Logia

J. C. Ryle · Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: St. John, Vol. I

John 5

88 excerpts on John 5, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

John 5:1–15

JOHN V. 1—15.

We are taught, for one thing, in this passage, what misery sin has brought into the world. We read of a man who had been ill for no less than thirty-eight years ! For eight-and-thirty weary summers and winters he had endured pain and infirmity. He had seen others healed at the waters of Bethesda, and going to their homes rejoicing. But for him there had been no healing. Friendless, helpless, and hopeless, he lay near the wonder-working waters, but derived no benefit from them. Year after year passed away, and left him still un cured. No relief or change for the better seemed likely to come, except from the grave.

When we read of cases of sickness like this, we should remember how deeply we ought to hate sin ! Sin was the original root, and cause, and fountain of every disease in the world God did not create man to be full of aches, and pains, and infirmities. These things are the fruits of the Fall. There would have been no sickness, if there had been no sin.

No greater proof can be shown of man's inbred unbelief, than his carelessness about sin. " Fools," says the wise man, "make a mock at sin." (Pro. xiv. 9.) Thousands delight in things which are positively evil, and run greedily after that which is downright poison. They love that which God abhors, and dislike that which God loves. They are like the madman, who loves his enemies and hates his friends. Their eyes are blinded. Surely if men would only look at hospitals and infirmaries, and think what havoc sin has made on this earth, they would never take pleasure in sin as they do.

John 5:1–15 · Open Word Bible

1Some time after this there was a Jewish festival, and Jesus went up to Jerusalem. 2In Jerusalem, by the Sheep Gate, there is a pool with five porticoes; in Hebrew it is called Bethesda. 3Many sick people used to lie in these porticoes: the blind, the lame and the paralyzed. …

Report a mistake

John 5:1

After this

Literally translated, this would be, "after these things." Some think that when St. John is telling some event which follows immediately after the last thing narrated, be uses the expression, " after this thing " (as John ii. 12), but that when there has been an interval of time he uses the expression, " after these things." — If this be correct, we must suppose that some space of time elapsed between the healing of the nobleman's son and the visit to Jerusalem, recorded in this chapter.

[A feast of the Jews.] There is nothing to show what feast this was. Most commentators think it was the passover. Many however think it was the feast of pentecost. Some few say it was the feast of tabernacles, some the feast of purim, and some the feast of the dedication. Each view has its advocates, and the question will probably never be settled. An argument in favour of the passover is the fact that none of the five Jewish feasts were so regularly attended by devout Jews as the passover. An argument against it is the fact that on three other occasions, when the feast of the passover is mentioned in St. John, he carefully specifies it by name; and one would naturally expect that it would be named here.

John 5:1 · Open Word Bible

1Some time after this there was a Jewish festival, and Jesus went up to Jerusalem.

Report a mistake

The matter is really of no peculiar importance. In one point of view only it is interesting. — If the "feast" was the passover, it proves that there were four passovers during the period of our Lords ministry on earth. St. John mentions three by name, — beside this " feast." (John ii. 23; vi. 4; xii. 1.) This would make it certain that our Lord's ministry lasted three full years, or at any rate must have begun with a passover, and ended Avith a passover. — If the "feast" was not the passover, we have no proof that His ministry lasted longer than between two and three years. (See notes on John ii. 13.)

The expression, "a feast of the Jews," is one of many incidental evidences that St. John wrote specially for the use of Gentile converts, and that he thought it needful for their benefit to explain Jewish ordinances.

Report a mistake

Jesus went up

The frequency of our Lord's attendance at Jewish feasts, and the respect He showed for Mosaic ordinances, should always be noticed. They were appointed by God. and so long as they lasted, He gave them honour. It is an important proof to us, that the unworthiness of ministers is no reason for neglecting God's ordinances, such as baptism and the Lord's Supper The benefit we receive from ordinances and sacraments does not depend on the character of those who administer them, but on the state of our own souls. The priests and officers of the Temple. in our Lord's time, were probably very unworthy persons. But that did not prevent our Lord honouring the Temple ordinances and feasts. — It does not however follow from this that we should be justified in habitually going to hear false doctrine preached. Our Lord never did this.-

Let it be noted, that none of the four Gospel-writers speak so much of our Lord's doings in Judaea and Jerusalem as St. John does.

Report a mistake

John 5:2

there is at Jerusalem

These words, it is thought, show that Jerusalem was yet standing, and not taken and destroyed by the Romans, when John wrote his Gospel. Otherwise, it is argued, he would have said, " There was at Jerusalem."

[By the sheep-market a pool] Nothing certain is known about this pool, or its precise situation. Modern travellers have professed to point out where it was. But there is little ground for determining the matter, except conjecture and tradition. After all the changes of eighteen centuries, points like these are almost incapable of a satisfactory solution. There is no place in the world, perhaps, where it is so difficult to settle anything decidedly about ancient buildings and sites as ' Jerusalem. Some propose to render the expression " sheep-market "the " sheepgate," because of Nehemiah iii. 1. But we really have no certain ground for either expression.

John 5:2 · Open Word Bible

2In Jerusalem, by the Sheep Gate, there is a pool with five porticoes; in Hebrew it is called Bethesda.

Report a mistake

called in the Hebrew tongue Bethesda

The word "Bethesda," according to Cruden, means " house of effusion," or " house of pity or mercy." It is not mentioned anywhere else in the Bible. The mention of the " Hebrew tongue," shows again that John did not write for Jews so much as Gentiles.

Report a mistake

John 5:3

In these lay a great multitude

The context seems to show that the multitude were assembled at this particular feast in this place, expecting a certain miracle to be wrought, which only took place at this particular time of the year.

[ Impotent folk ] This expression evidently does not mean paralytic people, but merely people who were sick and ilL Tha mention of " blind, halt, withered," shows this.

[Moving of the water.] This " moving " must have been something that could be seen and observed by persons standing by or looking on. There was no virtue or healing element in the water, until the movement took place.

John 5:3 · Open Word Bible

3Many sick people used to lie in these porticoes: the blind, the lame and the paralyzed.

Report a mistake

John 5:4

For an angel went down, &c.

The thing we are here told is very curious. There is nothing like it in the Bible, Josephus, the Jewish writer, does not mention it. The simplest view is that it was a standing miracle wrought once every year, as Cyril says, or at any rate at some special season only, by God's appointment, to keep the Jews in mind of the wonderful works that had been done for them in time past, and to remind them that the God of miracles was unchanged. — But when this singular miracle first began, — on what occasion it began, — why we never hear anything else about it, — in what way the angel came down, — are questions which cannot be answered. — That angels did interpose in a miraculous manner in the days of the New Testament, is perfectly clear from many instances in the Gospels and Acts. That the Jews themselves had strong faith in the interposition of angels on certain occasions, is clear from the account of the vision of Zacharias, when we are simply told that the people "perceived that he had seen a vision in the temple."' (Luke i. 22.) That from the days of Malachi, when inspiration ceased, God may have seen it good to keep up in the Jewish mind a faith in unseen things, by the grant of a standing miracle, is a very probable opinion. The wisest course is to take the passage as we find it, and to believe though we cannot explain.

Report a mistake

All other attempts to get over the difficulties of the passage are thoroughly unsatisfactory. To condemn the passage as not genuine, is a lazy way of cutting the knot, and not at all clearly warranted by the authority of manuscripts. — To say that St. John only used the popular language of the Jews in describing the miracle, and did not really believe it himself, is, to say the least, irreverent and profane. — To suppose, as Hammond and others have done, that the "angel" only means a common human "messenger" sent by the priests, and that the healing efficacy of the water arose from the blood of the many sacrifices which drained into the pool of Bethesda at the passover feast; — or to suppose, as others, that Bethesda was a pool where sacrifices were washed before they were offered, are all entirely gratuitous assumptions, and do not get over the main difficulty. There is no proof that the blood of the sacrifices did drain into the pool. There is no proof that the blood would give the water any healing virtue. There is no proof, as Lightfoot shows, that sacrifices were washed at all. (See Lightfoot's Exercitations on John, on this passage.) Moreover, this hypothesis would not account for only one person being healed every time the waters were " troubled," or for St. John's mention of the " angel troubling " the waters. Here, as in many other instances, the simplest view, and the one which involves the fewest difficulties, is to take the passage as we find it, and to interpret it as narrating an actual fact, — viz. : a standing miracle which actually was literally wrought at a certain season, and perhaps every year.

Report a mistake

After all there is no more real difficulty in the account before us, than in the history of our Lord's temptation in the wilderness, the various cases of Satanic possession, or the release of Peter from prison by an angel. Once admit the existence of angels, their ministry on earth, and the possibility of their interposition to carry out God's designs, and there is nothing that ought to stumble us in the passage. The true secret of some of the objections to it, is the modern tendency to regard all miracles as useless lumber, which must be thrown overboard, if possible, and cast out of the Sacred Narrative on every occasion. Against this tendency we must watch and be on our guard.

Rollock remarks, " The Jewish people at this time was in a state of great confusion, and the presence of God was in great measure withdrawn from it. The prophets whom God had been accustomed to raise up for extraordinary purposes, were no longer given to the Jews. Therefore God, that He might not appear altogether to cast off His people, was willing to heal some miraculously, and in an extraordinary way, in order that He might testify to the world that the nation was not yet entirely rejected." Brentius and Calvin say much the same.

Poole thinks that this miracle only began a little before the birth of Christ, "as a figure of him being about to come, who was to be a fountain opened to the house of David." Lightfoot takes the same view.

Report a mistake

John 5:5

infirmity thirty and eight years

This means the length of time during which the sick man had been ilL How old he was we do not know.

Baxter remarks, " How great a mercy is it to live eight and thirty years under God's wholesome discipline ! O my God, I thank Thee for the like discipline of eight and fifty years. How safe a life is this compared to one spent in full prosperity and pleasure !"

Those who see typical and abstruse meanings in all the least details of the narratives of Scriptures, observe that thirty-eight years was the exact time of Israel's wanderings in the wilderness. They see in the sick man, — helpless and hopeless till Christ came, — a type of the Jewish Church. The pool of Bethesda is Old Testament religion. The small benefit it conferred, — viz. : only healing one at a time, represents the narrow and limited benefit which Judaism conferred on mankind. The merciful interference of Christ on the sick man's behalf, represents the bringing in of the Gospel for all the world. These are pious thoughts, but it may well be doubted whether there is any warrant for them.

The notions that the pool of Bethesda was a type of baptism, and the five porches typical of the five books of the law, or the five wounds of Christ, appear to me mere ingenious inventions of man, without any solid foundation. Yet Chrysostom, Augustine, Theophylact, Euthymius, Burgon, Wordsworth, and many others, maintain them. Those who wish to see a full reply to the theory, that the miracle at the pool of Bethesda is a typical proof of the doctrine of baptismal regeneration, will find it in Gomarus, the Dutch divine. He takes up Bellarmine's argument on the subject, and anwers him completely.

John 5:5 · Open Word Bible

5One man there had been ill for thirty-eight years.

Report a mistake

John 5:6

When Jesus saw...knew...long time

We need not doubt that our Lord knew this man's history by that divine knowledge which, as God, He possesses of all things in heaven and earth. To suppose that He ascertained by inquiry the state of his case before speaking to him, is a weak, meagre, and frigid interpretation. As a practical truth, it is a most comfortable doctrine that Jesus knows every sickness and disease, and all its weary history. Nothing is hid from Him.

[He said unto him.'] This is an example of our Lord being the first to speak and begin conversation, as He did with the woman of Samaria. (John iv, 7.) Unasked, unsolicited, unexpectedly, He mercifully addressed the sick man. No doubt He always begins in man's heart .before man begins with Him. But He does all things, as a Sovereign, according to His own will; and it is not always that we see Him taking the first step so entirely of Himself, as we do here.

John 5:6 · Open Word Bible

6Jesus saw him lying there and knew that he had been in that condition for a long time, so He asked him, "Do you want to be well?"

Report a mistake

Wilt thou be made whole

The English language here fails to give the fuU force of the Greek. It means, "Hast thou a will? Dost thou wish? Dost thou desire to be made whole?" The question was perhaps meant to awaken desire and expectation in the man, and to prepare him in some sense for the blessing about to be bestowed on him.

Report a mistake

John 5:7

The impotent man answered him, Sir

The word rendered "Sir" is the same that is more commonly rendered "Lord." It is the same that is rendered " Sir " all through the fourth chapter, in the history of the Samaritan woman.

[I have no man... .put me into the pool.] This is no doubt mentioned as an intentional proof of the heartlessness and unkindness of human nature. Think of a poor invalid waiting for years by the water, and having not a single friend to help him! The longer we live on earth the more we shall find that it is a selfish world, and that the sick and afflicted have few real friends in time of need. " The poor is hated even of his neighbour." (Prov. xiv. 20.) Christ is the only unfailing friend of the friendless and helper of the helpless.

John 5:7 · Open Word Bible

7The sick man answered Him, "Sir, when the water is stirred up, there is no one to put me into the pool. And while I am on my way, someone else steps down before I do."

Report a mistake

John 5:8

Rise, take up thy bed, and walk

Here, as in other similar cases, it is evident that miraculous healing power went forth with the words of our Lord. Thus, " Stretch forth thy hand " (Mark iii. 5) ; " Go show yourselves to the priests " (Luke xvii. 14). Commands like these tested the faith and obedience of those to whom they were given. How could they possibly do the things commanded, if impotent, like the man before us ? Where the use of doing them, if still covered with leprosy, like the ten lepers? But it was precisely in the act of obedience that the blessing came. The whole power is Christ's. But He loves to make us exert ourselves, and show our obedience and faith.

John 5:8 · Open Word Bible

8Jesus told him, "Get up, pick up your mat, and start walking."

Report a mistake

John 5:9

- Augustine finds in the command, " Take up thy bed," an exhortation to the love of our neighbours, because we are to bear one another's burdens; and in the command, " walk," an exhortation to love God ! Such allegorizing appears to me very unwarrantable, and calculated to bring the Bible into contempt^ as a book that can be made to mean anything. 12*^

9. — [Immediately.... made whole,.. ..walked.] Here we see the reality of the miracle wrought. Nothing but Divine power could enable one who had been a cripple for so many years to move his limbs and carry a burden all at once. But it was as easy to our Lord to give immediate strength as it was to create muscles, nerves, and sinews in the day that Adam was made.

When we are told that the man " took up his bed," we must remember that this probably was nothing more than a light mattress, carpet, or thick cloth, such as is commonly used in hot countries for sleeping on.

John 5:9 · Open Word Bible

9Immediately the man became well. He picked up his mat and began walking about. And this happened on a Sabbath.

Report a mistake

John 5:10

The Jews

Here, as in many places in St. John's Gospel, the expression, " the Jews," when used of the Jews at Jerusalem, means the leaders of the people, — elders, rulers, and scribes. It does not mean vaguely the "Jewish crowd" around our Lord, but the representatives of the whole nation, — the heads of Israel at the time.

[It is not lawful.... carry bed.] In support of this charge of unlawfulness, the Jews would allege not merely the general law of the fourth commandment, but the special passages in Nehemiah and Jeremiah, about " bearing no burden " on the Sabbath day. (Neh. xiii. 19 ; Jer. xvii. 21.) But they could not have proved that these passages applied to the case of the man before them. — For a man to carry merchandise and wares on the Sabbath was one thing. For a sick man, suddenly and miraculously healed, to walk away to his home, carrying his mattress, was quite another. — To forbid the one man to carry his burden was Scriptural and lawful. To forbid the other was cruel, and contrary to the spirit of the law of Moses. — The act of the one man was unnecessary. The act of the other was an act of necessity and mercy. — It might perhaps be urged in defence of the Jews, that they only saw a man carrying off a burden, and knew nothing of his previous illness or his cure. But when we remember the many instances recorded in the Gospels of their extreme and harsh interpretation of the fourth commandment, it is doubtful whether this plea will stand.

John 5:10 · Open Word Bible

10So the Jewish leaders kept telling the man who had been healed, "It is the Sabbath. It is against the law for you to carry your mat."

Report a mistake

John 5:11

He that made me whole, the same said, &c.

The answer of the man seems simple. But it contains a deep principle. " He that has done so great a thing to me was surely to be obeyed, when He told me to take up my bed. If He had authority and power to heal, He was not likely to lay upon me an unlawful command. I only obeyed him who cured me." If Christ has really healed our souls, should not this be our feeling toward Him ? — "Thou hast healed me. What thou commandest I will do."

John 5:11 · Open Word Bible

11But he answered them, "The one who made me well is the one who told me, 'Pick up your mat and start walking.'"

Report a mistake

John 5:12

What man is that which said...Take up thy bed, &c.

Ecolampadius, Grotius, and many others, remark what an example this question is of the malevolent and malicious spirit of the Jews. Instead of asking, " who healed thee ?" they asked " who told thee to carry thy bed ?" They cared not for knowing what they might admire as a work of mercy, but what they might make ihe ground of an accusation. How many arc like them ! They are always looking out for something to find fault with.

John 5:12 · Open Word Bible

12So they asked him, "Who is this man who told you to pick it up and walk?"

Report a mistake

John 5:13

wist not who it was

It is most probable that the cripple really knew not who it was that had healed him, and had only seen our Lord that day for the first time. He was ignorant of His name, and only knew Him as a kind person, who came up and said suddenly, " Wilt thou be made whole ?" and, after curing him miraculously, suddenly disappeared in the crowd.

[Conveyed himself away.] The Greek word so rendered is peculiar, and only found in this place. Parkhurst thinks that it simply means " departed, or went away." Schleusner says that the root of the idea is, " swimming out, or escaping by swimming," and that the meaning here is, "withdrew himself secretly from the crowd that was in the place." If so, it is not improbable that, as in Luke iv. 30, at Nazareth, and John x. 39, in the Temple, our Lord put forth a miraculous power in passing or gliding through the crowd without being observed or stopped.

John 5:13 · Open Word Bible

13But the healed man had no idea who it was, since there was a crowd in the place and Jesus had moved off without being noticed.

Report a mistake

John 5:14

Afterward...temple

It is not clear how long a time elapsed before our Lord found the man whom He had healed in the Temple. If the theory be correct to which I adverted in the note on the first verse, there must have been an interval. The word " afterwards " is literally " after these things."

Chrysostom thinks that the circumstance of the man being found " in the temple " is an indication of his piety.

[Behold thou art made whole : sin no more, etc.] These words appear to point at something more than meets the eye. They are a solemn caution. One might fancy that our Lord knew that some sin had been the beginning of the man's illness, and that he meant to remind him of it. It certainly seems very unlikely that our Lord would say broadly and vaguely, " sin no more," unless he spoke with a significant reference to some sin which had been the primary cause of this man's long illness. (See 1 Cor. xi. 30.) There are sins which bring their own punishments on men's bodies ; and I am strongly disposed to think that it may have been the case with this man. The expression, " a worse thing," would then come out with more force. It would be " a heavier visitation," — a worse judgment, — even than this thirtyeight years' illness. A sick bed is a sorrowful place, but hell is much worse.

John 5:14 · Open Word Bible

14Afterward Jesus found him in the temple area and said to him, "Look, you are well now. Do not sin any longer, or something worse could come upon you."

Report a mistake

Besser remarks, — "It is a dreadful thing, when the correction and mercy of Divine love wearies itself with a man in va'n. You that are sick, write over your beds, when you rise up from them in renewed health, — ' Behold thou art made whole ; sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto thee.' " Brentius says much the same, If sin was the cause of this man's disease, and he had been ill from the effects of it thirty and eight years, it is plain that it must have been committed before our Lord was born ! It is an instance, in that case, of our Lord's perfect and Divine knowledge of all things, past as well as future.

Report a mistake

John 5:15

departed, and told the Jews

There is no proof that the man did this with anj evil design. Born a Jew, and taught to reverence his rulers and elders, he naturally wished to give them the information they desired, and had no reason to suppose, for anything we can see, that it would injure his Benefactor.

John 5:15 · Open Word Bible

15The man went off and told the Jewish leaders that the one who had made him well was Jesus.

Report a mistake

John 5:16–23

JOHN V. 16—23.

We learn, for one thing, from the verses before us, that there are some works which it is lawful to do on the Sabbath day.

The Jews, as on many other occasions, found fault because Jesus healed a man who had been ill for thirty-eight years, on the Sabbath. They charged our Lord with a breach of the fourth commandment.

Our Lord's reply to the Jews is very remarkable. " My Father," he says, " worketh hitherto, and I also work." It is as though He said : — " Though my Father rested on the seventh day from His work of creation, He has never rested for a moment from His providential government of the world, and from His merciful work of supplying the daily wants of all His creatures. Were He to rest from such work, the whole frame of nature would stand still. And I also work works of mercy on the Sabbath day. I do not break the fourth commandment when I heal the sick, any more than my Father breaks it when He causes the sun to rise and the grass to grow on the Sabbath."

We must distinctly understand, that neither here nor elsewhere does the Lord Jesus overthrow the obligation of the fourth commandment. Neither here nor elsewhere is there a word to justify the vague assertions of some modern teachers, that " Christians ought not to keep a Sabbath," and that it is " a Jewish institution which has passed away." The utmost that our Lord does, is to place the claims of the Sabbath on the right foundation. He clears the day of rest from the false and superstitious teaching of the Jews, about the right way of observing it. He shows us clearly that works of necessity and works of mercy are no breach of the fourth commandment.

John 5:16–23 · Open Word Bible

16For this reason the Jewish leaders began to persecute Jesus, since He kept doing such things on the Sabbath. 17Jesus answered them, "My Father has been at work right up to now, and I am at work as well." 18So the Jewish leaders were even more determined to kill Him. Besides breaking the Sabbath, He was speaking of God as His own Father, and so was making Himself equal to God. …

Report a mistake

John 5:16

therefore...Jews persecute, &c.

The verbs in this verse are all in the imperfect tense. It may be doubted whether the meaning is not, strictly speaking, something of this kind : — " The Jews from this time began to persecute Jesus, and were always seeking to slay Him, because He made a habit of doing these things on the Sabbath day." It is some confirmation of this view that our Lord at a much later period refers to this very miracle at Bethesda, as a thing which had specially angered the Jews of Jerusalem, and for which they hated Him and sought still to kill Him. It was long after the time of this miracle when He said, — "Are ye angry at me, because I have made a man every whit whole on the Sabbath day ? " (John vii. 23.)

John 5:16 · Open Word Bible

16For this reason the Jewish leaders began to persecute Jesus, since He kept doing such things on the Sabbath.

Report a mistake

John 5:17

But Jesus answered

This seems to have been the first reply which our Lord made when charged with breaking the fourth commandment. It was a short, simple justification of the lawfulness of doing works of mercy on the Sabbath. There seems to have been an interval between this reply and the long argumentative defence which begins in the 19th verse.

[My Father worketh hitherto, and I also work.] The words rendered "hitherto," are, literally, "until now," — that is, from the beginning of creation up to the present time.

I can only see one meaning in this pithy sentence: — "My Father in heaven is continually working works of mercy and kindness in His providential government of the world, in supplying the wants of all His creatures, in maintaining the whole fabric of the earth in perfection, in giving rain from heaven and fruitful seasons, in preserving and sustaining life. All this He does on Sabbaths, as well as week days. Were He to cease from such works, the whole world would be full of confusion. When He rested from His works of creation He did not rest from His works of providence. I also, who am His beloved Son, claim the right to work works of mercy on the Sabbath. In working such works I do not break the Sabbath any more than My Father does. My Father appointed the fourth commandment to be honoured, and yet never ceased to cause the sun to rise and the grass to grow on the Sabbath. I also, who claim to be One with the Father, honour the Sabbath, but I do not abstain from works of mercy upon it."

John 5:17 · Open Word Bible

17Jesus answered them, "My Father has been at work right up to now, and I am at work as well."

Report a mistake

Two things should be observed in this sentence. One is the plain practical lesson that the Sabbath was not meant to be a day of total idleness, and of entire cessation from all kinds and sorts of work. " The Sabbath was made for man," — for his benefit, comfort, and advantage. Works of mercy and of real necessity to man's life and animal existence on the Sabbath day, were never intended to be forbidden. — The other thing to be observed is our Lord's assertion of His own Divinity and equality with God the Father. When He said, " My Father worketh, and I also work/' He evidently meant much more than bringing forward His Father's example, though that of course is contained in His argument, and justifies all Christians in doing works of mercy on Sundays. What He meant was, "I am the beloved Son of God : I and My Father are one in essence, dignity, honour, and authority ; whatever He does I also do, and have right to do. He works and I also work. He gave you the Sabbath, and it is His day. I too, as one with Him, am Lord of the Sabbath." That the Jews saw this to be the meaning of His words seems clear from the next verse.

Report a mistake

Chrysostom remarks on this verse : — " If any one say, ' How doth the Father work, who ceased on the seventh day from all His works ? ' let him learn the manner in which He worketh. What is it ? He careth for, He holdeth together all that hath been made. When thou beholdest the sun rising, and the moon running in her path, the lakes, the fountains, the rivers, the rains, the course of nature in seeds, and in our own bodies and those of irrational beings, and all the rest, by means of which this universe is made up, then learn the ceaseless working of the Father." (Matt. v. 45 ; vi. 30.)

Schottgen quotes a remarkable saying of Philo Judaeus, — " God never ceases to work. Just as it is the property of fire to burn and of snow to be cold, so is it the property of God to work."

Ferus remarks on the great variety of arguments used by our Lord on various occasions, in reply to the superstitious views of the Jews about the Sabbath. One time He adduces the example of David eating the shew-bread, another time the example of the priests working in the Temple on the Sabbath, another time the readiness of the Jews to help an ox out of a pit on the Sabbath. All these arguments were used in defence of works of necessity and mercy. Here He takes higher ground still, — the example of His Father.

Report a mistake

John 5:18

Therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him

This short defence which our Lord made seems to have rankled in the minds of the Jews, and to have made them even more bitter against Him. What length of time is covered by this verse is not very plain. I am inclined to think that it implies some little pause between the 17th and 19th verses. Here again, as in the 16th verse, we have the imperfect tense all the way through. It must surely point at something of habit, both in the designs of the Jews against our Lord, and in our Lord's conduct, and in His language about His Father.

John 5:18 · Open Word Bible

18So the Jewish leaders were even more determined to kill Him. Besides breaking the Sabbath, He was speaking of God as His own Father, and so was making Himself equal to God.

Report a mistake

said also...his Father...equal with God

It is clear that our Lord's words about His Sonship struck the Jews in a far more forcible way than they seem to strike us. In a certain sense all believers are " sons of God." (Rom, viii. 14.) Bat it is evident that they are not so in the sense that our Lord meant when He talked of God as His Father, and Himself as God's Son. The Greek undoubtedly might be translated more clearly, "said that God was His own particular Father." (Compare Rom. viii. 32). The Jews at any rate accepted the words as meaning our Lord to assert His own peculiar Sonship, and His consequent entire equality with God the Father. Their charge and ground of anger against Him amounted to this : — " Thou callest God Thine own particular Father, and claimest authority to do whatsoever He does. By so doing Thou makest Thyself equal with God." And our Lord seems to have accepted this charge as a correct statement of the case, and to have proceeded to argue that He had a right to say what He had said, and that He really was equal with God. As St. Paul says, — " He thought it not robbery to be equal with God." (Phil. ii. 6.)

Augustine remarks, — " Behold the Jews understood what the Arians would not understand."

Whitby remarks that the Jews never accused our Lord of blasphemy for saying that he was the Messiah, but for saying that He was the Son of God, because they did not believe that Messiah when He appeared was to be a Divine Person.

Report a mistake

Ferus remarks that the Jews probably took notice of our Lord calling God " My Father," and not " our Father." — Cartwright also thinks that there is much weight in the expression "my," and that the Jews gathered from it that Christ claimed to be the only -begotten Son of God, and not merely a Son by adoption and grace.

Report a mistake

John 5:19

Then answered Jesus and said unto them

This verse begins a long discourse, in which our Lord formally defends himself from the charge of the Jews of laying claim to what He had no right to claim. (1.) He asserts His own Divine authority, commission, dignity, and equality with God His Father. (2.) He brings forward the evidence of His Divine commission, which the Jews ought to consider and receive. (3.) Finally, He tells the Jews plainly the reason of their unbelief, and charges home on their consciences their love of man's praise more than God's, and their inconsistency in pretending to honour Moses while they did not honour Christ. It is a discourse almost unrivalled in depth and majesty.

There are few chapters in the Bible, perhaps, where we feel our own shallowness of understanding so thoroughly, and discover so completely the insufficiency of all human language to express " the deep things of God." Men are often saying they want explanations of the mysteries of the Christian faith, the Trinity, the Incarnation, the person of Christ, and the like. Let them just observe, when we do find a passage full of explanatory statements on a deep subject, how much there is that we have no line to fathom and no mind to take in. " I want more light," says proud man. God gives him his desire in this chapter. and lifts up the veil a little. But behold 1 we are dazzled by the very light we wanted, and find we have not eyes to take it in.

John 5:19 · Open Word Bible

19So Jesus gave them this answer: "Truly, truly, I tell you, the Son cannot do anything on His own; He does only what He sees the Father doing. For what the Father does, the Son does as well, and in the same way.

Report a mistake

It has always been thought by many commentators that this solemn discourse of our Lord's was delivered before the Sanhedrim, or general Ecclesiastical Assembly of the Jews. They regard it as a formal defence of His Divinity and Messiahship, and a statement of evidence why He should be received, before a regularly constituted ecclesiastical court. — It may be so. Probabilities seem in favour of the idea. But it must be remembered that we have nothing but internal evidence in favour of the theory. There is not a word said to show that our Lord was formally brought before the Sanhedrim, and made a formal defence. — Some writers lay much stress upon the opening words of the 19th verse, — " Then answered Jesus and said," — and consider that these words imply a formal charge in court, and a formal reply from our Lord. It may be true. But we must remember that it is only a conjecture.

One thing only is certain. Nowhere else in the Gospels do we find our Lord making such a formal, systematic, orderly, regular statement of His own unity with the Father, His Divine commission and authority, and the proofs of His Messiahship, as we find in this discourse. To me it seems one of the deepest things in the Bible.

Report a mistake

Verily, verily, I say unto you

Here, as elsewhere, the remark applies, that this form of expression always precedes some statement of more than ordinary depth and importance.

[The Son can do nothing of himself, &c.] This opening verse declares ihe complete unity there is between God the Father and God the Son. The Son, from His very nature and relation to the Father, "can do nothing" independently or separately from the Father. It is not that He lacks or wants the power to do, but that He will not do. (Compare Gen. xix. 22.) When the angel said, " I cannot do anything till thou be come thither;" it means of course "'I will not do." — "Of himself" does not mean without help, or unassisted, but "from himself," from His own independent will. He can only do such things as, from His unity with the Father, and consequent ineffable knowledge, He "seeth" tLs Father doing. For the Father and the Son are so united, — one God though two Persons, — that whatsoever the Father does the Son does also. The acts of the Son therefore are not His own independent acts, but the acts of His Father also.

The Greek word which we render "likewise" must not be supposed to mean nothing more than "also, as well." It is literally " in like manner."

Bishop Hall paraphrases this saying of our Lord thus: — "1 and the Father are one indivisible essence, and our acts are no less inseparable. The Son can do nothing without the will and act of the Father ; and, even as He is man, can do nothing but what He seeth agreeable to the will and purpose of His heavenly Father."

Report a mistake

John 5:20

the Father loveth the Son, &c.

This verse carries on the thought begun in the preceding verse, — the unity of the Father and the Son. When we read the words, " The father loveth " and the "Father showeth," we must not for a moment suppose them to imply any superiority in the Father, or any inferiority in the Son, as to their Divine nature and essence. — The " love " is not the love of an earthly parent to a beloved child. The "showing" is not the showing of a teacher to an ignorant scholar. The " love " is meant to show us that unspeakable unity of heart and affection (if such words may be reverently used) which eternally existed and exists between the Father and the Son. The "showing" means that entire confidence and cooperation which there was between the Father and the Son as to all the works which the Son should do when He came into the world, to fill the office of Mediator, and to save sinners. — The "greater works,"which remained to be shown, were evidently the works specified in the two following verses, — the works of quickening and of judging. That the Jews did "marvel," and were confounded at the works of "quickening," we know from the Acts of the Apostles. That they will "marvel" even more at our Lord's work of judgment we shall see when Christ comes again to judge the heathen, to restore Jerusalem, to gather Israel, to convince the Jews of their unbelief, and to renew the face of the earth.

John 5:20 · Open Word Bible

20For the Father loves the Son and shows Him everything He Himself is doing. And there are greater works than these that He will show Him, so that you will be astonished.

Report a mistake

Both in this, and the preceding verse, we must carefully remember the utter inability of any human language, or human ideas, to express perfectly such matters as our Lord is speaking of. Language is intended specially to express the things of man. It fails greatly when used to express things about God. In the expressions "seeth the Father do," — "loveth the Son," — "showeth him all things," — " will show him greater works," — we must carefully bear this in mind. We must remember that they are expressions accommodated to our weaker capacities. They are intended to explain the relation between two divine Beings, who are one in essence, though two Persons, — one in mind and will, though two in manifestation, — equal in all things as touching the Godhead, though the Son is inferior to the Father as touching His manhood. There must needs be immense difficulty in finding words to convey any idea of the relation between these two Persons. Hence the language used by our Lord must be cautiously handled, with a constant recollection that we are not reading of an earthly father and son, but of God the Father and God the Son, who though one in essence as God, are at the same time two distinct Persons.

Augustine wisely remarks, " There are times when speech is deficient, even when the understanding is proficient. How much more doth speech suffer defect, when the understanding hath nothing perfect I "

Augustine and Bernard both remark, that it is far " greater work" to repair ruined human nature, than to make it at first, and to re-create it, than to create it.

Report a mistake

John 5:21–22

as the Father raiseth up the dead, &c.

Our Lord here proceeds to tell the Jews one of His mighty works which He had come to do, in proof of His divine nature, authority, and commission. Did they find fault with Him for making Himself equal with God ? Let them know that He had the same power as God the Father to give "life" and quicken the dead. Let them know furthermore, that all "judgment" was committed to Him. Surely He who had in His hand the mighty prerogatives of giving life and judging the world, had a right to speak of himself as equal with God 1

When we read "the Father raiseth up the dead, and quickeneth them," we must either understand the words to refer generally to God's power to raise the dead at the last day, — which the Jew would allow as an article of faith, and a special attribute of divinity, — or else we must understand it to apply to the power of spiritually quickening men's souls, which God had from the beginning exercised in calling men from death to life, — or else we must simply take it to mean that to give life, whether bodily or spiritual, is notoriously the peculiar attribute of God. The last view appears to me the most probable one, and most in harmony with what follows in after verses.

When we read " the Son quickeneth whom he wills," we have a distinct assertion of the Son's authority to give life at His will, either bodily or spiritual, with the same irresistible power as the Father. The highest of all gifts He has but to " will " and to bestow. The Greek word translated " quickeneth," is very strong. It is, literally, " makes alive," and seems to imply the power of making life of all kind, both bodily and spiritual.

John 5:21–22 · Open Word Bible

21For the Father raises the dead and brings them to life, and in the same way the Son brings to life whomever He chooses. 22Nor does the Father judge anyone; He has given the whole work of judging to the Son,

Report a mistake

Burkitt remarks, that it is never said of any prophet or apostle, that he did mighty works "at his will."

When we read " the Father judgeth no man, but hath committed all judgment to the Son," we must understand that in the economy of redemption, the Father has honoured the Son by devolving on Him the whole office of judging the world. It cannot of course mean that judgment is work with which the Father from His nature hath nothing to do, but that it is work which He has completely and entirely committed to the Son's hands. He that died for sinners, is He that will judge them. Thus it is written, — '• He will judge the world in righteousness by that man whom he hath ordained," (Acts xvii. 31.)

Burgon remarks, " There is an original, supreme, judicial power; and there is also a judicial power derived, given by commission.

Christ, p^ God, hath the first together with the Father : Christ, as man, hath the second from the Father,"

I think it highly probable that the " all judgment committed to the Son," includes not merely the final judgment of the last day, but the whole work of ordering, governing, and deciding the affairs of Gods kingdom. "To judge" is an expression constantly used in the Old Testament in the sense of " to rule." The meaning then would be, that the Father has given to the Son the office of King and Judge. The whole administration of the Divine government of the world is put into the hands of the Son, Christ Jesus. Everything connected with the rule of the church and world, as well as the last judgment, is placed in the Son's hands.

We should carefully mark the distinction between " quickening " and "judging" in the language of these two verses.

Report a mistake

(a.) It is not said that " the Father quickeneth no man," but hath committed the power of giving life to the Son. Had this been said, it would have contradicted the texts "no man can come unto Me except the Father draw him," and "the Spirit giveth life." (John vi. 44 ; 2 Cor. iii. 6.) Quickening is the work of all three Persons in the Trinity, of one as much as another.

(b). It is said that judgment is the special work of the second Person of the Trinity. It is not the peculiar office either of the Father, or the Spirit, but of the Son. There seems a fitness in this. He who was condemned by an unjust judgment, and died for sinners, is He whose office it will be to judge the world.

(c.) It is said that " the Son quickeneth whom he will " The power of giving life is as much the prerogative of the Son as of the Father, or of the Spirit. Surely this teaches us that to place the election of God the Father, or the work of the Spirit, before men, as the first and principal thing they should look at, is not good theology. Christ, after all, is the meeting-point between the Trinity and the world. It is His office to quicken as well as pardon. No doubt He quickeneth by the Spirit whom He sends into man's heart. But it is His prerogative to give life as well as peace. This ought to be remembered. There are some in this day who in a mistaken zeal put the work of the Father and the Spirit before the work of Christ.

Report a mistake

John 5:23

That all men should honour the Son, &c.

By these words our Lord teaches us that the Father would have the Son to receive equal honour with Himself We are to understand distinctly that there is no inferiority in the Son to the Father. He is equal to Him in dignity and authority. He is to be worshipped with equal worship. If any man fancies that to honour the Son equally with the Father, detracts from the Father's honour, our Lord declares that such a man is entirely mistaken. On the contary, " He that honoureth not the Son, honoureth not the Father that sent him." It was the mind and intention of the Father that the Son, as the Mediator between God and man, should receive honour from all men. The glory of His beloved Son is part of the Father's eternal counsels. Whenever therefore any one through ignorance or pride, or unbelief, neglects Christ, but professes at the same time to honour God, he is committing a mighty error, and so far from pleasing God, is greatly displeasing Him. The more a man honours Christ, and makes much of Him, the more the Father is pleased.

Evangelical Christians should mark the doctrine of this verse, and remember it. They are sometimes taunted with holding new views in religion, because they bring forward Christ so much more prominently than their fathers or grandfathers did. Let them see here that the more they exalt the Son of God and His office, the more honour they are doing to the Father who sent Him.

To the Deist and Socinian, the words of this verse are a strong condemnation. Not honouring Christ, they are angering God the Father. The Fatherhood of God, out of Christ, is a mere idol of man's invention, and incapable of comforting or saving.

John 5:23 · Open Word Bible

23so that everyone will honor the Son just as they honor the Father. Whoever refuses honor to the Son refuses it to the Father who sent Him.

Report a mistake

Alford remarks, "Whosoever does not honour the Son with equal honour to that which he pays to the Father, however he may imagine that he honours or approaches God, does not honour Him at all ; because he can only be known by us as 'the Father who sent his Son.'" — Barnes remarks, "If our Saviour here did not intend to teach that He ought to be worshipped and esteemed equal with God, it would be difficult to teach it by any language."

Rollock remarks, " The Jews and Turks in the present day profess to worship God earnestly, not only without the Son, but even with contempt of the Son Jesus Christ. But the whole of such worship is idolatrous, and that which they worship is an idol. There is no knowledge of the true God except in the face of the Son."

Wordsworth remarks, " They who profess zeal for the one God do not honour Him aright, unless they honour the Son as they honour the Father. This is a warning to those who claim the title of Unitarians, and deny the divinity of Christ. No one can be said to believe in the Divine Unity who rejects the doctrine of the Trinity."

The entire unity of the three Persons in the Trinity, is a subject that needs far more attention than many give to it. It may be feared that many well-meaning Christians are tritheists or worshippers of three distinct Gods, without knowing it. They talk as if God the Father's mind towards sinners was one thing-, and God the Son's another, — as if the Father hated man, and the Son loved him and protected him. Such persons would do well to study this part of Scripture, and to mark the unity of the Father and the Son.

Report a mistake

After all, that deep truth, " the eternal generation " of God the Son, whatever proud man may say of it, is the foundation truth which we must never forget in trying to understand a passage like that before us. In the Trinity " none is afore or after other. The Father is eternal : the Son eternal : the Holy Ghost eternal. The Father is God : the Son is God : the Holy Ghost is God. And yet there are not three eternals, but one eternal : not three Gods, but one God." — As Burgon remarks, '•' There never was a time when any one of the three Persons was not ;" and it might be added, there never was a time when the three Persons were not equal. And yet the Son was begotten of the Father from all eternity, and the Holy Ghost proceeded from all eternity from the Father and the Son.

Report a mistake

John 5:24–29

JOHN V. 24—29.

The passage before us is singularly rich in weighty truths. To the minds of Jews, who were familiar with the writings of Moses and Daniel, it would come home with peculiar power. In the words of our Lord they would not fail to see fresh assertions of His claim to be received as the promised Messiah.

We see in these verses that the salvation of our souls depends on hearing Christ. It is the man, we are told, who " hears Christ's word," and believes that God the Father sent Him to save sinners, who " has everlasting life." Such " hearing " of course is something more than mere listening. It is hearing as a humble scholar, --hearing as an obedient disciple, — hearing with faith and love, — hearing with a heart ready to do Christ's will, — this is the hearing that saves. It is the very hearing of which God spoke in the famous prediction of a " prophet like unto Moses :" — " Unto him shall ye hearken." — " Whosoever will not hearken unto my words which he shall speak in my name, I will require it of him." (Deut. xviii. 15—19.)

To " hear " Christ in this way, we must never forget, is just as needful now as it was eighteen hundred years ago. It is not enough to hear sermons, and run after preachers, though some people seem to think this makes up the whole of religion. We must go much further than this : we must " hear Christ." To submit our hearts to Christ's teaching, — to sit humbly at His feet by faith, and learn of Him, — to enter His school as penitents, and become His believing scholars, — to hear His voice and follow Him, — this is the way to heaven. Till we know something experimentally of these things, there is no life in us.

John 5:24–29 · Open Word Bible

24Truly, truly, I tell you, anyone who hears My word and believes the one who sent Me has eternal life. Such a person does not come under condemnation, but has already moved out of death into life. 25Truly, truly, I tell you, an hour is coming, and in fact it has already begun, when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear it will live. 26For just as the Father has life in Himself, so He has given the Son life in Himself as well. …

Report a mistake

John 5:24

Verily, verily, I say

Here, as in other places, these words are the preface to a saying of more than ordinary solemnity and importance.

[He that heareth my word.] The " hearing" here is much more than mere listening, or hearing with the ears. It means hearing / with the heart, hearing with faith, hearing accompanied by obedient discipleship. He that so hears the doctrine, teaching, or "word " of Christ, hath life. It is such hearing as that of the true sheep : " My sheep hear my voice," (John x. 27,) or as that spoken of by St, Paul: "Ye have not so learned Christ, if so be that ye have heard him, and have been taught by him." (Eph. iv. 21.)

John 5:24 · Open Word Bible

24Truly, truly, I tell you, anyone who hears My word and believes the one who sent Me has eternal life. Such a person does not come under condemnation, but has already moved out of death into life.

Report a mistake

believeth on him that sent me

This must not be supposed to mean that a vague faith in God, such as the Deist professes to have, is the way to everlasting life. The belief spoken of is a believing on God in Christ, — a believing on God as the God who sent Christ to save sinners, — a believing on God as the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has planned and provided redemption by the blood of His Son. He who so believes on God the Father, is the same man that believes in God the Son. In this sense the Father is just as much the- object of saving faith as the Son. Thus we read, " It shall be imputed if we believe on him who raised up Jesus our Lord from the dead." (Rom. iv. 24.) And again, " Who by him do believe in God, that raised him up from the dead, and gave him glory, that your faith and hope might be in God." (1 Pet. i. 21.) He that rightly believes on Christ as his Saviour, with the same faith believes in God as his reconciled Father. The Gospel that invites the sinner to believe in Jesus as his Redeemer and Advocate, invites him at the same time to believe in the Father, who is " well pleased " with all who trust in His Son.

Henry remarks, "Christ's design is to bring us to God. (1 Pet. iii. 18.) As God is the first original of all grace, so is He the ultimate object of all faith. Christ is our way, and God ia our rest. We must believe on God as having sent Jesus Christ, and recommended Himself to our faith and love, by manifesting His glory in the face of Jesus Christ."

Report a mistake

Lightfoot remarks, " He doth most properly centre the ultimate fixing and resting of belief in God the Father. For as from Him, as from a fountain, do flow all those things that are the object of faith, — namely free grace^ the gift of Christ, the way of redemption, the gracious promises, — so unto Him as to that fountain doth faith betake itself in its final resting and repose, — namely to God in Christ.'

Chemnitius remarks, that the expression " believe on Him who sent me," shows " that true faith embraces the word of the Gospel, not as something thought out by Christ alone, but as something decreed in the secret counsel of the whole Trinity."

Report a mistake

John 5:25

Verily, verily, I say unto you

This emphatic - preface here begins a prophecy of the wonderful things that should yet be done by the Son of God. Did the Jews of Jerusalem desire to know what proofs of Divine power and authority the Son of God would give ? Let them hear what he would do.

[The hour is coming and now is.] This meant that a time was coming, and in fact had already begun.

[The dead shall hear His voice and live.] It is thought by some that these words apply to the literal raising again of dead persons, such as Lazarus at Bethany. I cannot think it I believe that the " dead " here spoken of are the spiritually dead. I believe that the " hearing the voice of the Son of God," means the hearing of faith. I believe that the "living" spoken of means the rising out of the death of sin to spiritual newness of life. And I believe that the whole verse is a prediction of the many conversions of dead sinners that were to take place soon, and had begun in some measure to take place already. The prediction was fulfilled when dead souls were converted during our Lord's own ministry, and was much more fulfilled after the day of Pentecost, when He was preached by His apostles to the Gentiles, and "believed on in the world." (1 Tim. iii. 16.)

To confine the words to the few cases of miraculous raising of dead bodies which took place in the time of our Lord and His apostles, appears to supply a very inadequate interpretation, and to be rendered unnecessary by the succeeding verse.

Let it be noted that it is only those who " hear," or " have heard " with faith the voice of Christ, that live. Spiritual life turns on believing. "Ye also trusted, after that ye heard the word of truth." (Eph. i. 13.)

John 5:25 · Open Word Bible

25Truly, truly, I tell you, an hour is coming, and in fact it has already begun, when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear it will live.

Report a mistake

Ferus and Cocceius think that the calling and conversion of the Gentiles was the principal thought in our Lord's mind when He spoke these words.

Report a mistake

John 5:26

For as the Father, &c.

The first part of this verse needs no explanation. It is an admitted principle that God is the Author and Source of all life. He " hath life in himself." When it says further that " he hath given to the Son to have life in himself," we must not suppose it means that He has bestowed it on His Son, in the same way that He gives gifts to mere men, such as prophets and apostles. It rather means that in His everlasting counsels concerning man s redemption. He has appointed that the Second Person of the Trinity, — His beloved Son, — should be the Dispenser and Giver of life to all mankind. " God has given to us eternal life, and this life is in his Son." (1 John v. 11.)

Both here and in the following verse we must remember that "giving" does not imply any inferiority in the Son to the Father, so far as concerns His Divine essence. The things " given" to the Son were things solemnly appointed, deputed, and laid upon Him when He assumed the office of Mediator, in virtue of His office.

Burgon remarks, — " Both the Father and the Son have the same life; both have it in themselves; both in the same degree ; as the one so the other ; but only with this difference, — the Father from all eternity giveth it, the Son from all eternity receiveth it."

John 5:26 · Open Word Bible

26For just as the Father has life in Himself, so He has given the Son life in Himself as well.

Report a mistake

John 5:27

And hath given him authority, &c.

This means that in virtue of His Mediatorial office the Second Person of the Trinity ia specially appointed to be the Judge of all mankind. In the counsels of God concerning man, "judgment" is assigned to the Son, and not to the Father, or to the Holy Spirit. It is undoubtedly true that God is " the Judge of all." (Heb. xii. 23.) But it is also true that it is God the Son who will execute judgment^ and sit on the throne at the last day.

[Because he is the Son of man.] These words seem to imply that there is a connection between our Lord's incarnation and His filling the office of the Judge. It is because He humbled Himself to take our nature on Him, and be born of the Virgin Mary, that he will at length be exalted to execute judgment at the last day. It appears to be the same thought that St. Paul expresses when he tells the Philippians that because of Christ's humiliation, " God also hath highly exalted him, and given him a name which is above every name," etc. (Phil. ii. 9.)

Burgon remarks, — " Because of His alliance with man's nature, because of His sense of man's infirmities, because of all He did and suffered for man's sake as the Son of man, the Son is that Person of the Trinity who is most fit, as well as most worthy, to be man's judge."

The expression, " The Son of man," would be rendered more literally, " a Son of man," or, " Son of man," Campbell remarks that the absence of the article " the" before the words " Son of man," occurs nowhere in the Gospels except in this passage.

John 5:27 · Open Word Bible

27He has also given Him authority to pass judgment, since He is the Son of Man.

Report a mistake

Both in this and the preceding verse we should observe an example of the great truth, that " order is heaven's first law." Even the Second Person in the Trinity, one with the Father, very and eternal Gol, does not take on Himself the office of giving life and executing judgment, but receives it through the solemn appointment of God the Father. Just as it is written, — " Christ glorified not himself to be made an high priest, but he that said unto him, Thou art my .Son " (Heb. v. 5), so we find it written here, that in taking on Him the office of Mediator, it was ^^ given ^ to Him to have life in Himself, and "authority given to him" to judge. Those who take on themselves offices without either divine or human commission are very unlike our Lord.

Toletus quotes a remarkable passage from Athanasius, in which he points o it that such expressions as, '^ given to the Son by the Father," ' received by the Son from the Father," are purposely used in order to prevent the Sabellian heresy of supposing that the Father and the Son are one and the same Person. — Such expressions are an unanswerable proof that the Father and the Son are two distinct Persons, though one God. We must never forget the words of the Athanasian creed,— " Neither confounding the Persons nor dividing the substance."

Report a mistake

John 5:28–29

Marvel not at this

These words imply that the hearers of our Lord were astonished at the things He had spoken concerning His Divine commission to give life and to judge. He proceeds to tell them that they have not yet heard all. If they wondered at what they had already heard, what would they think when He told them one thing more ?

[The hour is coming.] This means the last day. To use the present tense of a time so distant as this is characteristic of one who is very God, to whom time past, time present, and time to come, are all alike, and a thousand years are as one day.

[All that are in the graves shall hear his voice..,come forth... damnation, etc.] These words are singularly like those in Daniel xii. 2. They contain one of the most distinct statements in Scripture of that great truth, — the resurrection of the dead. — It shall be universal, and not confined to a few only. "AH "in the graves shall come forth, whether old or young, rich or poor. — It shall take place at Christ's command and bidding. His " voice" shall be the call that shall summon the dead from their graves.-^ There shall be a distinction of those who rise again, into two classes. Some shall rise to glory and happiness, — to what is called a " resurrection of life," Some shall rise to be lost and ruined for ever, — to what is called a " resurrection of damnation." — The doings of men shall be the test by which their final state shall be decided. " Life" shall be the portion of those that have " done good," " damnation" of those that " have done evil," in the resurrection-day.

John 5:28–29 · Open Word Bible

28Do not be astonished at this. An hour is coming when everyone in the tombs will hear His voice 29and come out. Those who have done good will come out to a resurrection that brings life; those who have done evil, to a resurrection that brings condemnation.

Report a mistake

(a.) This passage condemns those who fancy that this world is all, and that this life ends everything, and that the grave is the conclusion. They are awfully mistaken. There is a resurrection and a life to come.

(6.) This passage condemns those who try to persuade us in the present day that there is no future punishment, no hell, no condemnation for the wicked in the world to come, — that the love of God is lower than hell, — that God is too merciful and compassionate to punish any one. There is a " resurrection," we are told, "of damnation."

(c.) This passage condemns those who try to make out that resurrection is the peculiar privilege of believers and saints, and that the wicked will be punished by complete annihilation. Both here and in Acts xxiv. 15 we are distinctly told that both bad and good shall rise again. In St. Paul's famous chapter about the resurrection (1 Cor. xv.), the resurrection of believers only is treated of.

(d.) This passage condemns those who try to make out that men's lives and conduct are of little importance so long as they profess to have faith and to believe in Christ. Christ himself tells us expressly that the "doings " of men, whether good or evil, will be the evidence that shall decide whether they rise again to glory or condemnation.

Report a mistake

Musculus remarks that the goodness which God requires of us is not such as only begins in the next world, after the resurrection. We must have it now, and it must precede the time of judgment. It is not said, "some shall rise again that they may be made good and partakers of life," but, " they that have done good shall come forth to a resurrection of life." We should take care to be such in this life as we desire to be found in the day of judgment. — He also remarks that our Lord does not say, "those who have known or talked what is good," but, " those who have actually done good " shall come forth to a resurrection of life. Those only will be found to have " done good " who are God's elect, born again, and true believers. Nothing but true faith will bear the fruit of good works.

Calvin remarks that our Lord is not here speaking of the cause of salvation, but of the marks of the saved, and that one great mark which distinguishes the elect from the reprobate, is good doing.

There are two different Greek words used to express the English words " they that have done," and it is difficult to say why. Precisely the same difference exists in John iii. 20, 21. The attempts made to explain the distinction between the two words do not appear to me very successful. For instance, — Wordsworth remarks : " Good made and done has permanence for ever. Evil is practised, but produces no fruit for eternity." Yet I doubt whether this remark will apply to Rom. i. 32, and ii. 3, where both the two Greek words for " doing " are used together, and applied to the same class of persons, viz., the wicked.

Report a mistake

John 5:30–39

JOHN V. 30—39.

Let us observe for one thing in this passage, the honour Christ puts on His faithful servants. See how He speaks of John the Baptist. — "He bare witness of the truth ;" — " He was a burning and a shining light." — John had probably passed away from his earthly labours when these words were spoken. He had been persecuted, imprisoned, and put to death by Herod, — none interfering, none trying to prevent his murder. But this murdered disciple was not forgotten by his Divine Master. If no one else remembered him, Jesus did. He had honoured Christ, and Christ honoured him.

These things ought not to be overlooked. They are written to teach us that Christ cares for all His believing people, and never forgets them. Forgotten and despised by the world, perhaps, they are never forgotten by their Saviour. He knows where they dwell, and what their trials are. A book of remembrance is written for them. " Their tears are all in His bottle." (Psalm lvi. 8.) Their names are graven on the palms of His hands. He notices all they do for Him in this evil world, though they think it not worth notice, and He will confess it one day publicly, before His Father and the holy angels. He that bore witness to John the Baptist never changes. Let believers remember this. In their worst estate they may boldly say with David, — " I am poor and needy ; yet the Lord thinketh upon me." (Psalm xl. 17.)

Let us observe, for another thing, the honour Christ puts upon miracles^ as an evidence of His being the Messiah. He says, — " The works which the Father hath given me to finish, the same works that I do, bear witness of me that the Father hath sent me."

John 5:30–39 · Open Word Bible

30I cannot do anything on My own. I judge according to what I hear, and the judgment I give is just, because I am not seeking to do My own will, but the will of the one who sent Me. 31If I testify on My own behalf, My testimony is not true. 32Someone else is testifying about Me, and I know that the testimony He gives about Me is true. …

Report a mistake

John 5:30

can of mine own self, &c.

This verse is perhaps one of the most difficult in Scripture. It is so because the subject of it is that great mystery, — the unity of God the Father and God the Son. Man has no language to express adequately the idea that has to be conveyed. The general thought of the verse seems to be as follows : —

" In consequence of the close relation between Me and the Father, I cannot do anything independently and separately from Him. 'I judge,' and decide, and speak on all points, in entire harmony with the Father, as though I heard Him continually at My side ; and so judging and speaking My judgment on all points is always right. It is right now, and will be seen right at the great account of the last day. For in all that I do I seek not to do My Own will only, but the will of Him that sent Me, since there is an entire harmony between My will and His."

Let it be carefully noted that at this part of His address our Lord ceases to speak in the third person of Himself as " the Son of man," and begins to use the first person, — "I can," "I hear," " I judge," etc.

" Of mine own self" does not mean "unhelped and unassisted," but "from myself," — from My own independent volition and action.

Chrysostom remarks, — " Just as when we say, it is impossible for God to do wrong, we do not impute to Him any weakness, but confess in Him an unutterable power; so also when Christ saith, ' I can of my own self do nothing,' the meaning is that it is impossible, — my nature admits not, — that I should do anything contrary to the Father."

John 5:30 · Open Word Bible

30I cannot do anything on My own. I judge according to what I hear, and the judgment I give is just, because I am not seeking to do My own will, but the will of the one who sent Me.

Report a mistake

" As I hear" is an expression adapted to man's comprehension, to convey the idea of the unity between the Father and the Son. It is like verse 19th, where it is said, " The Son can do nothing of himself, but what he seeth the Father do." It is also like the words used of the Holy Ghost, — " He shall not speak of himself, but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall he speak." (John xvi. 13.)

Chrysostom remarks, — " Just as when Christ said, ' we speak that we do know, and testify that we have seen,' and John the Baptist said, * that which he hath seen and heard he testifieth,' (John iii, 11, 32,) both expressions are used concerning exact knowledge, and not concerning mere 'seeing' and 'hearing;' — so in this place, when Christ speaks of 'hearing,' He declares nothing else than that it is impossible for Him to desire anything save what the Father desireth."

"I judge" applies not only to all Christ's judgments and decisions as Mediator when He was upon earth, but to His final judgment at the last day.

'■ My judgment is just" would probably remind the Jews of the prophecies about Messiah. (Isa. xi. 3 and Dan. vii. 13.)

Report a mistake

Chrysostom remarks, — "What Christ implieth is of this kind : — not that the will of the Father is one and His own another, but that as one will in one mind, so is Mine own will and My Father's."

Once more we must remember the extreme difficulty of handling such a subject as the one before us. The distinction between the Persons in the Trinity, and the Unity of their essence at the same time, must always be a deep thing to man, hard to conceive, and harder still to speak or write about.

Report a mistake

John 5:31

bear witness of myself, &c.

This verse must be interpreted with caution and reasonable qualification. It would be folly and blasphemy to say that our Lord's testimony about Himself must be false. What the verse does appear to mean is this : — " If I have no other testimony to bring forward in proof of My Messiahship but My own word, my testimony would be justly open to suspicion." — Our Lord knew that in any disputed question a man's assertions in his own favour are worth little or nothing. He tells the Jews that He did not want them to believe Him merely because He said He was the Son of God. He would show them that He had other witnesses, and these witnesses He next proceeds to bring forward. A comparison of this verse with John viii. 14 shows at once that the meaning of the words, " My witness is not true," must be qualified and restrained, or else one place of Scripture would contradict the other.

John 5:31 · Open Word Bible

31If I testify on My own behalf, My testimony is not true.

Report a mistake

John 5:32

There is another that beareth witness

There are two distinct and different views of this expression.

(a.) Some, as Chrysostom, Theophylact, Euthymius, Lightfoot, Brentius, Grotius, Ferus, Barradius, Quesnel, Whitby, Doddridge, Gill, think that the "other witness" is John the Baptist.

(b.) Some, as Cyril, Athanasius, Calvin, Beza, Gualter, Bucer, Ecolampadius, Zwingle, Rupertus, Flacius, Calovius, Cocceius, Piscator, Musculus, Aretius, Toletus, Nifanius, Rollock, Poole, Leigh, Diodati, Hammond, Trapp, Hutcheson, Henry, Burkitt, Baxter, Bloomfield, Lampe, Bengel, Pearce, A. Clarke, Scott. Barnes, Stier, Alford, Webster, think that "the other witness," is God the Father.

I feel no doubt in my own mind that this last is the correct view. The use of the present tense, — " witnesseth,"— is a strong proof of it. John the Baptist's testimony was a thing past and gone. — Our Lord declares that His Father had borne distinct testimony to Him, and supplied abundant evidence, if they, the Jews, would only receive it. And He adds, "his testimony is true." He will never bear witness to a lie. — Then having laid down this general proposition, He goes on to show the threefold testimony which God had provided : — first, John the Baptist; — secondly, the miracles which the Father had commissioned Him to work ; — and, thirdly, the Scriptures.

The expression, " I know," probably implies the deep consciousness which our Lord had, even in His humiliation, of His Father's perfect righteousness and truthfulness. It means much more than a mere man's " I know." " I know and have known from all eternity that my Father's testimony is perfect truth."

John 5:32 · Open Word Bible

32Someone else is testifying about Me, and I know that the testimony He gives about Me is true.

Report a mistake

John 5:33

Ye sent unto John, &c.

In this sentence the word "ye " must be taken emphatically. It is " ye yourselves." The meaning of the verse seems to be, — " My first witness is John the Baptist. Now ye yourselves sent unto him at an early period of his ministry, and ye know that he told you One greater than himself was coming, whose messenger he was, and that afterwards he said of Me, ' Behold the Lamb of God.' You cannot deny that he was a prophet indeed. Yet he bore faithful witness unto Me. He told you the truth."

There can be no doubt that our Lord refers to the formal mission of "priests and Levites from Jerusalem " to John the Baptist, described in John i. 19.

John 5:33 · Open Word Bible

33You yourselves sent messengers to John, and he has testified to the truth.

Report a mistake

John 5:34

But I receive not testimony from man

This sentence seems meant to remind the Jews that they must not suppose our Lord depended either solely or chiefly on man's testimony. "Not that I would have you think I rest My claim to be received as the Messiah on the witness of John the Baptist, or of any other man. But I say these things about John and his witness to Me in order to remind you of what you heard him say, and that remembering his testimony to Me you may believe and be saved."

Here, as elsewhere, we should note how our Lord presses home on the Jews the inconsistency of admitting John the Baptist to be a prophet sent from God, while they refused to believe Himself as the Messiah. If they believed John they ought in consistency to have believed Him. (See Matt. xxi. 23 — 27.)

John 5:34 · Open Word Bible

34Yet I do not accept testimony from a human being; I say these things so that you may be saved.

Report a mistake

John 5:35

He was a burning...light

This is very high testimony to John. Doubtless he was not " the light," as Christ was. But still he was not an ordinary lamp lighted from above, as all true believers are. He was pre-eminently " the lamp," a lamp of peculiar power and brilliancy, a "burning " and a " shining" light like a flaming beacon or light-house seen from afar.

I think the expression "he was " shows that at the time when our Lord spoke, John the Baptist was either in prison or dead. At any rate his public ministry was ended. " He used to be a light. He is burning and shining no longer."

Chrysostom remarks, — " He called John a torch or lamp, signifying that he had not light of himself, but by the grace of the Spirit."

John 5:35 · Open Word Bible

35John was the lamp that burned and shone, and for a little while you were glad to rejoice in his light.

Report a mistake

ye were willing for a season to rejoice

This refers to the extraordinary popularity and acceptance of John the Baptist when his ministry first began. " Then went out unto him Jerusalem and all Judaea, and all the country round about Jordan." (Matt, iii. 5.) " Many of the Pharisees and Sadducees came to his baptism." (Matt. iii. 7.) It was an ignorant excitement that brought many of John's hearers to him. They thought most probably, that the Messiah, of whom he spoke, and whose way he came to prepare, would be a temporal king and conqueror, and would give to Israel its old pre-eminence on earth. But be the motives what they might, the fact remains that John's ministry attracted immense attention, and awakened the curiosity of the whole Jewish nation. "They willingly rejoiced in the light which John lifted up," They seemed to take pleasure in coming to him, hearing him, following him, and submitting to his baptism.

The expression, "for a season," seems purposely used to remind the Jews of the very temporary and transitory nature of the impressions which John's ministry produced on them.

Stier remarks, — "Man generally, even a prophet, can only give light by burning, like a lighted candle, until he is burnt out, and his mission on earth ceases. Thus did the Baptist burn, brightly but rapidly."

Report a mistake

John 5:36

But I have greater witness...John

This means, " although John the Baptist was a witness to My being the Messiah, and the Son of God, his was not the only testimony I bid you receive. There is testimony even more important than his, namely, that My miracles." The Greek means literally, " the greater witness;"— " The witness that I have is greater."

Flacius suggests that our Lord here and in the preceding verse reminds the Jews how willing they were at first to receive John's ministry, and almost seemed to think he was the Messiah. Yet all this time "John did no miracle." — But when the true Messiah appeared, doing mighty " works," the Jews did not show him even as much attention as they had shown to John.

John 5:36 · Open Word Bible

36But I have a testimony greater than John's. The works the Father has given Me to bring to completion, the works themselves that I am doing, testify about Me: they show that the Father has sent Me.

Report a mistake

the works...Father hath given, &c.

This is a distinct appeal to miracles, as an important proof of our Lord's Messiahship and Divinity. Four times in this Gospel we find the same appeal. (John iii. 2; x. 25 ; xv. 24.) The evidence of miracles should never be lightly esteemed. We are apt to underrate their value because they were wrought so long ago. But in the days when they were wrought they were great facts, which demanded the attention of all who saw them, and could not be evaded. Unless the Jews could explain them away, they were bound, as honest and reasonable men, to believe our Lord's Divine mission. That they really were wrought the Jews never appear to have denied. In fact they dared not attempt to deny them. What they did do was to ascribe them to Satanic agency. All who attempt to deny the reality of our Lord's miracles in the present d y, would do well to remember that those who had the best opportunity of judging, namely, the men who saw these miracles, and lived within hearing of them, never disputed the fact that they were wrought. If the enemies of our Lord could have proved that His miracles were only tricks, legerdemain, and impostures, it stands to reason they would have been only too glad to show it to the world, and to silence Him for ever.

Report a mistake

Five things should always be noted about our Lord's miracles. (1.) Their number : they were not a few only, but very many indeed. (2.) Their greatness : they were not little, but mighty interferences with the ordinary course of nature. (3.) Their publicity : they were generally not done in a corner, but in open day, and before many witnesses, and often before enemies. (4.) Their character : they were almost always works of love, mercy, and compassion, helpful and beneficial to man, and not mere barren exhibitions of power. (5.) Their direct appeal to mens senses : they were visible, and would bear any examination. The difference between them and the boasted miracles of the Church of Rome, on all these points, is striking and instructive.

The manner in which our Lord speaks of His miracles is very remarkable. He calls them, — " The worlds that the Father hath given me that I should finish." He carefully avoids the appearance of want of unity between the Father and Himself, even in the working of miracles. They are not works which He did of His own independent will, but " works which the Father hath given me," works which it had been arranged in the eternal counsels the Son should work, when He became man and dwelt upon earth. Precisely the same expression is used elsewhere about " the words " our Lord spake, as here about " the works:" "I have given unto them the words which thou gavest me." (John xvii. 8.)

Report a mistake

John 5:37

And the Father himself...witness of me

There is undeniable difficulty about these words. It is not clear to what " witness of the Father " our Lord here refers.

(a..) Some, as Chrysostom, Brentius, Bullinger, Gualter, Ferus, Toletus, Barradius, Cartwright, Chemnitius, Rollock, Jansenius, Trapp, Baxter, Hammond, Burkitt, Lampe, Bengel, Henry, Scott, Gill, think that our Lord refers to the audible testimony borne to Him by the Father at His baptism, and at the transfiguration, when He said, — "This is my beloved Son, hear him." (Matt. iii. 17 ; xvii. 5.) But it surely is a capital objection to this theory, that this voice of the Father was in all probability heard by nobody excepting John the Baptist at the baptism, and Peter, James, and John at the transfiguration. At this rate it would be entirely a private testimony, and of no avail to the general body of the Jewish nation.

(b.) Some, as Theophylact, Euthymius, Rupertus, Calvin, Cocceius, Pearce, Tholuck, Bloomfield, Tittman, A. Clark, D. Brown, Alford, Burgon, think that our Lord refers to the testimony the Father has borne to Him generally throughout the Old Testament Scriptures, and that the sentence before us should be taken in close connection with the next verse but one, beginning, " Search the Scriptures." In fact that expression would then be the explanation of our Lord's meaning.

Of the two views I decidedly prefer the second one. It certainly seems the least difficult, and open to the fewest objections. There is a third view, supported by Olshausen and Bucer, viz., that the " witness " here means the inward witness of the Spirit in the hearts of believers. This, however, appears to me wholly out of the question. It is a witness that would be useless to the world at large.

John 5:37 · Open Word Bible

37And the Father who sent Me has testified about Me Himself. Not once have you heard His voice or seen His form.

Report a mistake

Both here and elsewhere we must take care that we do not attach the idea of " inferiority " to the expression "sent '" by the Father. Rollock remarks, — " It is quite possible that an equal may send an equal to discharge some office." Cyril remarks, — " Mission and obedience, being sent and obeying, do not take away equality of power in the sender and the sent one."

[ Ye have neither heard.... seen his shape.] This appears to be a parenthetical sentence, as well as the verse that follows. It certainly seems to strengthen the view that when our Lord spoke of His Father " bearing witness," He could not have meant the audible witness of His voice at the baptism or transfiguration. In fact the sentence seems purposely to preclude the notion. It is as though our Lord said, " Do not suppose that I mean any audible testimony of voice, or apparition, or vision, when I speak of My Father bearing witness to me. I mean testimony of a very different kind, even the testimony of His Word."

The expression " not seen His shape," teaches the same great truth we find elsewhere, — viz., that the Father is invisible, and has never been seen by mortal man. He who appeared to Abraham was the Second Person of the Trinity, and not the Father. St. Paul says distinctly of the Father, — " whom no man hath seen, nor can see." (1 Tim. vi. 17.) The idea of artists and painters, when they represent the Father as an aged man, is a mere irreverent invention of their own brains, without the slightest warrant of Scripture.

Rupertus and Ferus suggest that the latter part of this verse was spoken to prevent the Jews thinking that our Lord spoke of Joseph, His supposed father. This, however, seems a rather improbable and fanciful idea.

Report a mistake

John 5:38

And ye have not his word, &c.

This verse seems meant to remind the Jews that with all their pretended reverence for God, and affected zeal against blasphemies of Him, they were really ignorant of God's mind. Their reverence for Him was only a form. Their zeal for Him was a blind fanaticism. They knew no more of His mind than of His shape or voice. They were not acquainted with His Word. It did not dwell in their hearts and guide their religion. They proved their own ignorance by not believing Him whom the Father had sent. Had they really been familiar with the writings of the Old Testament they would have believed.

Our Lord evidently implies that real knowledge of God's Word will always lead a man to faith in Christ. Where there is no faith we may rightly assume the Bible is either not read, or read in a wrong spirit. Ignorance and unbelief will go together.

Locke holds the curious opinion, that the " word" in this verse means the " Personal Word," as at John i. 1. " Ye have not Me, the Eternal Word, dwelling in your hearts." But Christ nowhere calls Himself " the Word," and the idea does not harmonize with the context.

Ecolampadius thinks that in this and the preceding verse there is a reference to Deut. xviii. 15 — 19, where the Lord promised a prophet to the Jews like unto Moses, because they had said, — • " Let me not hear again the voice of the Lord my God, neither let me see this great fire any more, that I die not." He thinks our Lord reminds them of this. God had fulfilled His promise, and sent them a prophet like unto Moses, and now they would not believe on Him !

John 5:38 · Open Word Bible

38And His word does not remain in you, since you do not believe the very one He sent.

Report a mistake

John 5:39

Search the scriptures

This famous sentence is interpreted two different ways.

(a.) Some, as Cyril, Erasmus, Ecolampadius, Beza, Brentius, Piscator, Camero, Poole, Toletus, Lightfoot, Lampe, Bengel, Doddridge, Bloomfield, Tholuck, A. Clark, Scholefield, Barnes, Burgon, D. Brown, Webster, think that our Lord spoke in the indicative mood, simply making an assertion, — " Ye do search."

(&.) Some, as Chrysostom, Augustine, Theophylact, Euthymius, Luther, Calvin, Cartwright, Gualter, Grotius, Rollock, Ferus, Calovius, Jansenius, Cocceius, Barradius, Musculus, Nifanius, Maldonatus, Cornelius a Lapide, Leigh, Whitby, Hammond, Stier, Alford, Wordsworth, think that He spoke in the imperative mood, giving a command, — " Search," — as our version gives it.

I decidedly prefer this latter view. It is more forcible, and more in keeping with our Lord's general style of address. Above all it seems to me to agree far better with the context. Our Lord had told the Jews that His Father had borne witness of Him, though not by audible voice, nor by visible apparition. How then had He borne witness ? They would find it in His Word. " Go and search your own Scriptures," our Lord seems to say. " Examine them, and become really acquainted with their contents; you will find that they testify clearly and distinctly of Me. If you wish to know God the Father's testimony to Me, search the Scriptures."

The word rendered "search" means " search minutely and diligently." It appears to me intentionally used, to show that the Jews should not be content with mere reading. The Septuagint version of Prov. ii. 4, has an expression like it.

John 5:39 · Open Word Bible

39You pore over the Scriptures, since you think that eternal life is to be found in them; and they are the ones that testify about Me.

Report a mistake

Chrysostom remarks, — " When Christ referred the Jews to the Scriptures, He sent them not to a mere reading, but to a careful and considerate search. He said not, 'read,' but, 'search,' Since the sayings about Him required great attention (for they had been concealed from the beginning for the advantage of men of that time). He bids them now dig down with care, that they might discern what lay in the depths below. These saying'? were not on the surface, nor were they cast forth to open view, but lay like some treasure hidden very deep,"

Some, who think the word "search" should be taken as an indicative, ''ye search," maintain that our Lord spoke ironically, and meant, " Ye pretend to make a minute investigation of Scripture, and search into the letter of it, but never get any further." I can see little ground for this view. The word " search" is never used in a bad sense in Scripture (1 Pet. i. 11.) The chief argument in favour of the " indicative" side of the question is the notorious Rabbinical custom of minutely scrutinizing and reverencing every syllable of Scripture. To this custom of honouring the letter of Scripture, while neglecting its spirit, many advocates of the "indicative" here think that our Lord referred. Brentius gives a full account of the length to which the Jews went in their reverence for the letter of Scripture, such as counting the letters of each book, etc., and thinks that this was in our Lord's mind. I cannot however agree with this view.

Report a mistake

in them ye think ye have eternal life

In this sentence the first " ye" must be taken emphatically, as in the 33rd verse. " Think" does not imply that it was a doubtful point, or mere matter of opinion. It is rather, " Ye yourselves think, and think rightly, — it is one of the dogmas of your faith, — that ye have in the Scriptures the way to eternal life pointed out."

Chemnitius remarks, — "The words 'ye think' mean that common persuasion and opinion of all men concerning Scripture, which, like an axiom in science, is established, firm, and certain."

Let it be noted that many Christians are just in the unsatisfactory state of the Jews here described. Like them, they " think," and hold it as a dogma of their creed, that they " have eternal life in the Scriptures." But, like them, they never read, mark, learn, and inwardly digest what Scripture contains.

Ecolampadius remarks, — "Scripture alone does not make a man any the better, nor even preaching, by itself, except by the Holy Ghost aiding. It is the peculiar office of the external Word to supply testimony ; but it is the Spirit of God alone that can make the heart of man assent."

Report a mistake

John 5:40–47

JOHN V. 40—47.

This passage concludes our Lord Jesus Christ's wondrous defence of His own divine mission. It is a conclusion worthy of the defence, full of heart- searching appeals to the consciences of His enemies, and rich in deep truths. A mighty sermon is followed by a mighty application.

Let us mark, in this passage, the reason why many souls are lost. The Lord Jesus says to the unbelieving Jews, — " Ye will not come to me that ye might have life."

These words are a golden sentence, which ought to be engraven in our memories, and treasured up in our minds. It is want of will to come to Christ for salvation that will be found, at last, to have shut the many out of heaven, — It is not men's sins. All manner of sin may be forgiven. — It is not any decree of God. We are not told in the Bible of any whom God has only created to be destroyed,— It is not any limit in Christ's work of redemption. He has paid a price sufficient for all mankind. — It is something far more than this. It is man's own innate unwillingness to come to Christ, repent, and believe. Either from pride, or laziness, or love of sin, or love of the world, the many have no mind, or wish, or heart, or desire to seek life in Christ. " God has given to us eternal life, and this life is in his Son." (1 John v. 11.) But men stand still, and will not stir hand or foot to get life. And this is the whole reason why many of the lost are not saved.

John 5:40–47 · Open Word Bible

40But you do not want to come to Me so that you can have life. 41Glory from people is not something I accept. 42But I know you, and there is no love for God in you. …

Report a mistake

John 5:40

And ye will not come to me...life

The connection between this verse and the preceding one is not very clear. It is one of those abrupt elliptical transitions which occur frequently in St. John's writings. I conjecture the link must be something of this kind : " The Scriptures testify plainly of Me. And yet in the face of this testimony ye have no will or inclination to come to Me by faith, that ye may have eternal life through Me."

This verse evidently begins the third part of our Lord's address to the Jews. He had declared the relation between Himself and God the Father, He had brought forward the evidence of His own Divine commission, and His claim to be received as the Messiah, And now He concludes by a most heart-piercing appeal to the consciences of His enemies, in which He exposes the true state of their hearts, and the real reasons why they did not believe in Him. If ever men were plainly dealt with, and received home- thrusts as to their own spiritual condition, it was on this occasion. In reading the conclusion of this chapter, one cannot but feel that a miraculous restraint must have been put on our Lord's enemies. Otherwise it is difficult to understand how they could have allowed Him to bring such cutting and truthful charges against them. If ministers desire a warrant for dealing plainly with their hearers, and addressing them directly and personally about their sins, they have only to look at their Divine Master's words in this passage.

John 5:40 · Open Word Bible

40But you do not want to come to Me so that you can have life.

Report a mistake

The opening charge that our Lord makes, " Ye will not come to me," misses much of its force in the English language. It is not the future tense of " come " that is used in the Greek. Two distinct verbs are employed. The right meaning is, " Ye do not will to come," — " Ye have no heart, desire, or inclination to come to Me."

Let it be noted here that (1.) we are all by nature dead in sins; — that (2.) spiritual life is laid up for sinners in Christ alone ; He is the fountain of life; — that (3.) in order to receive benefit from Christ men must come to him by faith, and believe: believing is coming; — and, finally, (4.) that the real reasons why men do not come to Christ, and consequently die in their sins, is their want of will to come.

Let it be carefully noted, that both here and elsewhere the loss of man's soul is always attributed in Scripture to man's own want of will to be saved. It is not any decree of God. It is not God's unwillingness to receive. It is not any limitation of Christ's redeeming work and atonement. It is not any want of wide, broad, free, full invitations to repent and believe. It is simply and entirely man's own fault. — his want of will. For ever let us cleave to this doctrine. Man's salvation, if saved, is entirely of God. Man's ruin, if lost, is entirely of himself. He " loves darkness rather than light." He will have his own way.

We should observe in this concluding part of our Lord's address, that He charges the Jews with four distinct sins: (1.)

want of real will to come to Him, (2.) want of real love to God, (3.) undue desire of man's praise, (4.) want of real faith in Moses' writings.

Report a mistake

John 5:41

receive not honour from men

The connection between these words and the preceding verse is again not very clear. I conjecture that it must be as follows : — " I do not say these things, as if I desired the praise and honour of man. I do not complain of your not coming to Me, as if I only came into the world to seek man's praise. It is not on My own account that I mention your unbelief, but on yours, because it shows the state of your hearts. Do not suppose that I stand in need of followers, and am covetous of man's favour."

John 5:41 · Open Word Bible

41Glory from people is not something I accept.

Report a mistake

John 5:42

But I know you...not the love of God, &c.

The sense and connection here appear to be as follows : — " But the plain truth is, that I know and have long known the state of your hearts, and I know that you have no real love of God in you. You profess to worship the one true God, and to give Him honour. But you show by your conduct, that with all your profession you do not really love God."

To a Jewish hearer this tremendous charge must have been peculiarly galling. It was a charge that none but our Lord could make with equal decision, because He read men's hearts, and knew what was in them.

The word " I know " is literally " I have known." Alford paraphrases the sentence, — " By long trial and bearing with your manners these many generations, and personally also, I have known, and do know you."

In another place we find our Lord naming this sin as one of the special sins of the Pharisees. "Woe unto you, Pharisees I for ye tithe mint and rue, and all manner of herbs, and pass over judgment and the love of God." (Luke xi. 42.)

Ferus remarks that the incredulity of the Jews did not arise from want of evidence, but want of love towards God.

John 5:42 · Open Word Bible

42But I know you, and there is no love for God in you.

Report a mistake

John 5:43

am come in my Father’s name...receive me not

This sentence contains a proof of the assertion made in the preceding verse. " You show that you have no real love for God, by your not receiving Me who have come in my Father's name, and desire nothing so much as His honour. If you really loved and honoured God as you professed to do, you would gladly receive and honour His Son."

[If another.. .in his own name, him ye will receive.] In this sentence our Lord supposes a case, to show the corrupt and carnal state of the Jews' hearts. " If another public teacher shall appear, giving himself out to be some great one, not seeking God's honour, and doing all in God's name, but aiming to exalt himself, and get honour to himself, you will receive and believe him. You reject Me the true Son of God. You are ready to receive any false pretender who comes among you, though he may give no honour to the God whom you profess to worship. It is true then that you have no real love of God in you."

I believe decidedly that our Lord spoke these words prophetically. He had in view the many false Christs and false Messiahs who arose within the first hundred years after His death, and by whom so many of the Jews were invariably deluded. According to Stier no less than sixty-four false Messiahs appeared to them, and were more or less believed.

The readiness with which they believed these impostors is a remarkable historical fact, and a striking fulfilment of the words before us. They proved as forward to believe these pretenders to a Divine mission who came in their own names, as they had been backward to believe our Lord.

John 5:43 · Open Word Bible

43I have come in the name of My Father, yet you do not accept Me. Should someone else come in his own name, him you will accept.

Report a mistake

I may add, however, that I am one of those who doubt whether the words of our Lord have even yet received their complete fulfilment. I think it highly probable that the world may yet see a personal Antichrist arise, who will succeed in obtaining credence from a vast portion of the Jewish nation. Then, and not till then, when Antichrist has appeared, this verse will be completely accomplished. Chrysostom, Cyril, Theophylact, Euthymius, Alcuin, Heinsius, take this view.

Stier remarks, "He of whom the Lord here prophecies, is finally Antichrist, with his-open and avowed denial of God and of Christ; with his most daring 'I,' before which all the proud will humbly bow down, because they will find themselves in him, and will honour him as their true God. As the Father reveals Himself in Christ, so will Satan manifest himself in Antichrist, and give him all his work and witness, and his own honour as the prince of this world ; and the wicked will yield themselves to him, because through unbelief they have already fallen into his nature, and fitly belong to him."

Wordsworth remarks, " The Fathers were generally of opinion, grounded on this passage, that Antichrist would be received by the Jews."

Report a mistake

John 5:44

How can ye believe, &c.

This verse contains a very important principle. The substance of the meaning seems to be as follows : — Our Lord tells the Jews that they were not likely to believe, so long as they cared more for the praise of man than the praise of God. The true cause of their unbelief was a want of honesty and godly sincerity. With all their professed zeal for God, they did not really care so much for pleasing Him as for pleasing man. In this state of mind they were never likely to have faith, or to come to the knowledge of the truth. " How can ye believe, receiving and seeking honour from one another as ye do now?" It is not possible that you can believe, until you cease from your present earthly-mindedness, and honestly desire God's praise more than man's.

John 5:44 · Open Word Bible

44How could you believe? You accept glory from one another, while the glory that comes from the only God is something you do not seek.

Report a mistake

The great principle contained in the verse is the close connection between the state of a man's heart and his possessing the gift of faith. Believing or not believing, to have faith or not to have faith, is not a thing that depends only on a man's head being satisfied, and his intellect convinced. It depends far more on the state of a man's heart. If a man is not thoroughly honest in his professed desire to find out the truth in religion, — if he secretly cherishes any idol which he is resolved not to give up, — if he privately cares for anything more than God's praise, : — he will go on to the end of his days doubting, perplexed, dissatisfied, and restless, and will never find the way to peace. His insincerity of heart is an insuperable barrier in the way of his believing. There is a mine of wisdom in the expression, "An honest and good heart." (Luke viii. 15.) For want of it many a one complains that he cannot get comfort in religion, and cannot see his way towards heaven, when the truth is that his own dishonesty of heart is the cause. There is something he loves more than God. The consequence is that he never feels an honest will to believe.

The ''can" in this verse should be compared with the "will" in the fortieth verse. " Ye cannot because ye will not."

Report a mistake

from God only

This expression would be more literally rendered, " from the only God," — the one true God, whom the Jews boasted that they alone knew and worshipped.

Doddridge remarks that the whole verse " has much more spirit in it, if we consider it as applied to the members of the Sanhedrim, who had such distinguished titles of honour, than if we only take it as spoken to a mixed multitude." If, as many suppose, our Lord was making a formal defence of Himself and His divine mission before the great Ecclesiastical Assembly of the Jews, His words in this verse would come home to His hearers with stinging power.

Report a mistake

John 5:45

Do not think that I will accuse, &c.

We must not suppose that our Lord literally meant that there was any real likelihood of Moses or Himself standing up to make a formal accusation against the Jews. What He did mean was, that not to believe Him was not to believe Moses. There was no need for Him to accuse them of unbelief Moses himself, for whom they professed such respect, might be their accuser, and prove them guilty.

"Even now," He says, "Moses accuseth you. His writing's, daily read in your synagogue, are a constant witness of your unbelief." There may also, it is highly probable, be a reference here to the Song of Moses, where he predicts the unbelief of the people, and desires the book of the law to be " put in the side of the ark, that it may be there for a witness against thee.' (Deut. xxxii. 26.)

Chemnitius remarks, ''What the Lord says to the Jews, la exactly as if I were to say to the Papists, It is not I, but the very Fathers whose authority ye allege in favour of your superstition, who will accuse you of impiety. Or as if we were to say to the Pope, It is not we who accuse and condemn thee, but Christ himself, whose vicar thou callest thyself; and Peter whose successor thou wilt have thyself: and Paul whose sword thou pretendest to bear: they it is who will accuse thee." Beza makes much the same remark, and observes, that none will be more opposed to the Roman Catholics in the judgment-day than the Virgin Mary and the saints in whom they profess to trust!

The notion of some Romanists that the expression "Moses in whom ye trust," justifies the invocation of saints, and putting confidence in them as mediators, is, as Chemnitius observes, too weak and groundless to need refutation.

John 5:45 · Open Word Bible

45Do not imagine that I will be the one to accuse you before the Father. You already have an accuser: Moses, in whom you have put your hope.

Report a mistake

John 5:46

For had ye believed Moses, ye

These words are simply an amplification of the idea in the preceding verse. If the Jews had really believed Moses, they could not have helped believing Christ. The witness of Moses to Christ, was so distinct, express, and unmistakeable, that true belief in his writings must inevitably have led them to belief in Christ.

[He wrote of me.] These words are very remarkable. In what sense our Lord used them, we cannot exactly know. At the very least we may conclude He meant that throughout the five books of Moses, by direct prophecy, by typical persons, by typical ceremonies, in many ways, and in divers manners, Moses had written of Him, There is probably a depth of meaning in the Pentateuch that has never yet been fully fathomed. We shall probably find at the last day that Christ was in many a chapter and many a verse, and yet we knew it not. There is a fulness in all Scripture far beyond our conception.

Let us note carefully that our Lord distinctly speaks of Moses as a real person who, as a matter of history, lived and wrote books, and of his writings as true genuine writings deserving of all credit, and of undeniable authority. In the face of such an expression as this, it is a mournful fact that any man called a Christian can throw doubt on the existence of Moses, or on the authority of the books attributed to him.

John 5:46 · Open Word Bible

46If you really believed Moses, you would believe Me, because what he wrote was about Me.

Report a mistake

To say, as some have done, that our Lord, born of a Jewish woman, and brought up among Jews, was not above the ignorant prejudices of the Jews, and did not really know that Moses ever existed, and that his writings are full of mistakes, is to talk downright blasphemy and nonsense. Fancy the eternal Son of God at any time talking ignorantly I Fancy above all that any trace of Jewish ignorance would be likely to be found in this chapter of St. John's gospel, in which, above all other chapters perhaps, our Lord's divine knowledge is most strikingly brought out !

Report a mistake

John 5:47

if ye believe not his writings, &c.

This verse is an extension of the thought contained in the preceding one, and a solemn and mournful conclusion of the whole address. There is evidently an intentional contrast between "writings" and "words," as if our Lord would remind the Jews that " writings" are generally more relied upon than "sayings." — "If you do not really believe what your own honoured lawgiver Moses wrote, — and it is plain that you do not, — it is not likely that you will believe what I SAY. If you have no real faith in the things written in your Scriptures by that very Moses, for whom you profess such reverence, your favourite teacher and lawgiver, it is not to be wondered at that you have no faith in what I say, and that I speak to you in vain."

The Greek word used here for "writings" is very remarkable. It is generally translated "letters," as Luke xxiii. 38. In 2 Tim. iii. 15, it is rendered " Scriptures." To my mind it is a strong indirect evidence in favour of the verbal inspiration of Scripture.

There is a sense in which these words should ring painfully in the ears of all the modern assailants of the Mosaic writings. It is just as true now, I firmly believe, as it was eighteen hundred years ago. They cannot divide Moses and Christ. If they do not believe the one, they will find sooner or later that they do not believe the other. If they begin with casting off Moses and not believing his writings, they will find in the end that to be consistent they must cast off Christ. If they will not have the Old Testament, they will discover at last that they cannot have the New, The two are so linked together that they cannot be separated. "What God hath joined together let no man put asunder."

John 5:47 · Open Word Bible

47But if you do not believe the writings of Moses, how will you ever believe My spoken words?"

Report a mistake

In concluding the notes on this wonderful chapter, one would like to know how this marvellous address was received by those who heard it. But here we meet with one of the peculiar " silences " of Scripture. Not one word is written to tell us what the Jews of Jerusalem thought of our Lord's argument, or what effect it had upon them. Our own duty is clear. Let us take heed that it has some effect on ourselves.

The amazing fulness of our Lord's teaching appears most strikingly in the address contained in this chapter. Within the short span of twenty-nine verses, we find no less than eleven mighty subjects brought forward: (L) The intimate relation of the Father and the Son (2.) The divine commission and dignity of the Son. (3.) The privileges of the man who believes. (4.) The quickening of the spiritually dead. (5.) The judgment. (6.) The resurrection of the body. (7.) The value of miracles. (8.) The Scriptures. (9.) The corruption of man's will the secret of man's ruin. (10.) The love of man's praise the cause of unbelief. (11.) The importance of the writings of Moses.

Report a mistake