Johann Albrecht Bengel · Gnomon of the New Testament, Vol. II (Gospels according to St Luke and St John)
John 21
24 excerpts on John 21, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
after these things) More than eight days, as it seems, having intervened, for they had now no longer an expectation of another manifestation: ver. 4. John proves by an example that it was in his power to have recorded more miracles than what were written: ch, xx. 30. [This chapter is a kind of appendix to the book.—V. g.] ... He manifested Himself) This conveys to the reader a more striking idea than ... at the sea) In such a way, however, as that He did not Himself enter the sea, after the resurrection : comp. Rev. xxi. 1, “ A new earth,—and there was no more sea.”
John 21:1 · Open Word Bible
1After this Jesus revealed Himself to the disciples once more, by the Sea of Tiberias. It happened in this way.
together) in the one place, in the house, seven in all. ... Thomas) who was now the less absent than formerly (ch. xx. 24), and was the more confirmed and to be confirmed. ... Nathanael) ch. i. 46, note. His name here occurring in the midst of names of apostles, makes it likely he was the same as Bartholomew. ... the sons of Zebedee) John therefore wrote this book; for had any one else written it, he would have named John with his brother, immediately after Peter. Also he takes it for granted as a thing known from the other Evangelists, who were the sons of Zebedee, as well as who was Zebedee. ... of the disciples) apostles or others.
John 21:2 · Open Word Bible
2Simon Peter was there with Thomas (called Didymus, which means Twin), Nathanael from Cana in Galilee, Zebedee's sons, and two more of His disciples.
a fishing) Constrained by necessity, not for the sake of gain: ver. 5, “ Children, have ye any meat?” ‘No.’ A remarkable example of ... labouring with one’s own hands, without sacrificing the ... we also) They were now by this time not so much afraid. ... into a ship) which is called in ver. 8 a little ship.
John 21:3–4 · Open Word Bible
3Simon Peter said to them, "I am going out fishing." They answered, "We will come with you." They went out and got into the boat, but all that night they caught nothing. 4Just as day was breaking, Jesus stood on the shore, though the disciples did not realize that it was Jesus.
Little sons) A name of age [t.e. such as would be used by an aged person]. He addresses them as though He were one unknown, lovingly, from an elevation above them, as being the eternal Wisdom.' ... meat) as for instance a fish. ... no) Human art is not always consistent with itself [cannot always produce the same results]: but ver. 6, the Divine blessing always is [always can]. ... the right side) A most precise and unerring command. The power of the Lord collected together the fishes thither.
John 21:5–6 · Open Word Bible
5So Jesus called out to them, "Friends, you have no fish to eat, have you?" They answered Him, "No." 6He said to them, "Throw the net out on the boat's right side, and you will find fish." So they threw it out, and now they could not haul it in because there were so many fish.
saith) A quiet life more quickly observes Divine things, than an active life: and yet this latter furnishes an opportunity of doing so, and does not fail to produce fruit in the case of saints. ... But the Lxx. render by the word ... (the long upper garment worn by persons of rank). ... girt on himself) Peter [did so, because he] reverenced the presence of the Lord, whereas he had been previously engaged with his fellow-disciples in a more familiar manner. ... He had stript off (whilst fishing with his fellow-disciples) ... he cast himself into the sea) being likely to reach the Lord sooner by swimming than by ship. Comp. Matt. xiv. 28, “ Peter said, Lord, if it be Thou, bid me come unto Thee on the water.’? The love of Jesus draws one through fires and waves.
John 21:7 · Open Word Bible
7Then that disciple whom Jesus loved told Peter, "It is the Lord!" Hearing that it was the Lord, Simon Peter tied his outer garment around himself, since he had stripped for work, and threw himself into the sea.
for) These latter also (as well as Peter) were able to come quickly. ... the net) which had been left by Peter. ... they see) unexpectedly. A miracle. ... a small fish) a single one. ... a loaf) a single one: ver. 13, “ Jesus taketh the loaf” [Engl. vers., ‘ bread,’ loses the force of the article]. Jesus entertained His disciples at a feast: and with food, which would have been only enough for one guest, He fed them all.
John 21:8–9 · Open Word Bible
8The other disciples came in the boat, towing the net full of fish. They were not far out, only about 100 yards from land. 9When they came ashore, they saw a charcoal fire already there, with fish laid on it, and bread.
bring) Thus the disciples were able to perceive, that that fish was as real as the rest of the fishes. ... of) The remainder of the plentiful supply, they were allowed to keep. ... ye have caught) It was by the Lord’s gift that they had caught them: and yet He kindly says, that they had caught them. ... now) Demonstratively, in order that they might attend. In antithesis to, “that night they caught nothing,” ver. 3.
John 21:10 · Open Word Bible
10Jesus said to them, "Bring some of the fish that you have just caught."
of great fishes) which just now the great Lord had called, little fishes, ver. 10. It was thus (by fishing) that they had their livelihood (whilst in Galilee) up to the time of their journey into Judea. ... It is wonderful that the actual number should be thus expressed in this passage, as contrasted with Luke v. 6 (the ratio of which number might have affected the disciples more then than now), although the completely round number one hundred and fifty was so near, to which 4; might have been also added for accuracy, as in ver. 8, “about two hundred cubits.” The number cliii., is memorable. Jerome, on Ezek. xlvii. [9, 10, “ There shall be ... , “They who have written of the natures and peculiar qualities of animals, who have learned ... as well in the Latin as in the Greek language, of whom Oppian, a Cicilian, is the most learned poet, assert that there are one hundred and fifty-three kinds of fishes, all of which were taken by the apostles, and not one remained ... ; whilst both the noble and base-born, the rich and poor, and every class of men, are being drawn out of the sea of the world to salvation.” Comp. Matt. xiii. 47, “ The kingdom of heaven is like unto a net that was cast into the sea, and gathered of every kind.” ... was not broken) A new miraculous circumstance.
John 21:11 · Open Word Bible
11So Simon Peter went aboard and hauled the net ashore, full of large fish, 153 of them. Even with so many, the net did not tear.
come) The Lord receives His disciples at the banquet. In ver. 9 there is mentioned the preparation for dinner (or rather luncheon, or breakfast, ... breakfast or dine) viz. ye. Jesus had no necessity to eat. From the mention of breakfast or luncheon (the morning meal), with which comp. ver. 4, “the morning,” it is evident the manifestation (ver. 1) of Him lasted many hours. ... none) Implying the great solemnity of this feast.
John 21:12 · Open Word Bible
12Jesus said to them, "Come, eat your breakfast." Not one of the disciples dared ask Him, "Who are You?" They knew it was the Lord.
when) During their eating there had been more than usual silence. Silence at the beginning of a feast is not only the part of politeness, but even of modesty and self-control. ... The Byz. and Lat. formerly omitted these words, as is evident from Augustine. Nor were they in the cod. ... lovest [amas] thou Me?) Thrice the Lord asks a question: Lovest thou Me more than these? ... dost thou esteem Me? Thrice Peter answers, I do esteem Thee. ... is the part of relationship and affection : ... is the act-of the judgment. Others make this distinction, that ... to love in such a way as that we should evince our love by kissing one: and this is the distinction which ... upholds; but Peter, to the question of the Lord ... ey does not seem to have been likely to answer ... more emphatically, than was’ the expression in the question, pind. Where the difference is not expressed, the one is included in the signification of the other.’ Jesus, now that Peter’s faith was established, questions him about his dove: and this is the distinguishing ... of the Shepherd. On this condition of love depend the things which are mentioned in ver. 15, etc., and ver. 18, ... more than these, viz. thy ... this man, occurs in ver. 21. Previously Peter had said that he would show more fidelity than these (his fellow-disciples): Matt. xxvi. 33, “ Though ... shall be offended because of Thee, yet will I never be offended :” but now he simply says, I love Thee: he does not add, more than these. Yet he had lately shown himself most eagerly desirous of the Lord, in ver. 7 [“ He cast himself into the sea,” to reach Him the sooner]. ... Thou knowest) Peter had given a proof of the contrary by his late denial of Jesus: now, instead of argument, he makes his appeal to the knowledge and omniscience of Jesus.
John 21:15 · Open Word Bible
15After they had eaten breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me more than these?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My lambs."
feed) The words, more than these, serve to indicate that Peter is here restored to his place, which he had lost by his denial of Jesus ; and at the same time that a something is assigned to him peculiarly, as compared with the other disciples, but nothing from which the others are to be excluded: for in truth they also loved Jesus, ch. xvi. 27. Let the Pope, in the name of truth, cease, under the pretext of the succession to Peter, to claim violently this privilege to himself, and himself alone, seeing that he is one who does not either love or feed the sheep, but on the contrary feeds upon them. Rome can no more claim Peter as her own, than Jerusalem or Antioch, or any other place where Peter acted as an apostle: nay, Rome, as being the capital of the Gentiles, can least of all claim him. For Peter was one of the apostles of the circumcision. There is one feature peculiar to Rome, that the blood of the apostles, including even Peter, is to be ‘found’ in her: Rev. xviii. 20, 24. ... My lambs) Jesus is the Lord of the sheep and of the lambs. He loves His flock, and commits it to him that loves Him.
feed) This verb Peter has repeated in his first Epistle, ch. v. 2. ... sheep) The Latin Vulg. has, in the second answer, ‘agnos’:' although it comes to the same thing, as we shall presently see. By far the most frequent form in which this saying was quoted, was, Feed My sheep. Therefore more modern transcribers have introduced into John the formula which Ancient writers employed; and John seems to have written ... in this second place. [A different judgment is passed upon this reading in the margin of both Ed. and in Vers. Germ., wherein the word ... is approved of only in the first place, ver. 15: however, the subject itself, exhibiting as it does three periods, equally favours each of the two views.
John 21:16 · Open Word Bible
16A second time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Shepherd My sheep."
Peter and Paul, that the little sheep were commended to Peter, as also the sheep. Neither of these writers, indeed, reads in ver. 16, ... as Bellarmine contends in his B. I. concerning the Roman Pontiff, ch. xvi., whilst seeking to find marvellous classes'of sheep, subject to the Pope: but at all events those ancient writers acknowledged the gradation in the three sentences, which most delightfully accords with 1 John ii. 13, 14, “ Fathers— young men—little children.” Between this discourse and the death of Peter there elapsed thirty-six years: and this discourse itself divides that space of time into almost three equal periods. During the first, Peter fed the tender age of the Christian Church, or in other words the lambs ; the appellation of which is in consonance with that appellation which is found in Acts, viz. disciples, to which afterwards the appellation, brethren, succeeded. See on Matt. x. 1,2. [The Apostles were often called disciples before Pentecost ; after it never, but apostles. In Acts, those who either had learned with, or were learning from the apostles, were called disciples. After Acts vi. 1, xxi. 16, the term disciples does not occur in the New Testament, but they are called brethren, Christians, believers, saints, ... In the second period, he brought to him, ruled, and gathered together, the sheep. In the third, he fed the Church collected out of Jews and Gentiles up to the time of his martyrdom. 17. ... the third time) Comp. ch. xiii. 88. The decisive number. ... was grieved) In feeling so, his distress was with good reason.
and he said unto Him) At this point, as it were wearied out, he pours out his whole self [in a one final appeal to His omniscience]. ... Thou knowest all things) Peter in truth had most largely had proof of the Omnt- SCIENCE of the Lord Jesus, along with the rest of the disciples. Let us first collect the testimonies of it which occur in the Gospel of John. Jesus knew who Simon was, ch. i. 42: The mind and action of Nathanael, ver. 47, 48: What is in every man, ch. ii. 25: The deeds of the woman of Samaria, ch. iv. 29: What He Himself was about to do, ch. vi. 6: The treachery of Judas and of others, ch. vi. 64, 70: The death of Lazarus, ch. xi. 11: That His hour had come, ch. xiii, 1: The treachery of Judas, ver. 8: The denial of Peter, ver. 38: The disciples’ desire to question Him, ch. xvi. 19: And all things, ver. 30: The several things which should come upon Him, ch. xviii. 4: And their consummation, ch. xix. 28. Furthermore He knew, according to the report of the rest of the Evangelists, the thoughts of men, Mark ii. 6, 8; Luke vi. 8, vii. 47 (with which comp. ver. 39); Matt. xii. 25, xvi. 8; Luke ix. 47, xi. 17. Also what was the raiment of Solomon, Matt. vi. 29: What Sodom, Tyre, and Sidon would have done had they seen the works of Christ, ch. xi. 21, 23. He predicted His Passion, Matt. xvi. 21; Mark viii. 31; Luke ix. 22, etc.: The destruction of Jerusalem, Luke xix. 43; Matt. xxiii. 35, etc., xxiv. 2, etc.; Luke xxiii. 28, etc.: The circumstances which were about to accompany His entrance into the city and the Passover feast, Mark xi. 2, etc., xiv. 13, 15, 27: And very many other things of that kind.—Harm., p. 609, 610.]
verily) Even after the Resurrection the Lord employed this most weighty formula. ... a comparatively young man) The comparative comprises the years of Peter, even as far as to the threshold of old age. ... thou didst gird thyself) as in ver. 7. ... and didst walk about) as in ver. 3, “I go a fishing.” ... whither thou wouldest) So he had done in ver. 7. ... thou shalt be old) Hereby it is indicated, that Peter would reach old age, 1 Pet. v. 1, “I who am also an elder ;” but not a great old age. ... thou shalt stretch forth) after the manner of those crucified, thine hands, so as that they may be made fast to the transverse beam of the cross. ... shall gird thee) with a cord. ... shall carry thee) to the stock of the cross, so as that thou mayest be fastened to it with thy whole body. They used to be bound to the cross, whilst the nails were fastened in. In antithesis to, thou didst walk about. ... whither) namely, to the place where the cross is to be fastened into the ground. ‘This passage must be so explained as not to apply to every kind of punishment [but to crucifixion only]. ... wouldest not) according to the prompting of nature [as contrasted with grace].
John 21:18 · Open Word Bible
18Truly, truly, I tell you, when you were younger you fastened your own belt and went wherever you wished. But when you have grown old, you will stretch out your hands, and then someone else will fasten a belt on you and take you where you do not wish to go."
signifying) Such predictions are sometimes vouchsafed to those who excel in love and faithfulness. ... by what hind of death) John wrote his gospel before the death of Peter: and the event, in a few years after, corresponded to the prediction of the Lord recorded by John. Comp. ch. xii. 33 [referring to His own death ... he was about to glorify) It is chiefly by suffering, not merely by doing, that the saints glorify God. ... He saith) forthwith. ... follow Me) apart; by thyself: so as to hear what I have to do with thee alone; as also, that thou mayest undergo the suffering of the cross, ver. 18, 22, ch, xii. 36. [This saying of the Lord, throughout the whole career of Peter’s life, secured his alacrity in following ... This following implied not so much the similarity of Peter’s death by the cross to that of Christ, which had already been intimated, as the fact of the death of Peter being separated from that of the Lord by a not exceedingly long interval, when compared with the lengthened stay of John. ‘For there follows, What is that to thee? He had first of all said to the disciples, Follow Me (ch. 1. 43). The continuation of the beginning crowns the completion of Christianity.’ This especially was the mind of Ignatius, to follow so as to attain to Christ.
John 21:19 · Open Word Bible
19He said this to show by what kind of death Peter would glorify God. After saying this, He told him, "Follow Me."
turning about) He had therefore begun to follow. No prediction is given to James, who was about to die before Peter and John; from which very fact he might have inferred his speedy consummation. ... As before, at the last supper, so now also he was seeking the same place, and was leaning on Jesus’ breast almost with more familiarity than Peter liked. ... had leaned on the breast) An abbreviated phrase for, He had lain in the bosom of Jesus, and then in this position had turned towards His breast, ch. xiii. 23, 25. ... at the supper) that memorable supper on the day before the passover supper.
John 21:20 · Open Word Bible
20Peter turned around and saw the disciple whom Jesus loved following them, the same disciple who at the supper had leaned back against Jesus's chest and said, "Lord, who is it that is going to betray You?"
saith) He was supposing that he alone has been ordered now to follow the Saviour. ... what) We find it easier to devote ourselves to the Divine will, than to-lay aside curiosity respecting others, especially our equals, or those nearly so. ... saith) The Divine counsels respecting believers are more concealed than respecting the ungodly. Comp. ver. 20, as to the traitor. ... if) Never did the Lord give an unmixed repulse to His friends, however unseasonable their question might be. For which reason, not even in this instance does He repress Peter with unmixed sternness, but intimates, under the exterior repulse, something of kindness: even as also the ... he or him, which is relative, is more gentle than if He had used ... this person, which is demonstrative, in His reply to him. Therefore there is an ambiguity both weighty, and at the same time pleasing, in effect : For the conditional ... does not affirm, if Jesus’ words are to be taken of the full completion of His second advent: His words hold good, even absolutely, if they are taken of the first beginnings of His advent. And, indeed, the brethren felt that the if was not altogether, in its rigid strictness, employed by the Lord: although they ought not to have set it aside wholly : ver. 23. ... that He) So indicative of what was about to happen to Him is given to John, who was less forward to ask the question (for even on the former occasion he had not asked until he was prompted [by Peter] to do so [ch. xiii. 24], ver. 20), but who, notwithstanding, wished to ask it. More is revealed to those who are less disposed to pry curiously. ... I will) Implying the power of Jesus as to the life or death of His people: Rom. xiv. 9, “To this end Christ both died, and rose, and revived, that He might be Lord both of the dead and living.
John 21:21 · Open Word Bible
21When Peter saw him, he said to Jesus, "Lord, and what about him?"
tarry) ‘remain’ on earth. 1 Cor. xv. 6, “ The greater part remain unto this present.” On the contrary, the dead are termed ... “to await:” expectation or awaiting no doubt follows as the consequence of remaining: but the notion of remaining continues without sacrifice of truth.
John 21:22 · Open Word Bible
22Jesus said to him, "If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you? As for you, follow Me!"
This brings back the curiosity of Peter to order; but at the same time it much more intimates, that his course would be already ended, whilst John was still doing his work, and was subserving the advent of the Lord. The martyrdom of Peter was consummated several years before the destruction of Jerusalem: that destruction had the Lord’s advent subsequent to it. ... thow) A weighty and merciful command. ... follow Me) The future is contained in the Imperative: Give all thy attention to that which belongs to thee: leave to him (that disciple) what belongs to him. Similarly the Lord’s words concerning John, intimated not only what the Lord wishes to be done, but what is about to be.
the saying) See how much more trustworthy is the written letter than a saying. The saying, even among the brethren, was without any fraudulent intention, interpolated : the hand (writing) of the apostles, applies the remedy, and the benefit of it is preserved to us even to the present day. The patrons of traditions are themselves at war both with the ancient and new books of Scripture. ... brethren) viz. those Seven mentioned in ver. 2, and the remaining brethren of that age, or rather those who were living when John wrote. Otherwise there would have been no need to refute the error at so late a period [as when the apostle wrote this Gospel] : the error seems to be confirmed by the fact of the apostle’s continuing to live so long. They learned the appellation, Brethren, from ch, xx. 17. ... that disciple) This pronoun has the effect of amplifying (giving distinction or eminence to one). ... doth not die) They substitute this for different words, omitting ... and extending (straining) too much the antithesis between the following (‘ Follow’) and the remaining (‘tarry’). However they recognised the fact, that at the actual coming of the Lord, all mortality shall be abolished. This affords a specimen of the weakness of understanding which remained in the disciples before the coming of the Paraclete ; nay more, a specimen of the universal want of dexterity, on the part of men, in understanding the words of Christ, especially those in the Apocalypse, of which there is given in this place a contraction.
John 21:23 · Open Word Bible
23So the saying spread among the brothers and sisters that this disciple would not die. But Jesus had not told Peter that the disciple would not die; He had said, "If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you?"
and not) John carefully obviates the explanation, as foreign to the purpose and erroneous, lest an utterance should be attributed to Christ, which was not really His. For when John was dead, one thing might seem to have been foretold to him by the Lord, and a different thing to have come to pass. In the Divine words, all the points are to be precisely held fast ; and we must especially guard against making any addition to them: Rev. xxii. 18. [For ie a very slight change of the words, and such a change as may seem to be of no consequence, the genuine sense may be wrested.—V. g.] Such care did John and the other Evangelists employ in reporting the words of Christ. They have not reported all things in just so many and identically the same words; but yet altogether according to the mind (sentiment) of the Lord, so that they may be and ought to be regarded exactly the same as if they had employed just so many and identically the same words.
this) Therefore at that time, as yet the disciple was remaining, and his remaining showed the truth of the Lord’s words, after so many years had elapsed, and the power of His will [“If I will” ... He who was testifying) viz. in his words, as yet surviving. ... and we know) John himself may have prescribed this clause to the Church, which accordingly would, with no unwillingness, read it in public, and acknowledge it as obligatory with believing assent. But if the Church has added this, it does not derogate from the authority of the work, any more than that little verse which ... interwove with the Epistle to the Romans: or, if I may add this, than the little clause added to the Commentaries of ... concerning his death, and which was perhaps begun by himself and finished by a. friend.
John 21:24 · Open Word Bible
24This is the disciple who is testifying about these things and who has written them, and we know his testimony is true.
there are) The Present. They were present to the mind of John; and there is no doubt but that he was wont to narrate many such things in his conversations. ... other things also) The interests of Christianity suffer no loss in consequence, because some things which the apostles wrote are not extant in the present day : for not even is this prejudicial to it, that many of those things which Jesus did and said have not even been recorded. ... particularly) as concerns the facts and their several attendant circumstances. ... I think) By this word the amplification [the largeness of the statement as to the world not being able to contain the books] is softened down. The Singular number.shows that John wrote this verse. ... the world) John had a most exalted (august and grand) opinion of the multitude of Christ’s miracles.
John 21:25 · Open Word Bible
25Jesus did many other things as well. If each one were written down, I suppose that even the world itself could not hold all the books that would be written.