C. F. Keil · Biblical Commentary on the Old Testament: The Pentateuch, Vol. I (Genesis)
Genesis 36
4 excerpts on Genesis 36, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
Vers. 1-8. Esau's wives and children. His settlement in the mountains of Seir. — In the heading (ver. 1) the surname Edom is added to the name Esau, which he received at his birth, because the former became the national designation of his descendants. —
Genesis 36:1–8 · Open Word Bible
1This is the account of the family of Esau, that is, Edom. 2Esau married women of Canaan: Adah daughter of Elon the Hittite, Oholibamah daughter of Anah and granddaughter of Zibeon the Hivite, 3and Basemath daughter of Ishmael, Nebaioth's sister. …
Vers. 2, 3. The names of Esau's three wives differ from those given in the previous accounts (chap. xxvi. 34 and xxviii. 9), and in one instance the father's name as well. The daughter of Elon the Hittite is called Adah (the ornament), and in chap. xxvi. 34 Basmath (the fragrant) ; the second is called Aholibamali (probably tent-height), the daughter of Anah, daughter, i.e. grand-daughter of Zibeon the Hivite, and in xxvi. 34, Jehudith (the praised or praiseworthy), daughter of Beeri the Hittite ; the third, the daughter of Islmiael, is called Basmath here and Mahalath in chap, xxviii. 9. This difference arose from the fact, that Moses availed himself of genealogical documents for Esau's family and tribe, and inserted them without alteration. It presents no irreconcilable discrepancy, therefore, but may be explained from the ancient custom in the East, of giving surnames, as the Arabs frequently do still, founded upon some important or memorable event in a man's life, which gradually superseded the other name {e.g. the name Edom, as explained in chap. xxv. 30) ; whilst as a rule the women received new names when they were married (cf. Chardin, Hengstenberg, Dissertations, vol. ii. p. 223-G). The different names given for the father of Aholibamali or Judith, Hengstenberg explains by referring to the statement in ver. 24, that Anah, the son of Zibeon, while watching the asses of his father in the desert, discovered the warm springs (of Calirrhoe), on which he founds the acute conjecture, that from this discovery Anah received the surname Beeri, i.e. spring-man, which so threw his original name into the shade, as to be the only name given in the genealogical table. There is no force in the objection, that according to ver. 25 Aholibamali was not a daughter of the discoverer of the springs, but of his uncle of the same name. For where is it stated that the Aholibamah mentioned in ver. 25 was Esau's wife? And is it a thing unheard of that aunt and niece should have the same name ?
Genesis 36:2–3 · Open Word Bible
2Esau married women of Canaan: Adah daughter of Elon the Hittite, Oholibamah daughter of Anah and granddaughter of Zibeon the Hivite, 3and Basemath daughter of Ishmael, Nebaioth's sister.
Vers. 15-19. ... 19; Mic. v. 2), — the heads of the families, i.e. of the principal divisions, of the tribe. The names of these Alluplnm are not names of places, but of persons — of the three sons and ten grandsons of Esau mentioned in vers. 9—14 ; though Knobel would reverse the process and interpret the whole geographically. — In ver. 16 Korah has probably been copied by mistake from ver. 18, and should therefore be erased, as it really is in the Samar. Codex.
Vers. 20-30 (parallel, 1 Chron. i. 38-42). ... Rob. Pal. ii. p. 424). The Horites, who had previously been an independent people (xiv. 6), were partly exterminated and partly subjugated by the descendants of Esau (Deut. ii. 12, 22). Seven sons of Seir are given as tribe-princes of the Horites, who are afterwards mentioned as Alluphim (vers. 29, 30), also their sons, as well as two daughters, Tirana (ver. 22) and Aholibamah (ver. 25), who obtained notoriety from the fact that two of the headquarters of Edomitish tribe-princes bore their names (vers. 40 and 41). Timna was probably the same as the concubine of Eliphaz (ver. 12); but Aholibamah was not the wife of Esau (cf. ver. 2). — There are a few instances in which the names in this list differ from those in the Chronicles. ... 19), or those in the Wady el Ahsa to the S.E. of the Dead Sea, or those in the Wady Hamad between Kerek and the Dead Sea.2 —
Genesis 36:15–19 · Open Word Bible
15These were the clan chiefs among Esau's descendants. From the sons of Eliphaz, Esau's firstborn, came the chiefs Teman, Omar, Zepho, Kenaz, 16Korah, Gatam and Amalek. These were the chiefs descended from Eliphaz in the land of Edom, the descendants of Adah. 17From the sons of Reuel, Esau's son, came the chiefs Nahath, Zerah, Shammah and Mizzah. These were the chiefs descended from Reuel in the land of Edom, the descendants of Esau's wife Basemath. …
Ver. 30. " These are the princes of the Horites according to their princes" i.e. as their princes were individually named in the land of Seir. ? in enumerations indicates the relation of the individual to the whole, and of the whole to the individual.
Vers. 31-39 (parallel, 1 Chron. i. 43-50). The kings in the land OF Edom : before the children of Israel had a king.
1 Knobel also undertakes to explain these names geographically, and to point them out in tribes and places of Arabia, assuming, quite arbitrarily and in opposition to the text, that the names refer to tribes, not to persons, although an incident is related of Zibeon's son, which proves at once that the list relates to persons and not to tribes ; and expecting his readers to believe that not only are the descendants of these troglodytes, who were exterminated before the time of Moses, still to be found, but even their names may be traced in certain Bedouin tribes, though more than 3000 years have passed away ! The utter groundlessness of such explanations, which rest upon nothing more than similarity of names, may be seen in the association of Shdbal with Syria Sobal (Judith iii. 1), the name used by the Crusaders for Arabia tertia, i.e. the southernmost district below the Dead Sea, which was conquered by them. For notwithstanding the resemblance of the name Shobal to Sobal, no one could seriously think of connecting Syria Sobal with the Horite prince Shobal, unless he was altogether ignorant of the apocryphal origin of the former name, which first of all arose from the Greek or Latin version of the Old Testament, and in fact from a misunderstanding of Ps. Ix.
Genesis 36:30 · Open Word Bible
30Dishon, Ezer and Dishan. These were the Horite chiefs, clan by clan, in the land of Seir.