three times he must be publicly asked whether he loved his Master. Hengstenberg maintains that Peter's fall was not at all in our Lord's mind in this remarkable conversation. But I cannot agree with him.
(6) I believe our Lord's second object was, as Cyril remarks, to restore Peter to his former position as a trusted Apostle and minister in the presence of six witnesses. The thought might possibly come across the minds of some Christians, in future days, that Peter forfeited his claim to be an Apostle and leader of the Church, by his thrice repeated denial of his Master. Our Lord in mercy guards against this possibility, by publicly commissioning Peter once more to do the work of a pastor in the Church.
(c) I believe our Lord's third object was to teach Peter what should be the primary aim of an Apostle and minister. The true qualification for the ministerial office, he must learn, was not high profession of more courage and zeal than others, not loud talk, or even readiness to fight ; but loving, patient usefulness to the souls of others, and diligent care for the sheep of Christ's flock.
He saith to him again, &c.
This verse is simply a repetition of the preceding one, with three exceptions. — For one thing, the expression, " more than these," is omitted. — For another thing, the word which we render " feed," in the Greek is a wider, fuller word than the one employed in the preceding verse. — For another thing, our Lord speaks of His " sheep" instead of His " lambs." By " sheep " I believe our Lord meant those members of His flock who were of more advanced experience and strength in grace, than the class He had spoken of in the preceding verse. Both classes demanded the attention of a faithful pastor.
The repetition of the inquiry was doubtless intended to rouse Peter's attention, and to impress the whole subject on his mind.
Lightfoot thinks that the " threefold repetition, — feed, feed, feed, may most fitly apply to the threefold object of St. Peter's ministry: viz., the Gentiles, the Jews, and the dispersed ten tribes." But this seems to me fanciful. Bengel thinks it refers to the three periods of Peter's ministry.
Whitby observes, " Those who argue for Peter's supremacy above other Apostles, from this passage, are vain in their imagination. If by these words Christ required Peter to feed all His sheep and lambs, it is certain he was wanting in his duty. He never exercised an act of supremacy over the rest of the Apostles ; but being sent by them, obeyed (Acts viii. 14), and being reproved by St. Paul, held his peace (Gal. ii. 11 — 16), and was so far from feeding all Christ's sheep, that he never fed any of the province of St, Paul."
John 21:16 · Open Word Bible
16A second time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Shepherd My sheep."
He saith unto him the third time, &c.
This verse again is a repetition of the two preceding verses, but contains two points of difference. For one thing we are told that " Peter was grieved," on being asked the same question three times. For another thing, Peter uses stronger language when he appeals to our Lord's knowledge of his heart. " Lord," he says " Thou knowest all things."
I cannot for a moment doubt that our Lord asked Peter this remarkable question three times, in order to remind him that lie had denied Him thrice. Our sins ought never to be forgotten by us, though they are wiped out of the book of God's remembrance. The very "grief" which Peter felt at being thrice asked about his love, was intended to do him good. It was meant to remind him that if he was grieved to be asked thrice, " Lovest thou Me ? " how much more must his Master have been grieved when he thrice denied Him !
Whitby observes, " Here is an argument that Christ, in Peter's judgment, was truly God. He says, ' Thou knowest all things.' It is to God alone that the secrets of all hearts lie open."
John 21:17 · Open Word Bible
17A third time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter was hurt because Jesus asked him a third time, "Do you love Me?" Peter replied, "Lord, You know everything; You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My sheep.
There are little nice distinctions in the original Greek of these three verses, in the words that are used, which the English language cannot convey. But they deserve notice, and are not without meaning. Two different words are used to express our one word " love." One of these two words means a higher, calmer, nobler kind of love than the other. This is the word which our Lord uses in the fifteenth and sixteenth verses, where He asks the question, " Lovest thou Me?" — The other of the two words means a more passionate and lower kind of love. This is the word which Peter always uses when he says, " I love thee ! " and our Lord once uses it in the seventeenth verse. — Again : two different words are employed to express our one English word " feed." One means simply " provide food and pasture," and is used in the fifteenth and seventeenth verses. The other means not only " provide food," but " govern, lead, direct, and generally do the work of a shepherd."
Some of the Roman Catholic writers try to make out that " lambs " in this remarkable passage mean the laity, and "sheep " the clergy ; and that supremacy over clergy and laity alike is intended, by these words, to be conferred on Peter and his successors at Rome! Archbishop Trench (on Miracles) justly condemns this interpretation, as " groundless and trifling." He observes, " The commission should at least have run, * Feed my sheep and feed my shepherds,' if any such conclusion could be drawn from Christ's words, though an infinite deal would still remain to be proved."
The lessons which the whole passage is meant to teach the Church of Christ, are many and deep, and have been far too much neglected in every age. I can only indicate them, and then leave the reader to work them out in his own mind.
(a) Love to Christ's person is one of the most important graces that can adorn a Christian, and specially a minister. Without it, correct doctrinal views, zeal for proselytizing, knowledge, eloquence, liberality, diligence in visiting the sick and relieving the poor, are worth very little, and will do very little good. With it, God is pleased to look over many infirmities. A minister may be somewhat defective in some of his views, and even in some of his proceedings, but if he loves Christ and "has a warm heart, God will seldom allow him to lack a blessing.
Hengstenberg shrewdly remarks, that Christ's emphatical question about love to Himself, and omission of any question about love to God, is strong indirect proof of Christ's divinity.
(b) True love to Christ is chiefly to be seen in usefulness to others, in doing as Christ did, in walking in His steps, in laboring to do good in this bad world. He that talks of loving Christ, and idles on through life, never trying to do good to others, is deceiving himself, and will find at length that he had better never have been born.
(c) A vast amount of so-called Christianity is perfectly useless in the sight of God, and will only add to people's condemnation. Church-goers and chapel-goers, who are content to attend services and hear sermons, but know nothing of fervent love to Christ's person, and never lay themselves out to imitate Him, are in the broad way that leads to destruction.
Rollock observes, " A profane man or woman will say, • I love God ; ' but if it manifest not itself in an action, thou art but a liar, and lovest Him not. Faith and love must ever utter themselves in good actions. Hast thou gotten a heart, hands, and feet ? Do some good. Otherwise, if thou doest never a good deed, thy profession of faith and love is vain."
JOHN XXI. 18—25.
We learn, for one thing, from these verses, that the future history of Christians, both in life and death, is foreknown by Christ. The Lord tells Simon Peter, " When thou art old, thou shalt stretch forth thy hands, and another shall gird thee, and carry thee whither thou wouldest not." These words, without controversy, were a prediction of the manner of the Apostle's death. They were fulfilled in after days, it is commonly supposed, when Peter was crucified as a martyr for Christ's sake. The time, the place, the manner, the painfulness to flesh and blood of the disciple's death, were all matters foreseen by the Master.
The truth before us is eminently full of comfort to a true believer. To obtain foreknowledge of things to come would, in most cases, be a sorrowful possession. To know what was going to befall us, and yet not to be able to prevent it, would make us simply miserable. But it is an unspeakable consolation to remember, that our whole future is known and forearranged by Christ. There is no such thing as luck, chance, or accident in the journey of our life. Everything from beginning to end is foreseen, — arranged by One who is too wise to err, and too loving to do us harm.
John 21:18–25 · Open Word Bible
18Truly, truly, I tell you, when you were younger you fastened your own belt and went wherever you wished. But when you have grown old, you will stretch out your hands, and then someone else will fasten a belt on you and take you where you do not wish to go." 19He said this to show by what kind of death Peter would glorify God. After saying this, He told him, "Follow Me." 20Peter turned around and saw the disciple whom Jesus loved following them, the same disciple who at the supper had leaned back against Jesus's chest and said, "Lord, who is it that is going to betray You?" …
Verily, verily, I say unto thee, &c.
Tn this verse our Lord forewarns the Apostle Peter, what death he must expect to be the conclusion of his ministry. After restoring him to his office, and commissioning him to be a pastor, He tells him plainly what his end will be. He holds out no prospect of temporal ease and an earthly kingdom. On the contrary. He bids him look forward to a violent death. If he shows his love by feeding his Master's sheep, he must not be surprised if he is made partaker of his Master's sufferings. And so it was. Peter lived to be persecuted, beaten, imprisoned, and at length slain for Christ's sake. It happened exactly as his Master had predicted. Most ecclesiastical historians say that he suffered martyrdom at Rome, in one of the first persecutions, and was crucified with his head downwards.
Melancthon remarks that Peter, like most Jews, was probably expecting that, after our Lord's resurrection, He would take to Himself His kingdom, and reign in glory with His disciples. Jesus warns him that he must expect nothing of the kind. Tribulation and not glory, was the prospect before him in this world.
It is fair to say that some learned writers deny entirely that Peter ever was at Rome, and consequently deny the truth of the ecclesiastical tradition, that he was crucified there with his head downward. Calovius gives a long passage from Casaubon, maintaining this view. Whether it was so, or not, does not affect the passage before us. In any case, wherever he died, there is no reason to doubt that Peter died a violent death.
John 21:18 · Open Word Bible
18Truly, truly, I tell you, when you were younger you fastened your own belt and went wherever you wished. But when you have grown old, you will stretch out your hands, and then someone else will fasten a belt on you and take you where you do not wish to go."
The expression, " Verily, verily, I say unto thee," is thoroughly characteristic of St. John's Gospel. We cannot doubt that Peter would remember how solemn were the former occasions when our Lord used this phrase, and would see a peculiar solemnity in the words of this verse. Specially would Peter remember the night when our Lord was betrayed, when His Master said to him, " Verily, verily, I say unto thee. The cock shall not crow, till thou hast denied Me thrice." (John xiii. 38.)
The expression, " When thou wast young," is commonly thought to indicate that Peter was now an old man, when these words were spoken. Perhaps too much stress is laid on the words, especially considering the context. I think the safe plan is to interpret it as meaning, " When thou wast a younger man than thou art now."
The expression, " Thou girdedst thyself, and walkedst whither thou wouldest," appears to me a general phrase, denoting the freedom from restraint and independence of movement, which Peter enjoyed, when he followed his calling as a young fisherman, before he was called to be a disciple and Apostle. I cannot, like some commentators, see any allusion to Peter's recent action, when he put his "fisher's coat about him," cast himself into the sea, and waded to the shore. I rather regard it as a proverbial phrase. A young Jewish fisherman, when inclined to go here or there, would, according to oriental custom, gird up his loins and walk off upon his journey, at the pleasure of his own will. " This," says our Lord to Peter, " thou didst use to do when a young man."
The expression, " When thou shalt be old," seems to denote at any rate that Peter would be an older man than he then was, before he died, and would suffer martyrdom in his old age. It certainly condemns the idea entertained by many, that the Apostle Peter was an aged man, when our Lord left the world. Old age, in his case, is clearly represented as a thing future.
The expression, " Thou shalt stretch forth thine hands, and another shall gird thee," is regarded by almost all commentators, as an intimation of the manner of Peter's death. He was to stretch forth his hands at the command of another, that is, of an executioner, and, in all probability, to be bound by that executioner to the cross on which he was to suffer. If this be a correct interpretation of the words, it certainly favors the idea that crucified persons were " bound," as well as " nailed," to the cross. The phrase "gird" may possibly refer to a custom of girding a person's loins, and putting cords round his middle before crucifying him. The contrast would then be more natural between a man girding up his own loins to walk, and another girding him round the loins for execution.
The expression " carry thee whither thou wouldest not," must mean that the executioner having bound Peter to the cross, would carry him so bound to the place where the cross would be reared up, after a manner which would be repugnant and painful to flesh and blood. It cannot, of course, mean that Peter would object to his punishment and resist it. It can only mean that his punishment would be one which must needs bo a heavy trial to his natural will.
Brentius thinks that " another," in this sentence, refers to "Nero," or the " executioner."
spake he...what death...glorify God
We have here one of John's peculiar parenthetical comments, and one for which we may be specially thankful. Who can tell what Commentators might have made of our Lord's prediction to Peter, if John had not been mercifully inspired to tell us that Jesus spoke of his death ?
The expression " what death " means " what kind of death," and is generally considered to indicate that the preceding verse describes death by crucifixion.
The expression " glorify God " is peculiarly interesting, because it teaches that a Christian may bring glory to God by his death, as well as by his life. He does so when he bears it patiently, does not murmur, exhibits sensible peace, enjoys evident hope of a better world, testifies to others of the truth and consolation of the Gospel, and leaves broad evidences of the reality of his religion behind him. He that so ends glorifies God. The deaths of Latimer, Ridley, Hooper, Bradford, Rogers, Rowland Taylor, and many other English martyrs, in the days of Queen Mary, were said to have done more good even than their lives, and to have had immense influence in helping forward the Protestant Reformation.
John 21:19 · Open Word Bible
19He said this to show by what kind of death Peter would glorify God. After saying this, He told him, "Follow Me."
And when...saith...Follow me
The precise meaning of this short and emphatic phrase is not very plain.
(a) Some think that it must be interpreted literally, and that our Lord simply meant, " Follow Me in the direction where I am now going. We have tarried here long enough. Let us be going." At first sight this seems a thin and weak interpretation. But before we reject it entirely, we should carefully observe the language of the next verse.
(&) Some think that "Follow Me " must be interpreted spiritually, and that our Lord used the expression as a kind of watchword for Peter's course in life from that day forward. " Walk in my steps. Do as I have done. Follow Me whithersoever I lead thee, even though it be to prison and death."
I see no reason why we should not adopt both views. There is such a depth and fulness in our Lord's sayings, that I think we may safely do so. I therefore think it most probable that our Lord not only meant, " Arise, and follow Me now ; " but also meant, " Always follow Me through life, whatever be the consequences." After all, Christ's three great words to Christians are, " Come to Me, — Learn of Me, — and Follow Me." (Matt. xi. 28, 29.)
Is there not in the words, " Follow Me," a latent reference to the remarkable saying of our Lord to Peter, on the night that Peter denied Him thrice : " Whither I go, thou canst not follow Me now ; but thou shalt follow Me afterwards." (John xiii. 36.)
Then Peter, turning, &c.
This verse brings in the Apostle John Himself, described with more than usual feeling and particularity, as " the disciple whom Jesus loved, and who leaned on his breast at supper," as if to prevent the possibility of mistake.
The expressions, " turning," and " following," seem to me to place it beyond doubt, that our Lord began to move away from the scene of the social meal, when He said, " Follow Me." No other view can explain them. There was a movement in a certain direction. As our Lord moved away, Peter followed Him. As he followed, Peter turned round, and saw John following also. After John, I believe, the other five disciples followed also, or else they could hardly have heard the remarkable saying about "tarrying till 1 come," which they evidently did hear.
Tittman suggests that " When Peter saw John following he was displeased, as Jesus had ordered Peter alone to follow, with the intention of saying something to him apart. He therefore asked why Jesus permitted John to follow unbidden."— He then thinks, if we adopt this interpretation, that the remarkable words of the following verse may only mean, — " If I wish him to remain with the other disciples until I return to them, that is no business of thine. Just follow Me." — This however seems to me rather a tame interpretation.
Stier observes, " There was something wrong at first in Peter's act of turning himself. He was commanded to follow, and not to look around. Thus there was certainly an uncalledfor, and not artless, looking aside, a side-glance once more of comparison with others I After his deep humiliation here is still some light trace of the ancient Simon."
John 21:20 · Open Word Bible
20Peter turned around and saw the disciple whom Jesus loved following them, the same disciple who at the supper had leaned back against Jesus's chest and said, "Lord, who is it that is going to betray You?"
Peter seeing...Lord...what...this man do
The Greek words of Peter's question would be literally rendered, " Lord : and this man what?" The precise meaning and object of the question are a point which has been much disputed.
(a) Some think that the question was entirely one of brotherly love, interest, and affection. They regard the inquiry as one which arose from Peter's tender feeling toward John, as the disciple whom he loved most among the Apostles. He would fain know what was to be the future lot of his beloved friend and brother.
(6) Some think that the question was one of unseemly curiosity. They regard it as one which Peter ought not to have asked. If our Lord did not volunteer any prediction about John, Peter ought not to have made any inquiry.
(c) Some think, as Flacius, that there was a latent jealousy in Peter's question, and that he seemed to suspect that John, not having denied Christ, would die an easier death than himself I I cannot think this for a moment.
John 21:21 · Open Word Bible
21When Peter saw him, he said to Jesus, "Lord, and what about him?"
My own belief is that there is truth in both the two first views. Our Lord's reply to Peter, recorded in the next verse, certainly indicates to my mind that Peter ought not to have been so forward to ask. On the other hand, I should be sorry to say that Peter's inquiry arose entirely out of curiosity, when I mark Peter's unvarying connection with John on all occasions, and evident brotherly love towards him. In feeling concern about John's future, after hearing about his own, Peter was not to blame. Grace does not require us to be cold and unfeeling about our friends. But in the manner of Peter's inquiry there certainly seems to have been something to blame. Is there not about it a little touch of the old over-readiness to talk of others ? It was once, " Though all men, — all others, — forsake Thee yet will not I." It is now, "If I am to die a violent death, what are others to do ? "
It is certainly my own impression that Peter's question had special reference to John's end : " If I am to die a violent death, what is to be the end of my brother John ? "
Leighton, quoted by Burgon, remarks, " This was a transient stumbling in one who, but lately recovered of a great disease, did not walk firmly. But it is the common track of most, to wear out" their days with impertinent inquiries. There is a natural desire in men to know the things of others, and neglect their own ; and to be more concerned about things to come than things present."
Henry remarks, " Peter seems more concerned for another than for himself. So apt are we to be busy in other men's matters, but negligent in the concerns of our own souls, — quicksighted abroad, but dim-sighted at home, — judging others, and prognosticating what they will do, when we have enough to do to prove our own works, and understand our own ways. Peter seems more concerned about events than about duty. John was younger than himself, and in the course of nature likely to survive him. ' Lord,' he says, ' what times shall he be reserved for ? ' Whereas, if God, by His grace, enable us to persevere to the end, and finish well, and get safely to heaven, we need not ask, * What shall be the lot of those that shall come after us ? Is it not well if peace and truth shall be in my days ? Scripture predictions must be eyed for the direction of our conscience, not for the satisfying of our curiosity."
It is a curious fact worth remembering, that John was one of the only two Apostles, whose future lot had already been spoken of by Christ. " He shall drink of the cup that I drink of, and be baptized with the baptism I am baptized with." (Mark x. 39.)
Jesus saith unto him, If I will, &c.
Our Lord's answer to Peter can only be taken, in my judgment, as a rebuke. It was meant to teach the Apostle that he must first attend to his own duty, mind his own soul, fulfil his own course, and leave the future of other brethren in the hands of a wise and merciful Saviour. He must not pry too curiously into God's counsels concerning John. What good would it do him to know whether John was to live a long life or a short one ; to die a violent death or a natural one ? Our Lord seems to say, " Leave off inquiring about thy brother's future lot. Thou knowest that he is one of my sheep, and as such shall never perish, and is in safe keeping. What is the rest to thee ? Have faith to believe that all will be well done about him. Look to thine own soul and be content to follow Me." — I cannot help seeing a latent resemblance between this place and the well-known passage at the end of Daniel's prophecy. " Then said I, O my Lord, what shall be the end of these things? And He said, Go thy way, Daniel : for the words are closed up and sealed till the time of the end," — " Go thou thy way till the end be : for thou shalt rest, and stand in thy lot at the end of the days." (Dan. xii. 8, 9, 13.)
Theophylact suggests that our Lord saw that Peter was vehemently attached to John, and unwilling to be separated from him, and therefore meant to teach him that he must do his own work and follow Christ, wherever He might lead him, even though separation from John might be the consequence.
John 21:22 · Open Word Bible
22Jesus said to him, "If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you? As for you, follow Me!"
After all we must take care that we do not omit the special point of our Lord's words. What our Lord rebukes is not general concern about the souls of others, but over-anxiety and restless curiosity about the future of our friends. Such overanxiety indicates want of faith : we ought to be willing to leave their future in God's hands. To know their future would, in all probability, not make us one jot more happy. I can imagine nothing more miserable than to see in the distance tribulation and sorrow coming on our friends, and not to be able to avert it. Of what use would it have been to Peter, to know that his beloved brother John would one day be cast into a caldron of boiling oil, at Ephesus, during a persecution ? What good would it have done Peter, to know that John would spend years of weary captivity on the Isle of Patmos, and finally outlive all the company of the Apostles, and be left last and latest on the stormy sea of this troublous world ? To know all this would not have done Peter the slightest good, and would more likely have added to his own sorrow. Wisely and well did our Lord say, " What is that to thee ? " Wisely and well does He teach us not to be over-anxious about the future of our children, our relatives, and our friends. Far better for us, and far happier, to have faith in God, and to let the great unknown future alone.
Burkitt observes, " There are two great varieties in men with reference to knowledge. The one is a neglect to know what it is our duty to know. The other is a curiosity to know what it doth not belong to us to know."
In any case, the words " Follow Me " should always teach ns that our first duty in religion is to look to our own souls, and to take heed that we ourselves follow Christ, and walk with God. Whatever others may do or not do, suffer or not suffer, our own duty is clear and plain. People who are always looking at others, and considering others, and shaping their own course accordingly, commit a great mistake. Of all weak and foolish reasons assigned by some for not coming to the Lord's Supper, the weakest perhaps is that very common one, — the conduct of others who are communicants ! To such persons the words of our Lord apply with emphatical force, " What is that to thee ? Follow thou Me."
The words of our Lord, " If I will that he tarry till I come," are a deep and mysterious saying, and in every age of the Church have received different interpretations.
(a) Some, as Gerhard, Maldonatus, and Wordsworth, hold that Jesus meant, " If I will that he tarry a long time on earth, lingering here long after thou art gone, until I come for him at death, what is that to thee ? " — I cannot, however, admit this interpretation for a moment. Death and the coming of Christ are two totally different things, and it is an entire mistake to confound them, as people often do (with very good intentions), in selecting texts for tombstones, as part of epitaphs. There is not a single passage in the New Testament, where the coming of the Lord means death. Moreover, the very next verse in this chapter seems to place the two things in strong contrast, as not the same.
Then went this saying, &c.
In this verse John carefully describes the rise of the earliest ecclesiastical tradition. He says that it became a common saying among the brethren, that he was not to die. Some very likely took it into their heads that, like Enoch and Elijah, he was to be translated and never see death, but pass into glory without dying. The Apostle takes pains to point out that Jesus never said that he was not to die, and had only supposed the possibility of his " tarrying till He came." To my own mind his manner of stating the point is strongly confirmatory of the view I have already supported : viz., that our Lord only used a hypothetical expression, and did not at all intend to make a positive prediction.
We should carefully notice in this passage how easy it is for traditions to begin ; and how soon, even with the best intentions, unfounded reports originate among religious men. Nothing is more unsatisfactory, nothing more uncertain, nothing more destitute of solid foundation, than that huge mass of matter which the Roman Catholic Church has heaped together, and professes to respect, called " Catholic tradition." The moment a Christian departs from God's Word written, and allows " Catholic tradition " any authority, he plunges into a jungle of uncertainty, and will be happy if he does not make shipwreck of his faith altogether.
Flacius observes, that not observing our Lord's " if " gave rise to a tradition 1 A single word omitted in a text may do harm.
John 21:23 · Open Word Bible
23So the saying spread among the brothers and sisters that this disciple would not die. But Jesus had not told Peter that the disciple would not die; He had said, "If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you?"
Henry remarks, " Let us learn here the uncertainty of human tradition, and the folly of building faith upon it. Here was a tradition, an apostolical tradition, a saying that went abroad among the brethren. It was early ; it was common ; it was public ; and yet it was false. How little then are those unwritten traditions to be relied upon, which the Council of Trent has decreed to be worthy to be received with a veneration and pious affection equal to that which is owing to Holy Scripture."
Henry also remarks, " Let us learn the aptness of men to misinterpret the sayings of Christ. The grossest errors have sometimes shrouded themselves under the umbrage of incontestable truth, and the Scriptures themselves have been wrested by the unlearned and unstable. We must not think it strange if we hear the sayings of Christ misinterpreted, and quoted to patronize the errors of antichrist."
The Greek phrase" which we render " should not die," is literally, " does not die."
It seems impossible to avoid the conclusion, that the words which Jesus addressed to Peter were heard by the other five Apostles. Otherwise, the saying, or report referred to in this verse, could not have gone forth.
This is the disciple, &c.
In this verse the Apostle John makes a solemn declaration of his own authorship of the Gospel which bears his name, and of the truth of the matters which the Gospel itself contains. As usual, with characteristic humility, he does not give his name, but modestly speaks of himself in the third person. It is as though he said, — " Finally, I, John the Apostle, who leaned on Jesus's breast, declare that I am the person who here testifies of these sayings and doings of Christ, and who has here written them down in this book, and I know that I have told nothing but what ia true, and that my testimony may be implicitly trusted."
The first person plural is here used by John, we should observe^ just as it is in the beginning of his first Epistle.
The verse seems written in order to assure all readers of John's Gospel that they need feel no doubt whatever that they have in this Gospel a faithful and true record of things that Jesus said and did, and that this, the last of the four narratives of Christ's history, is just as trustworthy, credible, and dependable as the books written by Matthew, Mark, and Luke.
John 21:24 · Open Word Bible
24This is the disciple who is testifying about these things and who has written them, and we know his testimony is true.
And there are also many other things, &c.
In this verse John seems to wind up his book, by breaking forth into a fervent declaration about the wonderful things which his Lord and Master had done. It is as though he said, " Though I finish my Gospel here, I have not told all the marvellous things that Jesus did while He was upon earth. There are many other things which he did, and many other words which He spoke, which are not recorded in my Gospel, nor yet in the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, and Luke. Indeed, if they were written down every one, I suppose the world would not receive them, and could not comprehend their value."
The words which we render, " The books that should be written," would be more literally translated, " The books written."
Brentius calls attention to the very large number of miracles which, according to St. Matthew, were wrought by our Lord, of which we have no special record in any of the Gospels. (See Matt. iv. 23, 24 ; xi. 5.) He justly argues that if these were all put down and described, it would greatly swell the Gospel narrative. What we have recorded is only a sample of what Jesus did.
Henry observes, that books might easily have been multiplied about Christ. " Everything that Christ said or did was worth our notice, and capable of being improved. He never spoke an idle word, and never did an idle thing ; nay. He never spoke or did anything mean, little, or trifling, which is more than can be said of the wisest of men." — But he wisely adds, " If we do not believe and improve what is written already, neither should we if there had been much more."
John 21:25 · Open Word Bible
25Jesus did many other things as well. If each one were written down, I suppose that even the world itself could not hold all the books that would be written.
The expression which St. John uses in this verse about " the world not receiving the books," is not without difficulty. It cannot of course mean that the material bulk of the books would be so large that the universe could not receive them. This would be absurd, as the " things " spoken of are only the things which Jesus did and said during the three years of His ministry. But what does the expression mean ?
(a) Some, as Heinsius and Whitby, think that it means " the world, or unconverted portion of mankind, could not receive, take in, or comprehend more, if more was written. There is enough recorded for the conviction of sinners, and for the guidance of all who honestly want to be saved." — It is a grave objection to this view, that the text does not say " the world " simply, but " the world itself." Yet in fairness it must be allowed that in this sense the expression is rather like that in Amos : " The land is not able to bear all His words." (Amos vii. 10.)
(b) Some think that the phrase must be taken as a strong hyperbolical description of the quantity and value of Christ's works and words, during the period of His ministry, and that we must not press an excessively literal interpretation of the phrase. They argue that the figure called " hyperbole " is not at all uncommon in the Scripture, and that language is often used, when the idea to be conveyed is that of very great size, value, quantity, or number, which evidently cannot be interpreted literally. On the whole, I incline to think that this is the right view of the expression, and that it harmonizes well with the fervent, warm-hearted, loving character of the Apostle who lay on Jesus' breast, and was commissioned to write the fourth Gospel. He ends with a heart full of Christ, and running over with love to Him, and zeal for His glory, and so he winds up just like himself.