Logia

Where the churches differ · John

The flesh profits nothing: how has the church read John 6:60–66?

John 6:60–66

When they heard this, many of His disciples said, "This message is harsh. Who can bear to listen to it?" Jesus was aware that His disciples were grumbling about this, so He said to them, "Does this make you stumble? Then what if you were to see the Son of Man going up to where He was before? The Spirit is the one who gives life; the flesh is of no benefit at all. The words I have spoken to you are spirit, and they are life. Yet some among you do not believe." For Jesus had known from the start who the ones were that did not believe, and who would be the one to betray Him. And He added, "This is the reason I told you that no one is able to come to Me unless it has been given to them by the Father." At this, many of His disciples drew back and stopped going about with Him.

How the readings differ

AI draft, not yet reviewed Logia wrote this note; it is not commentary. It is a draft until a named reviewer approves it.

Held in common All take the verse as Jesus' own word on how the discourse is to be heard: it is the Spirit who gives life.

Of the sacrament

Readers who take the discourse of the sacrament hear in this verse a warning against a merely physical understanding of it: the Spirit gives the gift its life.

Of faith

Readers who take the discourse of faith hear the key to the whole of it: Jesus' words are to be understood spiritually, of believing in him.

This passage is one of the places the traditions read John differently.

Every commentator in Logia on the passage (11)

All of them, in the order they died, each by the opening words of what they say. Logia chooses none of them, and publishes a page like this only when they come from enough traditions to be fair.

  • Early church 3
  • Catholic 2
  • Lutheran 1
  • Reformed 2
  • Methodist 1
  • Anglican 2
  1. John Chrysostom c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East)

    On John 6:63 · 6 excerpts on the passage

    His meaning is, “Ye must hear spiritually what relateth to Me, for he who heareth carnally is not profited, nor gathereth any advantage.” It was carnal to question how He came down from heaven, to deem that He was the son of Joseph, to ask, “How can he give us His flesh to eat?” All this was carnal, when they…

    Read it all

  2. Augustine of Hippo 354–430 · Patristic (Latin West)

    On John 6:62–63 · 7 excerpts on the passage

    4. And He said, “It is the Spirit that quickeneth; the flesh profiteth nothing.” Before we expound this, as the Lord grants us, that other must not be negligently passed over, where He says, “Then what if ye shall see the Son of man ascending where He was before?” For Christ is the Son of man, of the Virgin Mary.…

    Read it all

  3. Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 · Patristic (Greek East)

    On John 6:60–61 · 4 excerpts on the passage

    This is the custom of the simple: they ever find fault with the more subtle doctrines and foolishly tear in pieces any thought that is above them, because themselves understand it not: although they ought rather to have been eager to learn, and to have loved to search diligently the things spoken, not on the contrary to rise up against…

    Read it all

  4. Thomas Aquinas 1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic

    On John 6:63 · 10 excerpts on the passage

    CHRYS. He tries to remove their difficulties in another way, as follows, the spirit that quickeneth, the flesh profiteth nothing: that is to say, You ought to understand My words in a spiritual sense: he who understands them carnally is profited nothing. To interpret carnally is to take a proposition in its bare literal meaning, and allow no other. But…

    Read it all

  5. John Calvin 1509–1564 · Reformed

    On John 6:63 · 11 excerpts on the passage

    63. It is the Spirit that quickeneth. By these words Christ shows the reason why the Jews did not profit by his doctrine to be, that, being spiritual and quickening, it does not find ears well prepared. But as this passage has been variously expounded, it will be of importance first to ascertain the natural meaning of the words; from…

    Read it all

  6. Cornelius a Lapide 1567–1637 · Roman Catholic (Jesuit)

    On John 6:63 · 7 excerpts on the passage

    Ver. 63. — Jf therefore ye shall see, &c. " He is speaking," says Euthymius, "concerning His future assumption into heaven." For some of them, such as the Apostles, beheld this. And others, who did not believe, although they saw it not, might have heard, and certainly leamt from those who did see.

    Read it all

  7. Matthew Henry 1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian)

    On John 6:63 · 11 excerpts on the passage

    [2.] He gives them a general key to this and all such parabolical discourses, teaching them that they are to be understood spiritually, and not after a corporal and carnal manner: It is the spirit that quickeneth, the flesh profiteth nothing, v. 63. As it is in the natural body, the animal spirits quicken and enliven it, and without these…

    Read it all

  8. Johann Albrecht Bengel 1687–1752 · Lutheran Pietist

    On John 6:63–64 · 5 excerpts on the passage

    I have spoken) He does not say, I speak, but I have spoken [Engl. Vers. loses this, “I speak” ]. For already they were disaffected towards [turned away from] Him, ver. 60, 61. ... spirit) although they [the words] speak of the flesh. ... and) and so therefore. ... but there are) With yourselves rests the blame. ... some) who…

    Read it all

  9. John Wesley 1703–1791 · Anglican (Methodist)

    On John 6:63 · 6 excerpts on the passage

    63. It is the Spirit - The spiritual meaning of these words, by which God giveth life. The flesh - The bare, carnal, literal meaning, profiteth nothing. The words which I have spoken, they are spirit - Are to be taken in a spiritual sense and, when they are so understood, they are life - That is, a means of…

    Read it all

  10. J. C. Ryle 1816–1900 · Anglican (Evangelical)

    On John 6:60–65 · 14 excerpts on the passage

    We learn from these verses that some of Christ's sayings seem hard to flesh and blood. We arc told that " many " who had followed our Lord for a season, were offended when He spoke of " eating his flesh and drinking his blood." They murmured and said " This is an hard saying ; who can hear it…

    Read it all

  11. B. F. Westcott 1825–1901 · Anglican

    On John 6:60–71 · 10 excerpts on the passage

    The discourses proved a trial to the faith of the disciples. The immediate effect was a " murmuring " among them which led to a clear affirmation of the divine conditions of discipleship (60 — 6.5). ...

    Read it all