Logia

Charles Hodge · A Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, designed for students of the English Bible

Romans 7

64 excerpts on Romans 7, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

Romans 7:1

(1) Know ye not brethren (for I speak to them that know the law), how that the law hath dominion over a man as long as he liveth? The sentiment of this verse, viz. the obligation of the law is not perpetual, is expressed very generally, and not precisely in the form suited to the illustration which follows.t The illustration is, that the law of marriage ceases to bind a woman when her husband is dead; but Paul here says, the law has dominion over a man so long as he lives. The general thought is all that is intended to be here expressed; and this received its form probably before the precise illustration was determined in the apostle’s own mind. It is not necessarily to be inferred from the expression, J speak to them that know the law, that the Jewish Christians are specially referred to. The principle stated being so familiar, the apostle might assume that any class of his readers knew enough of law to be aware of its truth.

Romans 7:1 · Open Word Bible

1Surely you understand, brothers and sisters, since I am speaking to people who know the law, that the law is master over someone only while that person is alive.

Report a mistake

The original leaves it doubtful whether the last clause of the verse is to be rendered “as long as he lives,”’ or “as long as it lives.”? The decision of this point depends on the context. In favour of the latter, it may be said, 1. That it is better suited to the apostle’s design, which is to show that the law is dead or abrogated. 2. That in v. 6 (according to the common reading) the law is spoken of as being dead. 3. And, especially, that in vs. 2, 3, the woman is said to be free from the law, not by her own, but by her husband’s death; which would seem to require that, in the other part of the comparison, the husband, i. e. the law, should be represented as dying, and not the wife, i. e. those bound by the law. But, on the other hand, it must be admitted that to say the daw dives, and the law dies, are very unusual modes of expression, and perfectly unexampled in Paul’s writings, if the doubtful case in vy. 6 be excepted. 2. This interpretation is inconsistent with verse 2. It is not the law that dies; “ The woman is bound to her husband as long as he liveth, but if the husband be dead, &c.”’ 3. Throughout the passage it is said that we are dead to the law (v. 4), delivered from the law (v. 6), and not that the law is dead. The common interpretation, therefore, is to be preferred. ‘The law has dominion as long and no longer than the person lives to whom it has respect. For example, the law of marriage ceases to be binding when one of the parties is dead.’

The word /aw, in this verse, seems to be used generally. It is not the law of Moses, nor the moral law, nor the law of marriage particularly; but the apostle’s remark has reference to laws in general. The particular example is given in vs. 2, 3, and the application of the remark to Christians is made in v. 4.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:2

(2) For the woman which hath an husband is bound by the law to her husband as long as he liveth, &c. This and the following verse are a simple illustration of the principle stated in v. 1. The word for, therefore, has the force which it so often has in such connexions, being equivalent to for example. ‘Death puts an end to the authority of laws; for example, the woman, &e.’? Is bound by the law. The law here is the law of marriage, and not specially or exclusively the Mosaic law on that subject. But if her husband be dead, she is loosed from the law of her husband. “ Law of her husband;”’ i. e. the law which bound her to her husband; or which respects her husband. The words rendered loosed from are so used in vy. 6. Gal. 5: 4.

Romans 7:2 · Open Word Bible

2Take a married woman: the law binds her to her husband while he is alive. But if he dies, she is set free from the law that tied her to him.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:3

So then if

(3) So then if, while her husband liveth, she be married to another man, she shall be called an adulteress, &c. This verse is but an amplification of the preceding one. ‘ While her husband lives, the woman is bound by the law of marriage, for she is an adulteress, if, while he is living, she be married to another man; but that his death frees her from this law is plain, for she is not regarded as an adulteress, if her husband being dead, she be married to another.’ Laws, therefore, are not necessarily of perpetual obligation.

Romans 7:3 · Open Word Bible

3So if she joins herself to another man while her husband is still living, people will call her an adulteress. But once her husband has died she is free from the law, and marrying another man does not make her an adulteress.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:4

Wherefore

(4) Wherefore, my brethren, ye also are become dead to the law by the body of Christ, that ye should be married to another, &c. Wherefore this being the case, i. e. as the woman is freed from the marriage contract by the death of her husband, in like manner ye are free from the law by the death of Christ. And, moreover, as the woman is at liberty to marry the second time, so are we. Freed from the demands of our first husband (the law), we may be married to him who has risen from the dead. That is, freed from the law, as a rule of justification, we are at liberty to accept of the offers of gratuitous acceptance made to us in the gospel. As before remarked, the meaning of the apostle would be rather plainer, if, at the beginning of this verse instead of saying ye are dead to the law, he had said the law is dead to you. As the woman is freed from her husband when he dies, so are we freed from the law when it is ...

Romans 7:4 · Open Word Bible

4It is the same with you, my brothers and sisters. Through the body of Christ you were put to death as far as the law is concerned, so that you could be joined to another: to the one who was raised from the dead. And so we can bear fruit for God.

Report a mistake

TuorvcK gives a different view of this passage. He considers the apostle as having virtually stated in the previous verses, that “the law is dead to us,” i. e. that “its demands are satisfied ;” he, therefore, regards him in this to state, as the natural consequence of this fact, that “we are dead to the law,” i. e. that we are free from a legal spirit. This, however, though perfectly true, is not in keeping with the context. ‘The main idea of the passage is, that we are freed from the law, and are in a state of grace; see v. 6. dead, i. e. satisfied. But this is a mode of expression which he seems studiously to avoid. And the idea of our freedom from the law is as well expressed by saying we are dead to the law, as by saying the law is dead to us. In illustration of the phrase dead to the law, see v. 6. ch. 6: 2. Gal. 2:19. 1 Peter 2: 24, We are said to be freed from the law by the body of Christ, i. e. by the sacrifice of that body, or by his death. Paul uses the expressions “ the blood of Christ,’ Eph. 2: 13; “ his flesh,” Eph. 2: 15; “ his cross,’’ v. 16; “his body,’ Col. 1: 22, as all equivalent to “ his death.”? The demands of the law are satisfied by the sufferings of Christ. He has redeemed us from the curse of the law, by bearing its penalty or curse in our place, Gal. 3:13. To those, therefore, who are in Christ Jesus, the law, as a covenant of works, or rule of justification, is no longer in force, Rom. 8: 2.

Report a mistake

That ye should be married to another, to him who is raised from the dead. This clause expresses the design of the redemption just spoken of. We are not delivered from the law, that we should be free from all restraint, or be our own masters, but that we should be united to him through whom alone the original design of the law, the sanctification of men, can be effected. As the apostle had spoken of Christ, by implication at least, as being dead, when he spoke of his body, there was a propriety in his saying who is raised from the dead. It is a living husband, to use the apostle’s figure, which every believer has in Christ. And as he ever lives, the union is perpetual; there is to be no more either divorce or death. That we should bring forth fruit unto God. This is the design of our union with Christ. The object, here expressed in a manner suited to the figurative language of the context, is the same which is so often elsewhere stated as the grand design of the redemption of Christ, viz. the sanctification of his people.

Report a mistake

The law, of which the apostle is here speaking, is evidently not the Mosaic law merely. It is not the doctrine of this and of similar passages, that Christ has delivered us from the Jewish economy, and left us at liberty to embrace the simpler and more spiritual system of the gospel. The law of which he speaks, is that which says, “ The man which doeth these things shall live by them,” ch. 10: 5. Gal. 3: 10; that is, which requires perfect obedience as the condition of acceptance. It is that which says, “Thou shalt not covet,’ v. 7; without which sin is dead, v. 8; which is holy, just and good, v. 12; which is spiritual, v. 14, &c. &c. It is that law by whose works the Gentiles cannot be justified, ch. 3: 20, from whose curse Christ has redeemed not the Jews only, but also the Gentiles, Gal. 3: 13,14. It is plain, therefore, that Paul here means by the law, the will of God, as a rule of duty, no matter how revealed. From this law, as prescribing the terms of our acceptance with God, Christ has delivered us. It is the legal system which says, “ Do this and live,”’ that Christ has abolished and introduced another, which says, “ He that believes shall be saved.” Since, however, as remarked above (ch. 6: 14), the Old Testament economy, including the Mosaic institutions, was the form in which the law, as law, was ever present to the minds of the apostle and his readers; and since deliverance from the legal system, as such, involved deliverance from that ecanomy, it is not wonderful that reference to that dispensation should often be made; or that Paul should at times express the idea of deliverance from the law, as such, by terms which would seem to express only deliverance from the particular form in which it was so familiar to his readers. ...

Report a mistake

... So, too, in the epistle to the Galatians, we find him constantly speaking of a return to Judaism as a renunciation of the method of gratuitous justification, and a recurrence to a reliance on the righteousness of works. The reason of this is obvious. The Old Testament dispensation, apart from its evangelical import, which lay, like a secondary sense, beneath the covert of its institutions, was but a re-enactment of the legal system. To make, however, as is so often done, the whole meaning of the apostle to be, that we are freed from the Jewish law, is not only inconsistent, in this place with the context, and irreconcileable with many express declarations of scripture, but distinctive of the whole evangelical character of the doctrine. How small a part of the redemption of Christ is deliverance from the Mosaic institutions! How slight the consolation to a soul, sensible of its ex- posure to the wrath of God, to be told that the law of Moses no longer condemns us! How void of truth and meaning the doctrine, that deliverance from the law is necessary to holiness, if the law means the Jewish economy merely!

Report a mistake

Romans 7:5

For when we were in the flesh

(5) For when we were in the flesh, the motions of sin, which were by the law, &c. The apostle having, in v. 4, stated that believers are freed from the law by the death of Christ, in this and the following verse he shows the necessity and the consequences of this change. ‘We have been thus freed, because formerly, when under the law, we brought forth fruit unto death; but now, being free from the law, we are devoted to the service of God,’ The force of for, at the beginning of this verse, is therefore obvious. The former legal state of believers is here described by saying, they were in the flesh. In the language of scripture, the word /lesh expresses, in such connexions, one or the other of two ideas, or both conjointly. First, a state of moral corruption, as in ch. 8: 8, “ Those that are in the flesh;’’ secondly, a carnal state, i. e. a state in which men are subject to external rites, ceremonies and commands; or, more generally, a legal state, inasmuch as among the Jews, that state was one of subjection to such external rites. Gal. 3: 3, “ Having begun in the spirit, are ye now made perfect by the flesh ??”? Compare Gal. 4: 9, where the expression “weak and beggarly elements” is substituted for the phrase “ the flesh,”’ see Rom. 4:1. In the present case, both ideas appear to be included. The meaning is, ‘When in your unrenewed and legal state.’ The opposite condition is described (v. 6) as a state of freedom from the law; which, of course, shows that the second of the two ideas mentioned above, was prominent in the apostle’s mind when he used the words “in the flesh.”

Romans 7:5 · Open Word Bible

5When we lived in the flesh, the law stirred up sinful desires in us. They were at work in the parts of our bodies, and what we produced belonged to death.

Report a mistake

The motions of sin, i. e. emotions or feelings of sin, for sinful feelings. Which were by the law ... . The obvious ellipsis in this clause may be variously supplied. ‘Which are made known by the law,’ according to ch. 3: 20; or ‘which are caused to abound by the law,’ according to ch, 5: 20; or ‘which are produced by the law,’ according to y. 8 of this chapter. The last mode of explanation is decidedly to be preferred, because more consistent with the context, and with Paul’s object, which required him to show that the law, instead of producing holiness, was incidentally the cause of sin.

Did work in our members to bring forth sin unto death. In our members is little more than a paraphrase for in us; see ch. 6: 12, 13. Zo bring forth. The infinitive ... here expresses the result. ‘Sin so wrought that we brought fruit, &e.’ Fruit unto death. Death is here again personified; to death (dativus commodi), the advantage of death; as opposed to the words to God, at the close of y. 4. The fruit which sin produced belonged, as it were, to death. Such was our condition when under the law. Our present state is prescribed in the next verse.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:6

But now we are delivered from the law

(6) But now we are delivered from the law, that being dead; wherein we were held, &c. Our former state was one in the flesh; our present one of freedom from the law. If the common reading be adopted, the meaning of this passage is, ‘We are delivered from the law, it being dead, &c.? But the true reading, as stated in the margin, requires the second clause to be rendered thus, we being dead. The meaning then is, ‘We are now delivered from the law, being dead in respect to that by which we were formerly held, &c.? There is apparently a transposition of the members of the sentence; their natural order seems to be this, ‘ But now, being dead as it respects the law, by which we were formerly held, we are free, so that, &c.’

That we should serve in newness of spirit, and not in oldness of the letter. The result of deliverance from the law is here described. The phrases newness of spirit, and oldness of the letter, according to a common Hebrew idiom, mean anew spirit and old letter. The word rendered letter means something written; then the law as written, or the written law; ch. 2: 27. 2 Cor. 3: 6, “ ministers of the New Testament; not of the letter, but of the spirit (1. e. not of the law, but of gospel); for the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life;”’ i. e. the law condemns, but the gospel secures life. ‘The sense of this passage, therefore, is, ‘ We serve God in the exercise of a new spirit, or in a new spiritual state; and not in bondage to the old written law, or in our old legal state.’ It is evident that the clause in the oldness of the letter is substituted by the apostle for the expressions under the law and in the flesh; all which he uses to describe the legal and corrupt condition of men, prior to the believing reception of the gospel.

Romans 7:6 · Open Word Bible

6But now we are free from the law. We have died to what once held us fast, so that we serve in the new life of the Spirit, not in the old life of the written letter.

Report a mistake

This clause may be differently explained. As the word God is not used by the apostle after serve, he may intend to say, ‘We serve a new spirit, and not an old letter;’ i.e. ‘We serve the gospel, and not the law;’? compare 2 Cor. 3: 6. Or the result of the change is, that ‘ We serve the Holy Spirit, and not the old written law.’ The interpretation first given, however, is much the most simple, and most consistent with the context. Believers, then, are free from the law by the death of Christ; they are no longer under the old covenant which said “ Do this, and live;’’? but are introduced into a new and gracious state, in which they are accepted, not for what they do, but for what has been done for them. Instead of having the legal and slavish spirit, which arose from their former relation to God, they have the feelings of children.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:7

What shall we say then

(7) What shall we say then? Is the law sin? Far from it, &e. The apostle asks whether it is to be inferred, either from the general doctrine of the preceding section, respecting the necessity of deliverance from the law, or from the special declaration made in v. 5, respecting the law’s producing sin, that the law was itself evil? He answers, by no means; and shows, in the next verse, that the effect ascribed to the law, in y. 5, is merely incidental. Js the law sin? means either, Is the law evil? or is it the cause of sin? see Micah 1: 5, ‘Samaria is the sin of Jacob.’ The former is best suited to the context, because Paul admits that the law is incidentally productive of sin.

Romans 7:7 · Open Word Bible

7What then are we to say? Is the law sin? Certainly not! But it was the law that taught me what sin is. I would never have recognized wrong desire for what it is unless the law had said, "You shall not covet."

Report a mistake

Nay, I had not known sin, but by the law. The word rendered nay very often signifies on the contrary, and may be so translated here. ‘So far from the law being evil, it is, on the contrary, of the greatest use, for I had not known sin, but by the law. I had not known sin. The will of God, which is the rule of right and wrong, is the source of all knowledge of what is morally good or evil. This law is revealed partially in the very constitution of our nature; and more fully in the scriptures. The more enlarged and spiritual our views of this law, the clearer our knowledge of the extent and evil of sin. For I had not known lust, except the law had said thou shall not covet. The meaning of this member of the sentence depends upon the sense given to for. It may be confirmatory, or merely illustrative. If the former, the sense is, ‘I had not known sin, but by the law, for I had not known that the mere inward desire was evil, had not the law said, &c.’ Or retaining the same force of this particle, ‘ I had not known the real inward fountain of sin, viz. concupiscence, except the law had said, &c.’ According to this view, which is the one most commonly adopted, the word rendered dust ... refers to the corrupt disposition of the heart, considered as the root or source of sin. If for ... be considered as merely illustrative, the sense is this: ‘I had not known sin except by the law; for example, 1 had not known concupiscence, had not the law said, &c.? According to this view, concupiscence does not differ from the more general term s7n, except as being adduced as an example of the evils to the knowledge of which the law leads. It seems probable that the first interpretation is the more correct of the two. ...

Report a mistake

... At least, that the apostle designedly referred to an inward, spiritual ... sin, in order the more clearly to confirm his declaration. That certain outward actions were wrong, he and all other Pharisees knew, and were ready to admit; but that God took cognizance of the heart, and of its most secret workings, and even of its habits or dispositions, they were less disposed to imagine; and were, therefore, deplorably ignorant of the extent and turpitude of their depravity in his sight.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:8

But sin

(8) But sin, taking occasion by the commandment, wrought in me all manner of concupiscence, &c. This verse is not to be connected logically with the last member of the preceding one. It is rather co-ordinate with it, and is a virtual answer to the question, Is the law evil? To this question, Paul replies, in y. 7, No; on the contrary, it leads to the knowledge of sin. And then, in vy. 8, he adds, it is not evil in itself, although incidentally the cause of sin in us. Sn in this passage, must mean the sinful disposition of the heart, or our corrupt nature, because it is said to produce all kinds of concupiscence; thatis,every kind of evil desire. These desires are the fruit and evidence of this corrupt state of the heart. Taking occasion. The word rendered occasion ... is used for any thing which affords an advantage for the performance of any thing else. The word occasion or opportunity, referring properly to mere fitness of time, is not so appropriate a translation as the more general term advantage.

Romans 7:8 · Open Word Bible

8Sin found its opening in the commandment and used it to rouse every kind of wrong desire in me, for without the law sin is dead.

Report a mistake

The words by the commandment may be connected either with the preceding or the following clause. If the former mode of construction be adopted, the passage means, ‘Sin, taking advantage of the commandment, wrought in me, &c.’ If the latter, ‘Sin, taking advantage, by the commandment wrought in me, &c.’ Our version is commonly pointed according to the former method, with a comma after commandment. The original, however, is in favour of the latter; and so is the context. Paul’s object is to show that by the daw sin is exeited and aroused; and, in the following verses, he uses similar expressions, as “ by it slew me,’’ v. 11; “ working death in me by that which is good,’’ v.13. The apostle, therefore, teaches, that the effect of the law operating upon our corrupt hearts, is to arouse their evil passions, and to lead to the desire of the ... very objects which the law forbids. This is a matter of universal experience. The same sentiment is, therefore, often met with in profane writers. Nitimur in vetitum, cupimusque negata, ‘We strive for what is forbidden, and desire what is denied,’ has become a proverb.

Report a mistake

For without the law, sin was dead.t To say that a thing is dead, is to say that it is inactive, unproductive and unobserved. All this may be said of sin prior to the operation of the law. It is comparatively inoperative and unknown until aroused and brought to light by the law. There are two effects of the law included in this declaration, the excitement of evil passions, and the discovery of them. Calvin makes the latter much the more prominent.t But the context, and the analogous declarations in the succeeding verses, seem to require the former to be considered as the most important. The law, then, is not evil, but it produces the conviction of sin, by teaching us what sin is, v. 7, and by making us conscious of the existence and power of this evil in our own hearts, v. 8.§ In the following verses, 9—11, we find an amplification and confirmation of the sentiment of vs. 7, 8, showing more fully the operation of the law. Paul is here describing his own experience. This is obvious, not only because he uses the first person singular throughout the passage, but because the exercises here detailed are more or less distinctly those of every true Christian; and, consequently, those of the apostle. Paul describes, in figurative language, his state before the operation of the law upon his mind, and after it began to produce its proper effect. In the former state, he was alive, and sin was dead; in the latter, sin became alive, and he died.

§ Ehe dem Menschen ein v6.0 entweder von aussen gegeben wird, oder in ihm selbst sich entwickelt, so ist die Stindhaftigkeit zwar in ihm, als Anlage, aber sie ist todt, d. h. sie ist ihm noch nicht zum Bewusstseyn gekommen, weil noch kein Widerstreit zwischen seiner Stindhaftigkeit und einem Gebote in ihm entstehen konnte-—Usrznrr Lehrbegriff Pauli, p. 25, as quoted by Tuoxucx.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:9

For I was alive without the law once

(9) For I was alive without the law once; but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died. The word for connects this verse logically with the two preceding. ‘The law produces conviction of sin, for I was alive, &c.’ Without the law, i. e. the law being absent, as it is opposed to the expression, when the conmandment came. 'This phrase describes the state of Paul, and of every Christian, before conviction of sin. He was without a proper apprehension of the nature and extent of the law, which is real ignorance of it. Of course, as the law is the rule of duty, he was unaware of the number and magnitude of his sins. In this state he was alive. Life is a common figure not only for activity, but happiness, including, among other ideas, those of peace and security. The meaning here is, ‘ I was at peace with myself; unaware of the dreadful opposition of my heart to the nature and requirements of God; and consequently unapprehensive of the danger to which, by that opposition, I was exposed.’

But when the commandment came, &c. That. is, when I obtained proper views of the nature and extent of the law, then two consequences followed, sin revived, and I died. As by sin’s being dead was meant that it was inactive and unobserved, so by its reviving must be intended, that it was roused from its torpor; its opposition to all that is good was excited by the clear exhibition of the law, and consequently it was no longer an unobserved or unknownevil. The sense of its existence, power, and turpitude, became clear and strong. The result of this effect of the law, Paul expresses by saying, and I died. That is, ‘I became miserable; because aware of the evil that was in me, and of the danger to which I was exposed.’ Self-satisfaction and sense of security fled before the light of the law.

Romans 7:9 · Open Word Bible

9There was a time when I lived without the law. Then the commandment arrived, sin woke up and came alive,

Report a mistake

Romans 7:10

And the commandment which was unto life

(10) And the commandment which was unto life, I found to be unto death. Life and death are here, as often elsewhere, opposed to each other; the one standing for happiness, the other for misery. The commandment, which was designed and adapted to lead men to happiness and the true end of their being, becomes productive of misery, by making them sensible of their corruption and exposure to condemnation. Throughout the whole of this passage it is to be remembered that Paul attributes to the law, not only the knowledge of sin, but the excitement of it. It produces “the motions of sin,’’ or sinful desires, v. 5; it works all manner of concupiscence, v. 8; it revives sin, v. 9; it seduces into sin, v. 11. In the death, therefore, which it produces, the idea of sin as well as misery is to be included; and in the life, to which it was designed to lead, the ideas of holiness and happiness are both embraced.

Romans 7:10 · Open Word Bible

10and I died. The commandment was given for life, yet for me it led to death.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:11

For sin

(11) For sin, taking occasion by the commandment, deceived me, and by it slew me. This verse assigns the reason of the law’s being the cause of death, and hence is connected by jor with v. 10. The proper pointing of this passage is doubtful. In our version it is commonly pointed thus, “ For sin, taking occasion by the commandment, deceived me, &c.”’ But for the reasons assigned on y. 8, the words by the commandment should be connected with the subsequent, rather than with the antecedent clause. It was by the commandment that sin deceived, &c. The law is therefore the cause of death, not directly, or in virtue of its own nature or tendency, but incidentally only. Sin makes it such; for the evil disposition of the heart avails itself even of the law to lead us into sin. The word rendered to deceive, means also to seduce; which sense is better suited to this passage. The idea, therefore, is the same as that before expressed, ‘ our corrupt hearts make even the law the means of causing us to sin.’ nd by it slew me, i. e. rendered me miserable, at once unholy and unhappy. ‘It made me sensible that I was sunk in hopeless corruption and ruin.’

Romans 7:11 · Open Word Bible

11Sin found its opening in the commandment, deceived me, and used the commandment to kill me.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:12

Wherefore the law is holy, and the commandment holy, just and good

(12) Wherefore the law is holy, and the commandment holy, just and good. The conclusion from the foregoing exhibition of the effect of the law is, that it is not to be blamed for the evil which it incidentally produces. In v. 9, Paul uses the words daw and commandment as perfectly synonymous; here they are distinguished. The law collectively, and each command separately, are alike holy, &c. The word holy, in the first clause, expresses general excellence, freedom from all fault; and contains all that is expressed by the three terms of the second clause, where holy means pure, just means reasonable, and good, benevolent, or tending to happiness. The law is In every way excellent.

Romans 7:12 · Open Word Bible

12The law, then, is holy. The commandment is holy, just and good.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:13

(13) Was then that which is good made death unto me 2 God forbid, &c. With a view to prevent the possibility of its being supposed that he thought disrespectfully of this holy law of God, the apostle again denies that it is directly the cause of sin, but shows that our own corruption is the real source of the evil. Made death, agreeably to what has been said above, means ‘made the cause of sin and misery.’ The law is not this cause.

Romans 7:13 · Open Word Bible

13Did something good, then, become death to me? Certainly not! Sin was the cause. It used what was good to work death in me, so that sin would be seen for what it really is. Through the commandment sin showed itself sinful past all measure.

Report a mistake

But sin, that it might appear sin, working death in me by that which is good; that sin by the commandment might become exceeding sinful. The grammatical construction of this part of the verse is, in the original, very doubtful, and, in our version, inaccurate. It will be observed that it consists of two clauses, each beginning with that; “ that it might appear”? ... ; and “that it might become” ... . The latter of these clauses may depend upon the former; and the participle working ... be taken Hebraically for averb. The sense is then plain and good. ‘The law is not the cause of death, but sin, that it might appear sin, wrought death in me by that which is good; that thus it might become exceeding sinful.’ So Calvin, and others. This, however, does violence to the text, as the participle cannot properly be taken here as a verb. Others, therefore, make the clauses coordinate, both depending upon the first words of the sentence. ‘The law is not the cause of death, but sin zs, that it might appear sin, working death in me by that which is good; that is, that it might become exceeding sinful, &c.? So Beza,t and others. There are several other methods by which the construction may be explained; but the general sense remains the same. That it might appear working, 1. e. might be apprehended in its true character from its effects. Sin, therefore, and not the law, is the cause of death. And the turpitude and enormity of sin are made the more conspicuous by the law, inasmuch as it makes even that which is in itself good a source of evil.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:14

For we know that the law is spiritual

(14) For we know that the law is spiritual; but I am carnal, sold under sin. The connexion between this verse and the preceding passage seems to be this. It had been asserted in v. 5, that the law was incidentally the cause of sin. This result, however, was no reflection on the law; for it was holy, just and good, v.12. As the fact, that the law excites sin, is consistent with its being good, so is also the fact that it cannot destroy the power of sin. The law indeed is spiritual, but we-are carnal. The fault is again in us. According to this view, for, at the beginning of this verse, is rather a particle of transition, or, at most, of illustration; and not of confirmation or inference. Paul, according to our version, says, We know (cidaev); the original, however, admits of the rendering J know indeed ... ; which is more consistent with the use of the first person singular throughout the chapter. The former reading is commonly adopted. .

Romans 7:14 · Open Word Bible

14We know that the law is spiritual. I, however, am made of flesh, and I have been sold to sin as its slave.

Report a mistake

The law is spiritual. The word spiritual is here expressive of general excellence, and includes all that is meant by holy, just and good, in v. 12. This use of the word is easily accounted for. The Spirit of God is the source of all excellence; hence, the term spiritual, when applied to any thing of which he is the author, implies that it derives its nature and character from the Spirit. Carnal, on the other hand, is applied to any thing which derives its nature and character from the flesh. Hence, “ things of the Spirit,’ “ fruits of the Spirit,” &c., are good things, or good fruits, ch. 8: 5. Gal. 5: 22; and “things of the flesh,’ “works of the flesh,’’ &c.,are evil works. As it is the doctrine of the scriptures that men are entirely depraved, or destitute of holiness, in their natural state, the word flesh, which is the scriptural designation of men (as in the frequent expressions, “all flesh,’’ “no flesh living,’’ &e.), is used for that which is corrupt, or for human nature considered apart from divine influence, ch. 8: 1—11. John 3: 5, 6, and other passages too numerous to be cited. To be carnal, therefore, when spoken of men, means to be under the government of the flesh, or of natural principles merely; and to be spiritual is to be under the government of the Spirit. When spoken of things, to be carnal is to be corrupt; to be spiritual is to be holy or excellent. The law is thus excellent. It is an emanation from the Spirit of God; atranscript of his nature, and of course partakes of his character. But we are carnal, under the government of a corrupt nature. There is, therefore, a necessary opposition between the character and requirements of the law, and our hearts. This, and not any evil in the law, is the true reason why the law cannot effect our deliverance from sin. The evil is too deep to be destroyed by the mere objective presentation of excellence.

Report a mistake

Sold under sin, that is, a slave to sin. As slaves were procured by purchase, a person sold to another was his slave. The expression in the text is ambiguous. It may mean that one is entirely devoted to the service of sin, as in v. 7 of the preceding chapter. In this sense it is entirely inapplicable to the Christian. Paul says expressly, the believer isin this sense no longer the servant (Gr. slave) of sin, but the servant of righteousness. The phrase in question, however, may also mean, that one is subject to a power which, of himself, he cannot resist; against which he may and does struggle, and from which he desires to be free; but which, notwithstanding all his efforts, still asserts its authority. This isa state of bondage. It is in this sense that Paul says he was sold under sin. This appears clearly from the following verses, which are explanatory of this clause.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:15

For that which I do, I allow not

(15) For that which I do, I allow not, &c. This is an explanation and confirmation of the preceding declaration. ‘J am sold under sin, for that which I do, I allow not, &c.’? The original word rendered J allow, properly signifies £ know, and as it is used in different senses in the scriptures, its meaning in this case isa matter of doubt. Retaining its ordinary sense, the word may be used here popularly, as in the common phrase, ‘I know not what I do,’ expressive of the absence of a calm and deliberate purpose, and of the violence of the impulse under which one acts. Or the meaning may be that what is done, is done thoughtlessly. As, however, the word often expresses the idea of approbation, the interpretation best suited to the context is, ‘What I do, that I approve not;? compare Ps. 1: 6, “The Lord knoweth (i. e. approves) the way of the righteous;”’ Ps. 36: 10. 1 Cor. 8: 3, &c.

Romans 7:15 · Open Word Bible

15What I am doing makes no sense to me. The things I want to do, I fail to do; the things I hate are what I end up doing.

Report a mistake

For what I would, that do I not; but what I hate, that do I. This is a further description of this state of bondage. As the expressions what I would and what I hate are in antithesis, the former must mean what I love or delight in. This use of the Greek word ... is accommodated to the corresponding Hebrew term, and occurs several times in the New Testament. Matt. 27: 43, “Let him deliver him, if he will have him ... , i. e. if he delights in him;’’t Matt. 9: 13. 12: 7. Heb. 10: 5, 8, and Ps. 21: 9. 39: 7,in the Septuagint. The word wl, therefore, does not express so much a mere determination of the mind, as a state of the feelings and judgment. ‘ What I love and approve, that I omit; what I hate and disapprove, that Ido.’ This may not be metaphysical, though it is perfect correct language. It is the language of common life, which, as it proceeds from the common consciousness of men, is often a better indication of what that consciousness teaches, than the language of the schools. We do not find the bible making that broad distinction between the various faculties of the soul, as though they were so many different agents, which is so common with the philosophers. The language of the apostle, in this passage, expresses a fact of consciousness, with which every Christian is familiar. Whether the conflict here described is that which, in a greater or less degree, exists in every man, between the natural authoritative sense of right and wrong, and his corrupt inclinations; or whether it is peculiar to the Christian, must be decided by considerations drawn from the whole description, and from the connexion of this passage with the preceding and succeeding portions of the apostle’s discourse. {t is enough to remark here, that every Christian can adopt the language of this verse. ...

Report a mistake

... Pride, coldness, slothfulness and other feelings which he disapproves and hates, are, day by day, reasserting their power over him. He struggles against their influence, groans beneath their bondage, longs to be filled with meekness, humility, and all other fruits of the love of God, but finds he can neither of himself, nor by the aid of the law, effect his freedom from what he hates, or the full performance of what he desires and approves. Every evening witnesses his penitent confession of his degrading bondage, his sense of utter helplessness, and his longing desire for aid from above. He isaslave looking and longing for liberty.

Two consequences flow from this representation of the experience of the Christian. First, the fault is felt and acknowledged to be his own; the law is not to be blamed, v. 16. Second, this state of feeling is consistent with his being a Christian, v. 17.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:16

Lf then I do that which I would not

(16) Lf then I do that which I would not, I consent unto the law that it is good. Paul here asserts that his acting contrary to the law, was no evidence that he thought the law evil; for what he did, he disapproved. But to disapprove and condemn what the law forbids, is to assent to the excellence of the law. There isa constant feeling of self-disapprobation, and a sense of the excellence of the law in the Christian’s mind. He is, therefore, never disposed to blame the extent or severity of the law, but admits the fault to be in himself. JZ consent to, literally, I speak with, agree with, concede to.

Romans 7:16 · Open Word Bible

16But if I do things I do not want to do, that shows I side with the law: I agree that it is good.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:17

Now then it is no more I that do it

(17) Now then it is no more I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me. Now then, that is, under these circumstances, or, this being the case. Or the meaning may be but now, 1. e. since | became a Christian. The former explanation is to be preferred on account of the connexion of this verse with v. 15, from which this passage is an inference. ‘If the case be so, that I am sold under sin and am its unwilling slave; if I do what I disapprove, and fail to accomplish what I love; it is clear that it is not properly and fully I that do it, my real self; my better feelings or renovated nature is opposed to what the law forbids.’ This is not-said as an exculpation, but to exhibit the extent and power of indwelling sin, which it is beyond our own power, and beyond the power of the law to eradicate or effectually control. This feeling of helplessness is not only consistent with a sense and acknowledgement of accountability, but is always found united with genuine self-condemnation and penitence. There are, in general, few stronger indications of ignorance of the power and evil of sin, than the confident assertion of our ability to resist and subdue it. Paul groaned beneath its bondage, as if held in the loathsome embrace of a “body of death.””? The apostle’s object, therefore, is not to apologize for sin, but to show that the experience detailed in v. 15, is consistent with his being a Christian. ‘If it is true that I really approve and love the law, and desire to be conformed to it, 1am no longer the willing slave of sin; to the depth and power of the original evil is to be attributed the fact that I am not entirely delivered from its influence.’ This is obviously connected with the main object of the whole passage. ...

Romans 7:17 · Open Word Bible

17In that case, I am no longer the one doing it; sin is, the sin that has made its home in me.

Report a mistake

... For if sin remains and exerts its power, notwithstanding our disapprobation, and in despite of all our efforts, it is clear that we must look for deliverance to something out of ourselves, and that the mere preceptive power of the law cannot remove the evil.

(18, 19, 20) These verses contain an amplification and confirmation of the sentiment of the preceding verses. They reassert the existence, and explain the nature of the inward struggle of which the apostle had been speaking. ‘Iam unable to come up to the requirements of the law, not because they are unreasonable, but because I am corrupt; there is no good in me. I can approve and delight in the exhibitions of holiness made by the law, but full conformity to its demands is more than I can attain. It is not I, therefore, my real and lasting self, but this intrusive tyrant dwelling within me, that disobeys the law.’ This strong and expressive language, though susceptible of a literal interpretation, which would make it teach ~ not only error but nonsense, is still perfectly perspicuous and correct, because accurately descriptive of the common feelings of men. Paul frequently employs similar modes of expression. When speaking of his apostolic labours, he says, “ Yet not I, but the grace of God, which was with me,’’ 1 Cor. 15: 10. And in Gal. 2: 20, he says, “I live, yet not I, but Christ liveth in me.’? As no one supposes that the labours and life here spoken of were not the labours and life of the apostle, or that they did not constitute and express his moral character; so no Christian supposes that the greatness and power of his sin frees him from its responsibility, even when he expresses his helpless misery by saying, with the apostle, “It is not I, but sin that dwelleth in me.”’

Report a mistake

Romans 7:18

For I know that in me

(18) For I know that in me, that is, in my flesh, there dwelleth no good thing, &c. Paul is here explaining how it is that there is such a contradiction between his better principles and his conduct, as just described. The reason is, that in himself, he was entirely depraved, “In me, that is, in my flesh, there dwelleth no good thing.’? As Paul is here speaking of himself, he limits the declaration that there was no good in him. In its full sense, as he was a renewed man, this could not be trué; he therefore adds, “in my flesh.” Agreeably to the explanation given above, v. 14, these words evidently mean, ‘in my nature considered apart from divine influence,’ i. e. ‘in me viewed independently of the effects produced by the Spirit of God.’? This is Paul’s constant use of the word flesh. As he ascribes all excellence in man to the Holy Spirit, in men, when destitute of that Spirit, there is “no good thing.””? To be “in the flesh,”’ is to be unrenewed, and under the government of our own depraved nature; to be “in the Spirit,” is to be under the guidance of the Holy Ghost; ch. 8: 8, 9. So too, in scriptural language, a natural man isa depraved man; and a spiritual man is one that is renewed; 1 Cor. 2:14, 15. It need hardly be remarked that in the flesh cannot here mean in the body. Paul does not mean to say that in his body there was no good thing, as though the body were the seat of sin in man, and that exclusively. He constantly uses the phrase works of the flesh, in reference to sins which have no connexion with the body, as envy, pride, seditions, heresies, &c., Gal. 5: 19, 20.

Romans 7:18 · Open Word Bible

18I know that in me, that is, in my flesh, there is nothing good living. Wanting the good is within my reach; doing it is not.

Report a mistake

For to will is present with me, but to perform that which is good I find not. To will indeed. As willis here opposed to performance, it must have a somewhat different sense from that which it has in v. 15, where it is opposed to the word fo hate. There it means to approve or love; here it means to purpose or desire. ‘I have the purpose or desire to obey the law, but the performance I find not.” J find not, i.e. I do not find to be present; I cannot attain.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:19

For the good that I would

(19) For the good that I would, I do not; but the evil that Iwould not, that Ido. This is a repetition, nearly in the same words, of v.15. Paul re-asserts that he was unable to act up to his purpose and desires. For example, he doubtless desired to love God with all his heart and at all times; but how constantly was his love colder, and less operative than the law demands. This verse is, therefore, but an amplification of the last clause of v. 18. J would ... , means either J approve or dove, as in v. 15; or J purpose, as in v. 18. The numerous passagest quoted by commentators in illustration of this and the preceding verses, though they may serve to throw light upon the language, are expressive of feelings very different from those of the apostle. When an impenitent man says ‘ He is Quid est hoc, Lucili, quod nos alio tendentes alio trahit, et eo, unde recedere cupimus, repellit? Quid colluctatur cum animo nostro, nec permittit nobis quidquam semel velle ? Fluctuamus inter varia concilia, nihil libere volumus, nihil absolute, nihil semper.—Sernxca, Ep. 25.

Sed trahit invitam nova vis, aliudque cupido, mens aliud suadet. Video meliora proboque, deteriora sequor.—Ovin, Metam. VII. 19.

Vos testor, omnes coelites, hoc quod volo, me nolle—Szneca, Hippol. V. 604.

... 2. 26. “Since the sinner does not wish to err, but to act correctly, it is plain that what he wills he does not, and what he wills not he does.”

...

“T know indeed that what I am about to do is evil ;

Romans 7:19 · Open Word Bible

19I fail to do the good I want, and the evil I do not want is what I carry out.

Report a mistake

But passion is too strong for my purposes.” sorry for his sins,’ he may express the real state of his feelings; and yet the import of this language is very different from what it is in the mouth of a man truly contrite. The word sorrow expresses a multitude of very different feelings. Thus, also, when wicked men say they approve the good while they pursue the wrong, their approbation is something very different from Paul’s approbation of the law of God. And when Seneca calls the gods to witness, ‘that what he wills, he does not will,’ he too expresses something far short of what the language of the apostle conveys. This must be so, if there is any such thing as experimental or evangelical religion; that is, if there is any difference between the sorrow for sin and desire of good in the mind of a true Christian, and in the unrenewed and willing votaries of sin in whom conscience is not entirely obliterated.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:20

Now if I do that I would not

(20) Now if I do that I would not, it is na more I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me. The same conclusion from the same premises as in vy. 17. ‘The things which I do, when contrary to the characteristic desires and purposes of my heart, are to be considered as the acts of a slave. They are indeed my own acts, but not being performed with the full and joyful purpose of the heart, are not to be regarded as a fair criterion of character.’

Romans 7:20 · Open Word Bible

20But if I do what I do not want, then I am no longer the one doing it; sin is, the sin that has made its home in me.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:21

£ find then a law

(21) £ find then a law, that when I would do good, evil is present with me. ‘This verse has been subjected to a greater variety of interpretations than any other in the chapter, or perhaps in the whole epistle. The construction in the original is doubtful; and besides this difficulty, there is no little uncertainty as to the sense in which the word daw is to be here taken. The question is, whether Paul means the law of God, of which he has been speaking throughout the chapter, or whether he uses the word in a new sense, for a rule, course, or law of action. Our translators have assumed the latter. If the former sense of the word be preferred, the passage may be thus interpreted. ‘I find, therefore, that to me wishing to do good, evil (the law as the cause of evil) is present with me.’ See Koppe. This is very unnatural. Or thus, ‘I find, therefore, that to me wishing to act according to the law, i. e. to do good, evil is present with me.’ The considerations, however, in favour of the second explanation of the word Jaw appear to be decisive. 1. The other interpretation does not afford a sense suited to the context, as appears from Paul’s own explanation of his meaning in the following verses. ‘I find,’ he says, ‘ this law, that while wishing to do good, I do evil, v. 21; that is, I find that while I delight in the law of God, after the inward man, there is another law in my members which causes me to sin,’ vs. 22, 23. Here it is evident, that the apostle means to explain what he intended by saying in y. 21, that he found or experienced a law which caused him to go counter to his better judgment and desires. ...

Romans 7:21 · Open Word Bible

21This, then, is the law I discover: whenever I set out to do what is good, evil is already there at my side.

Report a mistake

... 2. Having used the word law by itself for the divine law throughout the chapter, he, for the first time, in v. 22, calls it “the law of God,’’ to mark the distinction between the law intended in v. 21, and that intended in v. 22. 3. This sense of the word is not unusual, it occurs repeatedly in the immediately succeeding verses.

The meaning of the verse is, ‘I find, therefore, this law, that to me wishing to do good, evil is present.’ This passage thus expresses the result at which the apostle had arrived. ‘There was this inward conflict in his mind between good and eyil which the law could not terminate. He found, that while wishing to do good, he was still subject to evil, and from this subjection nothing but the grace of God could deliver him. This is more fully explained in the following verses.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:22

For I delight in the law of God after the inward man

(22) For I delight in the law of God after the inward man, &c. In the preceding verse Paul had said, “I would do good;’’ the same desire after conformity to the requisitions of God is here expressed with more distinctness. J delight in the law is a stronger expression than [ consent to it, v.16. As J, in the language of the apostle, includes, as it were, two persons, the new and the old man, the flesh and the spirit, it is necessary to limit the proposition whether he says, “In me there is no good thing,” or “ I delight in the law of God.” The former was true only as to his flesh; the latter only as to his znward man.

Romans 7:22 · Open Word Bible

22In my inner self I gladly agree with God's law.

Report a mistake

That this phrase is here expressive of real complacency and delight in the divine excellence as exhibited in the law, seems evident from the following reasons. 1. Because the delight is restricted to the ¢zrward man, and not spoken of the soul generally. As the term inward man meant at first the soul in opposition to the body, and as the former is superior to the — latter, it naturally became expressive of excellence, and when opposed to something in the soul, indicates its renewed or better feelings. Compare Eph. 3: 16, “Strengthened with might, by his Spirit, in the inner man;”’ i. e. their holy affections being confirmed. 1 Peter 3: 4, “ Hidden man of the heart.’? 2 Cor. 4: 10, “ The inward man is renewed day by day.”’ In all these and similar passages, the phrase includes the idea of excellence. When opposed to the body, it is the soul; but when opposed to something in the mind, as in this passage to the “ law in the members,”’ it means the better feelings or principles. 2. When the bible makes this opposition between a good and evil principle in man, it uniformly attributes the former to the Holy Spirit, especially when any one is spoken of as hating evil and rejoicing in God. 8. A comparison of the terms “ inward man,” “law of the mind,” “ the new man,’ “ the Spirit,” as opposed to “ the law in the memhers,”’ “ the old man,”’ “the flesh,’’ shows that the former are all employed to designate holy feelings, or the soul considered as renewed; and the latter the reverse. This is peculiarly obvious from what is said in v. 25, where “ the flesh”’ is opposed to “the law of the mind.’’ 4, What is here said of the “inward man’”’ and “ the law in the members,”’ is elsewhere said of “the Spirit”? and “the flesh.”? The conflict which is described here, is described also in ch. 8: 13. Gal, 5: 17. ...

Report a mistake

... Col. 3: 9,10; precisely the same things are predicated of the evil principle in all these cases, especially in the passage in Galatians. If, therefore, the contest between “the flesh and Spirit”’ is peculiar to the renewed man, so is also that of which Paul speaks in this chapter.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:23

(23) But I see another law in my members warring against the law af my mind, &ce. Another, i. e. other than the “inward man” or “law of the mind.”? With the one he delighted in the law of God, with the other he was opposed to it. These principles war against each other; exactly as in Gal. 5: 17, the flesh and spirit are represented as being contrary the one to the other, so that we cannot do the things that we would. This law is said to be in my members, i. e. in me; compare ch. 6: 13,19. As he had spoken of the good principle as “ the inward man,’ it was natural to speak of the evil principle as being outward. in my members, therefore, is equivalent to “in my flesh,” in my unsanctified nature. What in vs. 17, 20 is ascribed to ‘ indwelling sin,’ is here attributed to ‘the law in the members.’ The latter is, therefore, but a figurative expression of the same idea. This evil is called a law from its controlling influence; it regulates the conduct as though it had a right to do so. The daw of the mind is evidently but another expression for the “inward man.’? This form of expression was adopted from its natural opposition to the phrase “ law in the members.’’ Bringing me into captivity to the law of sin, which is in my members. The law in my members brings me into ecaptivity to the law of sin; that is, to itself. The form of expression is rather unusual, although the sense appears sufficiently plain from the context. There does not seem to be any adequate reason for making a distinction between “ the law in the members’’ and “ the law of sin;’’ the latter designation is rather explanatory of the former. Indwelling sin wars against the renewed principle, and brings the soul into captivity to itself. This, therefore, is but another form of expressing the idea that he was sold under sin, was its unwilling and unhappy captive, constantly resisting its power and longing for deliverance from its tyranny. Hence the exclamation,

Romans 7:23 · Open Word Bible

23But I see another law in the parts of my body. It is at war with the law of my mind, and it takes me prisoner to the law of sin that is in those parts of my body.

Report a mistake

Romans 7:24

O wretched man that Iam

(24) O wretched man that Iam! Who shall deliver me Srom the body of this death. The expression body of this death has been very variously explained. It may be equivalent to this body of death, by a very common Hebraism, according to which the pronoun, which properly belongs to the governing word, is attached to the word governed; as tdols of his silver, mountain of his holiness, for his idols of silver, &e. “This body of death”? may then mean, this body which is destined or obnoxious to death, i. e. this mortal body. But it is clearly foreign from the spirit of this passage to consider the apostle as here wishing for deliverance from the body. He had been speaking of the burden of sin, and it is from this burden that he longs to be delivered. Body of death is, therefore, better understood as ‘ body which causes death;’ and body may then be taken for flesh, i. e. corrupt nature, which, however, is contrary to usage; or it may be taken metaphorically for sin considered as a body. This is the more natural, as Paul had just spoken of “ members”’ and of sin as something “ outward,”’ in contrast to the “inward man.’ The meaning then is ‘ Who will deliver me from this body, i. e. mass of death, this weight which tends to death.’ This strong expression of the hatefulness of sin, and of earnest desire to be delivered from it, seems to be clearly descriptive of the exercises of a renewed mind.

Romans 7:24 · Open Word Bible

24Wretched man that I am! Who will set me free from this body of death?

Report a mistake

Romans 7:25

(25) The burden of sin being the great evil under which the apostle and all other believers labour, from which no efficacy of the law, and no efforts of their own can deliver them, their case would be entirely hopeless but for help from on high. “Sin shall not have dominion over you,”’ is the language of the grace of God in the gospel. The conflict which the believer sustains is not to result in the victory of sin, but in the triumph of grace. In view of this certain and glorious result, Paul exclaims, J thank God through Jesus Christ our Lord. This is evidently the expression of a strong and sudden emotion of gratitude. As, however, his object is to illustrate the operation of the law, it would be foreign to his purpose to expatiate on a deliverance effected by a different power; he, therefore, does not follow up the idea suggested by this exclamation, but immediately returns to the point in hand.

Romans 7:25 · Open Word Bible

25Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord! So then, I myself serve God's law with my mind, but the law of sin with my flesh.

Report a mistake

III. While there is nothing in the sentiments of this passage which a true Christian may not adopt, there is much which cannot be asserted by any unrenewed man. As far as this point is concerned, it depends, of course, on the correct interpretation of the several expressions employed by the apostle. 1. What is the true meaning of the phrases “ inward man” and “Jaw of the mind,’? when opposed to “ the flesh”’ and “ the law in the members?’? The sense of these expressions is to be determined by their use in other passages, or if they do not elsewhere occur, by the meaning attached to those which are obviously substituted for them. As from the similarity of the passages, it can hardly be questioned, that what Paul here calls “the inward man’’ and “law of the mind,’ he, in Gal. 5: 17 and elsewhere, calls “ the Spirit;’’ it is plain that he intends, by these terms, to designate the soul considered as renewed, in opposition to the “ flesh,” or the soul considered as destitute of divine influence. 2. It is not in accordance with the scriptural representation of the wicked, to describe them as consenting to the law of God, as hating sin and struggling against it, groaning under it as a tyrant’s yoke, as delighting in the law of God, i. e. in holiness; doing all this, not as men, but as men viewed in a particular aspect, as to the inward or new man. This is not the scriptural representation of the natural man, who does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, and cannot know them, 1 Cor. 2: 14. On the contrary, the carnal mind is enmity against God and his law.. ...

Report a mistake

... They, therefore, who are in the flesh, that is, who have this carnal mind, hate and oppose the law, Rom. 8: 7, 8. The expressions here used by the apostle, are such as, throughout the scriptures, are used to describe the exercises of the pious, “whose delight is in the law of the Lord,’ Ps. 1:2. 3. Not only do these particular expressions show that the speaker is a true Christian, but the whole conflict here described is such as is peculiar to the sincere believer. There is, indeed, in the natural man, something very analogous to this, when his conscience is enlightened, and his better feelings come into collision with the strong inclination to evil which dwells in his mind. But this struggle is very far below that which the apostle here describes. The true nature of this conflict seems to be ascertained beyond dispute, by the parallel passage in Gal. 5: 17, already referred to. It cannot be denied, that to possess the Spirit is, in scriptural language, a characteristic mark of atrue Christian. “ But ye are not in the flesh, but in the spirit, if so be the Spirit of God dwell in you. Now if any man have not the Spirit of Christ, he is none of his,’? Rom. 8: 9. Those, therefore, who have that Spirit, are Christians. This being the case, it will not be doubted that the passage in Galatians, in which the spirit is represented as warring against the flesh, and the flesh against the spirit, is descriptive of the experience of the true believer. But the conflict there described is identical with that of which the same apostle speaks in this chapter. This is evident, not merely from the fact that one of the antagonist principles is, in both cases, called flesh, but because the description is nearly in the same words. ...

Report a mistake

... In consequence of the opposition of the flesh and spirit, Paul tells the Galatians they cannot do the things that they would; and he says here of himself, that in consequence of the opposition between the flesh and the law of his mind, what he would he did not. The same conflict and the same bondage are described in each case; if the one be descriptive of the exercises of a true Christian, the other must be so also. my ways, &c.,” the meaning is, that while they indulge in sin, they make much ado about religion, are very zealous for its forms or doctrines, &c.; see also Mark 6: 20. John 5: 35, IV. The context, or the connexion of this passage with the preceding and succeeding chapters, is in favour of the common interpretation. The contrary is, indeed, strongly asserted by those who take the opposite view of the passage. Tholuck seems to admit that, were it not for the context, the whole of the latter part of the chapter might well be understood of the believer; see his remarks on v. 14. And Prof. Stuart says, “I repeat the remark, that the question is not, whether what is here said might be applied to Christians; but whether, from the tenor of the context, it appears to have been the intention of the writer that it should be so applied. This principle cannot fail to settle the question concerning such an application,” p. 558. It may be proper to pause to remark, that such statements involve a renunciation of the arguments derived from the inapplicability to the real Christian, of what is here said. Every thing is here admitted to be in itself inapplicable to him, did but the context allow it to be so applied. Yet every one is aware that no argument is more frequently and strongly urged against the common interpretation, than that the description here given is, in its very nature, unsuitable to Christian experience. On the same page which contains the passage just quoted, Prof. ...

Report a mistake

... Stuart says, “ As, however, there is no denying the truth of these and the like declarations, and no receding from them, nor explaining them away as meaning less than habitual victory over sin; so it follows that when vs. 14—25 are applied to Christian experience, they are wrongly applied. The person represented in these verses, succumbs to sin IN EVERY INSTANCE of contest.’? This is certainly an argument against applying the passage in question to the Christian, founded on the assumption that it is, from its nature, entirely inapplicable. And the argument is perfectly conclusive, if the meaning of the passage be what is here stated. But it is believed that this is very far from being its true meaning, as shown above. This argument, however, it appears, is not insisted upon, every thing is made to depend upon the context.

Report a mistake

Many distinguished commentators, as Alfonso Turrettin, Knapp, Tholuck, Flatt, Stuart, consider this chapter, from v. 7 to the end, as a commentary upon v. 5, in which verse the state of those who are in “ the flesh” is spoken of; and the first part of the next chapter as a commentary on v. 6, which speaks of those who are no longer under the law. Accordingly, verses 7—25 are descriptive of the exercises of a man yet under the law; and ch. 8: 1—17 of those of a man under the gospel, or of a believer. It is said that the two passages are in direct antithesis; the one describes the state of a captive to sin, ch. 7: 23, and the other the state of one who is delivered from sin, ch. 8: 2. This is certainly ingenious and plausible, but is founded on a twofold misapprehension; first, as to the nature of this captivity to sin, or the real meaning of the former passage (ch. 7: 14—25); and, secondly, as to the correct interpretation of the latter passage, or ch. 8: 1—17. If ch. 7: 14—25 really describes such a captivity as these “authors suppose, in which the individual spoken of ‘succumbs to sin in every instance,’ there is, of course, an end of the question, and that too without any appeal to the context for support. But, on the other hand, if it describes no such state, but, as Tholuck and Prof. Stuart admit, contains nothing which might not be said of the Christian, the whole force of the argument is gone; verses 7—25 are no longer necessarily a comment on v. 5; nor ch. 8: 1—17 on vy. 6. The antithesis, of course, ceases, if the interpretation, to which it owes its existence, be abandoned. The matter, after all, therefore, is made to depend on the correct exposition of the passage, vs. 14—25, itself. A particular interpretation cannot first be assumed, in order to make out the antithesis; and then the antithesis be assumed to justify the interpretation. This would be reasoning in a circle. ...

Report a mistake

... In the second place, this view of the context is founded, as is believed, on an erroneous exegesis of ch. 8: 1—17. The first part of that chapter is not so intimately connected with the latter part of this, nor is it designed to show that the Christian is delivered from “the law of sin and death” in his members. For the grounds of this statement, the reader is referred to the commentary on the passage in question. Even if the reverse were the fact, still, unless it can be previously shown that vs. 14—25 of this chapter describe the state of a man under the law, there is no ground for the assumption of such an antithesis between the two passages, as is supposed in the view of the context stated above. Both passages might describe the same individual under different aspects; the one exhibiting the operation of the law, and the other that of the gospel on the renewed mind. But if the exposition given below of ch. 8: 1—17 is correct, there is not a shadow of foundation for the argument derived from the context against the common interpretation of ch. 7: 14—25.

Report a mistake

The whole tenor of the apostle’s argument, from the beginning of the epistle to the close of this chapter, is not only consistent with the common interpretation, but seems absolutely to demand it. His great object in the first eight chapters, is to show that the whole work of the sinner’s salvation, his justification and sanctification, are not of the law but of grace; that legal obedience can never secure the one, nor legal efforts the other. Accordingly, in the first five chapters, he shows that we are justified by faith, without the works of the law; in the sixth, that this doctrine of gratuitous justification, instead of leading to licentiousness, presents the only certain and effectual means of sanctification. In the beginning of the seventh chapter, he shows that the believer is really thus free from the law, and is now under grace; and that while under the law he brought forth fruit unto sin, but being under grace, he now brings forth fruit unto God. The question here arises, why is the holy, just and good law thus impotent? Isit becauseit isevil? Far from it; the reason les in our own corruption. Then, to show how this is, and why the objective and authoritative exhibition of truth cannot sanctify, the apostle proceeds to show how it actually operates on the depraved mind. In the first place, it enlightens conscience, and, in the second, it rouses the opposition of the corrupt heart. These are the two elements of conviction of sin; a knowledge of its nature, and a sense of its power over ourselves. Hence the feeling of self-condemnation, of helplessness and misery. Thus the law slays. This is one portion of its effect, but not the whole; for even after the heart is renewed, as it is but imperfectly sanctified, the law is still unable to promote holiness. The reason here again is not that the law is evil, but that we are carnal, v. 14. Indwelling sin, as the apostle calls it, is the cause why the law cannot effect the sanctification even of the believer. ...

Report a mistake

... It presents indeed the form of beauty, and the soul delights in it after the inward man; but the corrupt affections, which turn to self and the world, are still there; these the law cannot destroy. But though the law cannot do this, it shall eventually be done. Thanks to God, through Jesus Christ, our case is not hopeless.

The apostle’s object would have been but half attained, had he not thus exhibited the effect of the law upon the believer’s mind, and demonstrated that a sense of legal bondage was not necessary to the Christian, and could not secure his sanctification. Having done this, his object is accomplished. The eighth chapter, therefore, is not so intimately connected with the seventh. It does not commence with an inference from the discussion in vs. 7—25, but from the whole preceding exhibition. “There is, therefore, now no condemnation to them that are in Christ Jesus.” Why? Because they are sanctified ? No; but because they are not under the law. This is the main point from first to last. They are delivered from that law, which, however good in itself, can only produce sin and death, y. 2. In view of this insufficiency of the law, God, having sent his Son as a sacrifice for sin, has delivered them from it, by condemning sin in him, and has thus secured the justification of believers. 'Fhrough him they satisfy the demands of the law, and their salvation is rendered certain. This, however, implies that they do not live after the flesh, but after the Spirit, agreeably to the doctrine of the sixth chapter, for salvation in sin is a contradiction in terms.

Report a mistake

There is, therefore, no such antithesis between the seventh and eight chapters, as the opposite interpretation supposes. It is not the design of the latter to ‘show that men are delivered from indwelling sin; or that the conflict between the “law in the members”? and “the law of the mind,’’ between the flesh and Spirit, ceases when men embrace the gospel. But it shows that this consummation is secured to all who are in Christ, to all who do not deliberately and of choice walk after the flesh, and make it their guide and master. In virtue of deliverance from the law, and introduction into a state of grace, the believer has not only his acceptance with God, but his final deliverance from sin secured. Sin shall not triumph in those who have the Spirit of Christ, and who, by that Spirit, mortify the deeds of the body.

If then the context is altogether favourable to the ordinary interpretation; if the passage is accurately descriptive of Christian experience, and analogous to other inspired accounts of the exercises of the renewed heart; if not merely particular expres- sions, but the whole tenor of the discourse is inconsistent with the scriptural account of the natural man; and if Paul, in the use of the first person and the present tense, cannot, without violence, be considered otherwise than as expressing his own feelings while writing, we have abundant reason to rest satisfied with the obvious sense of the passage.

Report a mistake

So then, with the mind, I myself serve the law of God, but with the flesh, the law of sin. Mind and flesh are here opposed. As the latter, according to the constant usage of the apostle, signifies that which is corrupt in man, his unsanctified nature; the former must mean here, as in v. 23, that nature as renewed. In every believer, and in no one else, there are these two principles, grace and sin, the flesh and spirit, the law in the members and the law in the mind; these are contrary the one to the other. ‘Z myself,’ says the apostle, or ‘I one and the same man, feel both of those principles within me. With the one, I serve the law of God; with the other, the law of sin, that is, sin itself, which, as a law in my members, essays to control my conduct.’ This, in few words, is the sum of what the apostle has said from v. 14. Such is the state in which the law leaves the believer; such the effect of the mere objective and preceptive presentation of truth. The law excites in the unrenewed mind opposition and hatred; in the pious mind complacency and delight; but in neither case can it break the power of sin, or introduce the soul into the true liberty of the children of God.

Report a mistake

Having gone through the exposition of this passage, it is time to pause and ask, Of whom has Paul been speaking, of a renewed or unrenewed man? Few questions of this kind have been more frequently canvassed, or more intimately associated with the doctrinal views of different classes of theologians. The history of the interpretation of the latter part of this chapter, is one of the most interesting sections of the doctrinal history of the church. A brief outline of this history may be found in the Dissertation of Knapp above referred to, and somewhat more extended in the commentary of Tholuck. It appears that during the first three centuries, the fathers were generally agreed in considering the passage as descriptive of the experience of one yet under the law. Even Augustine at first concurred in the correctness of this view. But as a deeper insight into his own heart, and a more thorough investigation of the scriptures, led to the modification of his opinions on so many other points, they produced a change on this subject also. This general alteration of his doctrinal views cannot be attributed to his controversy with Pelagius, because it took place long before that controversy commenced. It is to be ascribed to his religious experience, and his study of the word of God.

Report a mistake

The writers of the middle ages, in general, agreed with the later views of Augustine on this as on other subjects. At the time of the Reformation, the original diversity of opinion on this point, and on all others connected with it, soon became manifested. rasmus, Socinus, and others, revived the opinion of the Greek fathers; while Luther, Calvin, Melancthon, Beza, &c. adhered to the opposite interpretation. Ata later period, when the controversy with the Remonstrants occurred, it com- menced with a discussion of the interpretation of this chapter. The first writings of Arminius, in which he broached his peculiar opinions, were lectures on this passage. All his associates and successors, as Grotius, Episcopius, Limborch, &c., adopted the same view of the subject. As a general rule, Arminian writers have been found on one side of this question, and Calvinistic authors on the other. This is indeed the natural result of their different views of the scriptural doctrine of the natural state ofman. Most of the former class, going much farther than Arminius himself ever went, either denying that the corruption consequent on the fall is such as to destroy the power of men to conform themselves to the law of God, or maintaining that. this power, if lost, is restored by those operations of the Holy Spirit which are common to all, found no difficulty in considering the expressions, “I consent to”? and “delight in the law of God after the inward man,’ as the language ef a person yet in his natural state. On the other hand, those who held the doctrine of total depravity, and of the consequent inability of sinners, and who rejected the doctrine of “common grace,” could not reconcile with these opinions the strong language here used by the apostle.

Report a mistake

Although this has been the general course of opinion on this subject, some of the most evangelical men, especially on the continent of Europe, have agreed with Erasmus in this view of this passage. This was the case with Francke, Arnold, Bengel, &e., of a previous age; and with Knapp, Flatt, Tholuck, &c., of our own day; not to mention the distinguished writers of England and our own country, who have adopted the same view. There is nothing, therefore, in this opinion, which implies the denial or disregard of any of the fundamental principles of evangelical religion. Still, that the view of the passage which so long prevailed in the church, and which has been generally adopted by evangelical men, is the correct one, seems evident from the following considerations.

Report a mistake

I. The onus probandi is certainly on the other side. When the apostle uses not only the first person, but the present tense, and says, “I consent to the law that it is good,’’ “I delight in the law of God,’’ “TI see another law in my members warring against the law of my mind,’’ &c. &c., those who deny that he means himself, even though he says Z myself, or refuse to acknowledge that this language expresses his feelings while writing, are surely bound to let the contrary very clearly be seen. Appearances are certainly against them. It should be remembered that Paul uses this language, not once or twice, but uniformly through the whole passage, and that too with an ardour of feeling indicative of language coming directly from the heart, and expressing its most joyful or painful experience. This is a consideration which cannot be argumentatively exhibited, but it must impress every attentive and susceptible reader. To suppose that the apostle is personating another, either, as Grotius supposes, the Jew first before the giving of the law, and then after it; or as Erasmus thinks a Gentile without the law, as opposed to a Jew under it; or as is more commonly supposed, an ordinary individual under the influence of a knowledge of the law; is to suppose him to do what he does no where else in any of his writings, and what is entirely foreign to his whole spirit and manner. Instead of thus sinking himself in another, he can hardly prevent his own individual feelings from mingling with, and moulding the very statement of objections to his own reasoning; see ch. 3: 3—8. One great difficulty in explaining his epistles arises from this very source. It is hard to tell at times what is his language, and what that of an objector. ...

Report a mistake

... If any one will examine the passages in which Paul is supposed to mean another, when he uses the first person, he will see how far short they come of affording any parallel to the case supposed in this chapter.t In many of them he undoubtedly means himself, as in 1 Cor. 3: 5, &c. 4: 3, &c.; in others the language is, in one sense, expressive of the apostle’s real sentiments, and is only perverted by the objector, as in 1 Cor. 6: 12; while in others the personation of another is only for a single sentence. Nothing analogous to this passage is to be found in all his writings, if indeed he is not here pouring out the feelings of his own heart.

Report a mistake

II. There is no necessity for denying that Paul here speaks t The passages referred to by Knapp are 1 Cor. 3: 5, &c. 4: 3, &c. 6: 12. 10: 29, 30, 18: 11, 12. 14: 14, 15. Gal. 2: 18—21, of himself, and describes the exercises of arenewed man. There is not an expression from beginning to the end of this section, which the holiest man may not and must not adopt. This has been shown in the commentary. The strongest declarations, as, for example, “I am carnal, and sold under sin,”’ admit, indeed, by themselves, of an interpretation inconsistent with even ordinary morality; but, as explained by the apostle, and limited by the context, they express nothing more than every believer experiences. What Christian does not feel, in the very centre of his soul, that he is carnal! Alas, how different is he from the spirits of the just made perfect! How cheerfully does he recognise his obligation to love God with all the heart, and yet how constantly does the tendency to self and the world, the law in his members, war against the purer and better law of his mind, and bring him into subjection to sin! If, indeed, it were true, as has been asserted, that the person here described “succumbs to sin IN EVERY INSTANCE Of contest,’’ the description would be inapplicable not to the Christian only, but to any other than the most immoral of men. It is rare indeed, even in the natural conflict between reason and passion, or conscience and corrupt inclination, that the better principle does not succeed, not once merely, but often. There is, however, nothing approaching even to the implication of such a sentiment in the whole passage. Paul merely asserts that the believer is, and ever remains in this life, imperfectly sanctified ; that sin continues to dwell within him; that he never comes up to the full requisitions of the law, however anxiously he may desire it. Often as he subdues one spiritual foe, another rises ina different form; so that he cannot do the things that he would; that is, cannot be perfectly conformed in heart and life to the image of God.

Report a mistake

It must have been in a moment of forgetfulness, that such a man as Tholuck could quote with approbation the assertion of Dr. A. Clarke; “This opinion has most pitifully and shamefully, not only lowered the standard of Christianity, but destroyed its influence and disgraced its character.” What lamentable blindness to notorious facts does such language evince! From the days of Job and David to the present hour, the holiest men have been the most ready to acknowledge and deplore the existence and power of indwelling sin. Without appealing to individual illustrations of the truth of this remark, look at masses of men, at Augustinians and Pelagians, Calvinists and Remonstrants; in all ages the strictest doctrines and the sternest morals have been found united. It is not those who have most exalted human ability, that have most advantageously exhibited the fruits of this power. It has been rather those who, with the lowest views of themselves and the highest of the efficacy of the grace of God, have been able to adopt the language of Paul, “ What I would, that do I not;’’? and who, looking away from themselves to him through whom they can do all things, have shown the divine strength manifested in their weakness.

Report a mistake