Logia

Matthew · Chapter 17 · Passages

Elijah has already come (Matthew 17:9–13)

9 On the way down the mountain Jesus gave them this order: "Tell no one about the vision until the Son of Man has been raised from the dead." 10 So the disciples questioned Him: "If that is so, why do the scribes say that Elijah has to come first?" 11 He answered, "Elijah is indeed coming, and he will set all things right. 12 But I tell you that Elijah has come already. They did not recognize him, and they treated him however they pleased. They will make the Son of Man suffer in the same way." 13 The disciples then realized that He meant John the Baptist.

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

40 excerpts from 5 commentators on Matthew 17:9–13, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to J. C. Ryle (1816–1900).

Two voices on Elijah has already come (Matthew 17:9–13)

Choose two:

What the church has said

Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.

What does Chrysostom say about Matthew 17:9–13?

John Chrysostom

c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East) · Homilies on the Gospel of Saint Matthew · 5 excerpts

  • Matthew 17:10 Homily LVII. Matt. XVII. 10

    “And His disciples asked Him, saying, Why then say the Scribes that Elias must first come?”

  • Matthew 17:10

    In this sense Elias is come: but if thou wouldest seek the Tishbite, he is coming. Wherefore also He said, “Elias truly cometh, and shall restore all things.” All what things? Such as the Prophet Malachi spake of; for “I…

  • Matthew 17:12–13 Homily LVII. Matt. XVII. 10

    “But I say unto you, that Elias is come already, and they knew him not, but have done unto him whatsoever they listed. Likewise shall also the Son of Man suffer of them. Then they understood that He spake to…

  • Matthew 17:12–13

    “Likewise shall also the Son of Man suffer of them.” Seest thou how again He in due season reminds them of His passion, laying up for them great store of comfort from the passion of John. And not in this…

  • Matthew 17:12–13

    But should any one say, “Wherefore did He not even now raise up Elias and send him, witnessing as He doth so great good of his coming?” we should reply, that even as it was, while thinking Christ to be…

What does Aquinas say about Matthew 17:9–13?

Thomas Aquinas

1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic · Catena Aurea: Commentary on the Four Gospels, Collected out of the Works of the Fathers. Vol. I: St. Matthew · 6 excerpts

  • Matthew 17:9

    It follows; “And as they came down from the mount, Jesus charged them, saying, Tell no man this vision, until the Son of Man shall rise from the dead.” He will not be preached among the people, lest the marvel…

  • Matthew 17:10 And his disciples asked him, saying, “Why then say the Scribes that Elias must first come?”

    Jerome: It was a tradition of the Pharisees following the Prophet Malachi, that Elias should come before the coming of the Saviour, and bring back the heart of the fathers to the children, and the children to the fathers, and…

  • Matthew 17:11 And Jesus answered and said unto them, “Elias truly shall first come, and restore all things.

    Chrys., Hom., lvii: The disciples knew not of the coming of Elias out of the Scriptures; but the Scribes made it known to them; and this report was current among the ignorant multitude, as was that concerning Christ. Yet the…

  • Matthew 17:11

    Chrys.: But if there shall so much good arise out of the presence of Elias, why did He not send him at that time? We shall say, Because they then held Christ to be Elias, and yet believed not on…

  • Matthew 17:12

    Hilary: As he announced the Lord’s coming, so he was also to foreshew His passion by the example of his own suffering and wrong; whence it follows, “So also shall the Son of Man suffer of them.”

  • Matthew 17:13 Then the disciples understood that he spake unto them of John the Baptist.

    Raban.: From the mention of His own passion which the Lord had often foretold to them, and from that of His forerunner, which they beheld already accomplished, the disciples perceived that John was set forth to them under the name…

What does Calvin say about Matthew 17:9–13?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentary on a Harmony of the Evangelists, Matthew, Mark, and Luke: Matthew · 5 excerpts

  • Matthew 17:9 And as they were going down from the mountain

    Matthew 17:9. And as they were going down from the mountain. We have said that the time for making known the vision was not yet fully come; and, indeed, the disciples would not have believed it, if Christ had not…

  • Matthew 17:10 And his disciples asked him, saying

    10. And his disciples asked him, saying. No sooner is the resurrection mentioned than the disciples imagine that the reign of Christ is commenced; for they explain this word to mean that the world would acknowledge him to be the…

  • Matthew 17:10 Why do the scribes say that Elijah must come first?

    Why do the scribes say that Elijah must come first? The gross mistakes which they committed as to the person of Elijah have been pointed out on two or three occasions. Perhaps, too, they cunningly and wickedly endeavored to lessen…

  • Matthew 17:11 Elijah indeed will come first

    11. Elijah indeed will come first. We have stated elsewhere the origin of that error which prevailed among the Jews. As John the Baptist was to resemble Elijah by restoring the fallen condition of the Church, the prophet Malachi (4:5,6)…

  • Matthew 17:11 And will restore all things

    And will restore all things. This does not mean that John the Baptist restored them perfectly, but that he conveyed and handed them over to Christ, who would complete the work which he had begun. Now as the scribes had…

What does Henry say about Matthew 17:9–13?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume V (Matthew to John): Matthew · 18 excerpts

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    We have here the story of Christ's transfiguration; he had said that the Son of man should shortly come in his kingdom, with which promise all the three evangelists industriously connect this story; as if Christ's transfiguration were intended for…

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    Moses and Elias were now with him; the law and the prophets; hitherto it was said, Hear them, Luke xvi. 29. The disciples were ready to equal them with Christ, when they must have tabernacles for them as well as…

  • Matthew 17:1–13 The disciples fell on their faces, and were sore afraid

    IV. The fright which the disciples were put into by this voice, and the encouragement Christ gave them.

  • Matthew 17:1–13 Christ graciously raised them up with abundance of tenderness

    2. Christ graciously raised them up with abundance of tenderness. Note, The glories and advancements of our Lord Jesus do not at all lessen his regard to, and concern for, his people that are compassed about with infirmity. It is…

  • Matthew 17:1–13 The great pleasure and satisfaction that the disciples took in the sight of Christ's glory

    IV. The great pleasure and satisfaction that the disciples took in the sight of Christ's glory. Peter, as usual, spoke for the rest; Lord, it is good for us to be here. Peter here expresses,

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    (1.) Here was a zeal for this converse with heavenly things, a laudable complacency in the sight they had of Christ's glory. Note, Those that by faith behold the beauty of the Lord in his house, cannot but desire to…

  • Matthew 17:1–13 Yet in this zeal he betrayed a great deal of weakness and ignorance

    (2.) Yet in this zeal he betrayed a great deal of weakness and ignorance. What need had Moses and Elias of tabernacles? They belonged to that blessed world, where they hunger no more, nor doth the sun light upon them.…

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    V. The glorious testimony which God the Father gave to our Lord Jesus, in which he received from him honour and glory (2 Pet. i. 17), when there came this voice from the excellent glory. This was like proclaiming the…

  • Matthew 17:1–13 How it came, and in what manner it was introduced

    Now concerning this testimony from heaven to Christ, observe.

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    (4.) There came a voice out of the cloud, and it was the voice of God, who now, as of old, spake in the cloudy pillar, Ps. xcix. 7. Here was no thunder, or lightning, or voice of a trumpet,…

  • Matthew 17:1–13 What this testimony from heaven was

    2. What this testimony from heaven was; This is my beloved Son, hear ye him. Here we have,

  • Matthew 17:1–13 The great gospel duty required, and it is the condition of our benefit by Christ

    (2.) The great gospel duty required, and it is the condition of our benefit by Christ; Hear ye him. God is well pleased with none in Christ but those that hear him. It is not enough to give him the…

  • Matthew 17:9–13 The discourse between Christ and his disciples as they came down from the mountain

    VIII. The discourse between Christ and his disciples as they came down from the mountain, v. 9-13.

  • Matthew 17:9

    Here is, (1.) The charge that Christ gave the disciples to keep the vision very private for the present (v. 9); Tell it to no man till the Son of man is risen. If they had proclaimed it, the credibility…

  • Matthew 17:10 An objection which the disciples made against something Christ had said

    (2.) An objection which the disciples made against something Christ had said (v. 10); "Why then say the scribes that Elias must first come? If Elias make so short a stay, and is gone so suddenly, and we must say…

  • Matthew 17:11 The solving of this objection

    (3.) The solving of this objection. Ask, and it shall be given, ask instruction, and it shall be given.

  • Matthew 17:12 He asserts the accomplishment

    [2.] He asserts the accomplishment. The scribes say true, that Elias is come, v. 12. Note, God's promises are often fulfilled, and men perceive it not, but enquire, Where is the promise? when it is already performed. Elias is come,…

  • Matthew 17:13 The disciples' satisfaction in Christ's reply to their objection

    (4.) The disciples' satisfaction in Christ's reply to their objection (v. 13); They understood that he spake unto them of John the Baptist. He did not name John, but gives them such a description of him as would put them…

What does Ryle say about Matthew 17:9–13?

J. C. Ryle

1816–1900 · Anglican (Evangelical) · Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: St. Matthew · 6 excerpts

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    These verses contain one of the most remarkable events in our Lord’s earthly ministry, the event commonly called the transfiguration. The order in which it is recorded is beautiful and instructive. The latter part of the last chapter showed us…

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    There can be little question that this was one main object of this wonderful vision. It was meant to encourage the disciples by giving them a glimpse of good things yet to come. That face “shining as the sun” and…

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    It is good for us to have the coming glory of Christ and his people deeply impressed on our minds. We are sadly apt to forget it. There are few visible indications of it in the world: “We see not…

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    Let us lay firm hold on this part of the vision. It deserves close attention. We must all feel, if we ever think at all, that the state of the dead is a wonderful and mysterious subject. One after another…

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    This is a point which is brought out strongly by the voice from heaven which the disciples heard. Peter, bewildered by the heavenly vision and not knowing what to say, proposed to build three tabernacles, one for Christ, one for…

  • Matthew 17:1–13

    Let us see in these words a striking lesson to the whole church of Christ. There is a constant tendency in human nature to “hear man.” Bishops, priests, deacons, popes, cardinals, councils, presbyterian preachers and independent ministers are continually exalted…

Read Matthew 17 with all its commentary