Logia

Matthew · Chapter 17 · Passages

The tax for God's house (Matthew 17:24–27)

24 When they arrived in Capernaum, the men who collected the temple tax came to Peter and said, "Your teacher pays the temple tax, does He not?" 25 "Yes, He does," Peter answered. When Peter came into the house, Jesus spoke to him before he could say anything. "Simon," He said, "tell me what you think. When the kings of the earth take tolls or taxes, who pays them? From their own sons, or from people outside their family?" 26 "From outsiders," Peter replied. Jesus said to him, "So the sons owe nothing. 27 Still, we do not want to give them a reason to take offense. So go down to the lake and throw in a hook. Take the first fish that comes up, open its mouth, and you will find a silver coin worth four days' wages. Take it and give it to them for Me and for you."

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

26 excerpts from 4 commentators on Matthew 17:24–27, from Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) to J. C. Ryle (1816–1900).

Two voices on The tax for God's house (Matthew 17:24–27)

Choose two:

What the church has said

Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.

What does Aquinas say about Matthew 17:24–27?

Thomas Aquinas

1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic · Catena Aurea: Commentary on the Four Gospels, Collected out of the Works of the Fathers. Vol. I: St. Matthew · 7 excerpts

  • Matthew 17:24 And when they were come to Capernaum, they that received tribute money came to Peter, and said, “Doth not your master pay tribute?”

    Gloss., non occ.: The disciples were exceeding sorrowful when they heard of the Lord’s passion, and therefore that none might ascribe His suffering to compulsion, and not to a voluntary submission, he adds an incident which instances Christ’s power, and…

  • Matthew 17:24

    Chrys.: What then does Peter say? “He saith, Yea.” To these then he said that He did pay, but to Christ he said not so, blushing perhaps to speak of such matters.

  • Matthew 17:25

    Gloss., ap. Anselm: Otherwise; Peter answered, Yea; meaning, yea, He does not pay. And Peter sought to acquaint the Lord that the Herodians had demanded tribute, but the Lord prevented him; as it follows, “And when he had entered into…

  • Matthew 17:26 Peter saith unto him, “Of strangers.” Jesus saith unto him, “Then are the children free.

    It follows, “But he said, From strangers; Jesus said unto him, Then are the children free.”

  • Matthew 17:27

    Jerome: Howsoever free then He was, yet seeing He had taken to Him lowliness of the flesh, He ought to fulfil all righteousness; whence it follows, “But that they should not be offended, go to the sea.”

  • Matthew 17:27

    Chrys.: Or He does not direct it to be paid out of that they had at hand, that He might shew that He was Lord also of the sea and the fish.

  • Matthew 17:27

    Origen: Mystically; In the field of comfort, (for so is Capernaum expounded,) He comforts each one of His disciples, and pronounces him to be a son and free, and gives him the power of taking the first fish, that after…

What does Calvin say about Matthew 17:24–27?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentary on a Harmony of the Evangelists, Matthew, Mark, and Luke: Matthew · 6 excerpts

  • Matthew 17:24 And when they came to Capernaum

    Matthew 17:24. And when they came to Capernaum. We must attend, first of all, to the design of this narrative; which is, that Christ, by paying tribute of his own accord, declared his subjection, as he had taken upon him…

  • Matthew 17:24 Doth not your Master pay?

    Doth not your Master pay? Some think that the collectors of the tribute intended to throw blame on Christ, as if he were claiming exemption from the common law. For my own part, as men of that class are insolent…

  • Matthew 17:25 He saith, Yes. Peter’s

    25. He saith, Yes. Peter’s reply contains a modest excuse to satisfy them: “he will pay,” says he; from which we infer that Christ had formerly been accustomed to pay, for Peter promises it as a thing about which there…

  • Matthew 17:25 What thinkest thou, Simon?

    What thinkest thou, Simon? In this Christ gave a proof of his Divinity, by showing that nothing was unknown to him. But what is the object of his discourse? Is it to exempt himself and his followers from subjection to…

  • Matthew 17:25

    The Pope has not less foolishly than successfully abused this passage to exempt his clergy from the laws; as if the shaving of the head made them sons of God, and exempted them from tributes and taxes. But nothing else…

  • Matthew 17:27 Throw a hook

    27. Throw a hook. Though I acknowledge that Christ had not always full coffers, yet I think that he was not compelled by poverty to give this order to Peter, but that he did so in order to prove by…

What does Henry say about Matthew 17:24–27?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume V (Matthew to John): Matthew · 8 excerpts

  • Matthew 17:24 Observe how it was demanded

    We have here an account of Christ's paying tribute.

  • Matthew 17:24

    Peter presently his word for his Master; "Yes, certainly; my Master pays tribute; it is his principle and practice; you need not fear moving it to him." (1.) He was made under the law (Gal. iv. 4); therefore under this…

  • Matthew 17:25 How it was disputed

    II. How it was disputed (v. 25), not with the collectors themselves, lest they should be irritated, but with Peter, that he might be satisfied in the reason why Christ paid tribute, and might not mistake about it. He brought…

  • Matthew 17:27 How it was paid, notwithstanding

    III. How it was paid, notwithstanding, v. 27.

  • Matthew 17:27 What course he took for the payment of this tax

    2. What course he took for the payment of this tax; he furnished himself with money for it out of the mouth of a fish (v. 27), wherein appears,

  • Matthew 17:27

    [2.] The fish came up, with money in the mouth of it, which represents to us the reward of obedience in obedience. What work we do at Christ's command brings its own pay along with it: In keeping God's commands,…

  • Matthew 17:27 The piece of money was just enough to pay the tax for Christ and Peter

    [3.] The piece of money was just enough to pay the tax for Christ and Peter. Thou shalt find a stater, the value of a Jewish shekel, which would pay the poll-tax for two, for it was half a shekel,…

  • Matthew 17:27 Observe, The evangelist records here the orders Christ gave to Peter, the warrant

    Lastly, Observe, The evangelist records here the orders Christ gave to Peter, the warrant; the effect is not particularly mentioned, but taken for granted, and justly; for, with Christ, saying and doing are the same thing.

What does Ryle say about Matthew 17:24–27?

J. C. Ryle

1816–1900 · Anglican (Evangelical) · Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: St. Matthew · 5 excerpts

  • Matthew 17:22–27

    These verses contain a circumstance in our Lord’s history which is not recorded by any of the evangelists excepting St. Matthew. A remarkable miracle is worked in order to provide payment of the tribute money required for the service of…

  • Matthew 17:22–27

    We ought to endeavor to make practical use of this truth. We should strive to live as in the Lord’s sight and, like Abraham, to “walk before” him ( Genesis 17:1 ). Let it be our daily aim to say…

  • Matthew 17:22–27

    Here is one among many proofs of the majesty and greatness of our Lord Jesus Christ. He only who first created could at his will command the obedience of all his creatures. “By him were all things created. - by…

  • Matthew 17:22–27

    Our Lord’s example in this case deserves the attention of all who profess and call themselves Christians. There is deep wisdom in those five words, “lest we should offend them.” They teach us plainly that there are matters in which…

  • Matthew 17:22–27

    Let us remember this passage as members of society. There may be usages and customs in the circle where our lot is cast, which to us as Christians are tiresome, useless and unprofitable: but are they matters of principle? Do…

Read Matthew 17 with all its commentary